An Analysis of the Incentive Mechanism at the Private Universities for Teachers’ Job Satisfaction in Easter China: Taking H University as a Case

Fang Chen, Marlon Rael AstilleroAdvances 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

This research selects the teachers of H private university as the research object. Based on Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs Theory, this research investigates the relevant incentive effects from five aspects: salary and welfare guarantee, sense of belonging, training opportunity and promotion system, performance appraisal system, working environment, and personalized spiritual incentive. This study adopts the method of quantitative investigation. The questionnaire was used as a data collection tool. The statistical data used in the data collection are descriptive analysis, F-test, one-way ANOVA, and correlation analysis. The research shows that the overall satisfaction of teachers' incentive mechanism in H private university is low, and the existing incentive mechanism can not meet the needs of teachers. The better the salary and welfare, the higher the sense of belonging, the fairer the training opportunities, the more attractive the promotion system, the more perfect the performance appraisal system, and the higher the teachers' job satisfaction.

Introduction

Private higher education in China has seen explosive growth, accounting for over 34% of undergraduate institutions as of 2019. However, these institutions often face a "recognition deficit" compared to public universities, which lack the same level of prestige and national policy support. This disparity frequently results in high teacher turnover and low job satisfaction. This paper addresses the critical human resources challenge of moving beyond "single incentive mechanisms"—often limited to basic salary—to create a holistic environment capable of retaining high-quality academic talent. By focusing on "H University" in Qingdao, this study explores the disconnect between faculty needs and institutional offerings.

Methodology and Conceptual Framework

The research utilizes a quantitative, cross-sectional survey design grounded in Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs Theory. The conceptual framework categorizes incentives into five primary dimensions corresponding to different levels of human needs:

  1. Salary and welfare guarantee (Physiological/Safety needs)
  2. Sense of belonging (Social needs)
  3. Training and promotion (Esteem needs)
  4. Performance appraisal (Esteem/Safety needs)
  5. Working environment and spiritual incentives (Self-actualization)
Conceptual framework of the study linking incentive factors to job satisfaction

To ensure technical rigor, the researchers validated the instrument using Cronbach’s Alpha (0.898) and the KMO test (0.915). Data analysis involved descriptive statistics, F-tests, and one-way ANOVA to compare demographic groups, alongside Pearson correlation analysis to determine the strength of relationships between variables.

Data and Participant Profile

The study's primary dataset was generated from the faculty of H University, which has a total population of 682 full-time members. Out of 300 questionnaires distributed, 284 valid responses were recovered (94.7% effective rate).

Demographic profile of the survey respondents (N=284)

As shown in the demographic breakdown, the sample was predominantly female (76.06%) and largely composed of mid-career professionals, with 55.28% aged between 30–40. A significant majority (71.13%) held Master’s degrees, and most respondents had between 1 and 10 years of teaching experience.

Key Findings and Discussion

The Satisfaction Gap

The analysis revealed a "satisfaction midpoint crisis." On a 5-point Likert scale, mean satisfaction scores for salary, belonging, training, and performance appraisal were all below 3.0. This indicates widespread dissatisfaction across the most critical career pillars. Interestingly, the only dimension to score above 3.0 was "working environment and spiritual incentive." However, the authors identified a paradox: while teachers appreciated the environment, there was a significant negative relationship suggesting that spiritual incentives cannot compensate for inadequate pay or lack of career progression.

Correlation Analysis

The study found powerful positive correlations between job satisfaction and four key incentive dimensions:

  • Salary/Welfare: $r = 0.971$
  • Training/Promotion: $r = 0.966$
  • Sense of Belonging: $r = 0.954$
  • Performance Appraisal: $r = 0.916$

The data highlights a massive misalignment in institutional priorities: "Salary treatment and welfare security" was ranked as the most important factor by teachers but received the lowest satisfaction score (2.473).

Demographic Divergence

Satisfaction levels were not uniform across the faculty. Female teachers and older, more experienced faculty reported higher satisfaction than their younger, male counterparts. This suggests that the "backbone" of the university—young and middle-aged teachers—is the demographic most at risk of turnover.

Conclusion

The incentive mechanism at H University currently fails to meet the basic expectations of its faculty. For knowledge workers in private higher education, the pathway to growth (training and promotion) is nearly as vital as the paycheck itself. To improve retention, institutions must move toward a more balanced incentive system that addresses both physiological and esteem needs.

Future research should expand this scope to multiple private institutions across different regions of China and utilize Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to further clarify the causal pathways between these incentive variables.

Summary updated

Abstract

This research selects the teachers of H private university as the research object.Based on Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs Theory, this research investigates the relevant incentive effects from five aspects: salary and welfare guarantee, sense of belonging, training opportunity and promotion system, performance appraisal system, working environment, and personalized spiritual incentive.This study adopts the method of quantitative investigation.The questionnaire was used as a data collection tool.The statistical data used in the data collection are descriptive analysis, F-test, one-way ANOVA, and correlation analysis.The research shows that the overall satisfaction of teachers' incentive mechanism in H private university is low, and the existing incentive mechanism can not meet the needs of teachers.The better the salary and welfare, the higher the sense of belonging, the fairer the training opportunities, the more attractive the promotion system, the more perfect the performance appraisal system, and the higher the teachers' job satisfaction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2023analysis,
  author = {Fang Chen and Marlon Rael Astillero},
  title = {{An Analysis of the Incentive Mechanism at the Private Universities for Teachers’ Job Satisfaction in Easter China: Taking H University as a Case}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.2991/978-2-38476-040-4\_18},
}
Figure