Sufficiently Accurate Model Learning

Clark Zhang, Arbaaz Khan, Santiago Paternain, Alejandro Ribeiro

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Sufficiently Accurate" model learning framework that explicitly enforces constraints on prediction errors within specific regions of the state-space. This approach leads to more predictable model errors, enabling better performance for downstream control and planning algorithms, as demonstrated on a simulated ball-bouncing task.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing effective control and planning algorithms for robots hinges on having accurate models of their dynamics. However, real-world robots and their environments are complex and dynamic, making it challenging to obtain precise physical models. Traditional data-driven model learning methods often aim for overall accuracy but can produce unpredictable errors in critical state-space regions, hindering the performance of control systems. This paper addresses the need for models that are not just generally accurate, but sufficiently accurate in ways that are beneficial for control, by allowing for targeted error control.

Methods

The core contribution is a constrained optimization formulation for model learning. Instead of simply minimizing the average prediction error (as in standard approaches), the authors propose to minimize a loss function while simultaneously enforcing constraints on the error within predefined subsets of the state-action space. This is achieved by introducing indicator functions and Lagrange multipliers, leading to a primal-dual optimization problem.

The paper then proposes a primal-dual algorithm to solve this constrained optimization problem. This iterative method updates both the model parameters (primal variables) and the Lagrange multipliers (dual variables) to find an optimal solution. The authors also theoretically demonstrate that this formulation leads to a small duality gap, justifying the use of the primal-dual approach.

For control, the learned "Sufficiently Accurate" model can be integrated into optimization-based controllers. The paper outlines how to formulate a control problem as an optimization problem that uses the learned model to predict future states, subject to task-specific constraints.

Datasets

The paper uses a simulated ball-paddle system for experiments. The dataset is generated by running a controller with a faulty analytic model and collecting state-action-next state tuples. This dataset is used for both training and evaluating the learned models. No new benchmark datasets are introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Sufficiently Accurate" is better than "Perfectly Accurate" for Control: The key insight is that for control and planning, the distribution of model errors matters more than just the overall average error. By constraining errors in critical regions, we can achieve better downstream performance.
  • Targeted Error Control: The framework allows for trading off model accuracy across different parts of the state space. For example, it might be more important to accurately predict the ball's trajectory when it's moving fast than when it's nearly stationary.
  • Smoother Gradients for Controllers: By enforcing constraints and potentially smoothing error characteristics, the learned models can provide more predictable and less noisy gradients, which are crucial for gradient-based optimization in controllers and planners.
  • Primal-Dual for Constrained Optimization: The use of primal-dual methods is well-motivated by the theoretical guarantees of a small duality gap, making it an effective way to solve the constrained model learning problem.

Key Results

  • Reduced Failure Rate: In experiments with a simulated ball-bouncing task, controllers using models trained with the "Sufficiently Accurate" formulation showed a significantly lower failure rate (0.8% vs. 20.8% for the unconstrained model).
  • Lower Mean Error: The constrained models also achieved a lower mean position error (0.2124 vs. 0.3136 for the unconstrained full model).
  • Improved Residual Learning: When learning a residual model on top of a faulty analytic model, the constrained approach led to much better performance, with no failures and a lower mean error (0.156 vs. 0.164 for the unconstrained residual model).
  • Better Error Distribution: Visualizations show that the constrained model error is more evenly distributed and less prone to large errors in critical regions compared to the unconstrained model.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: Computing derivatives of neural network models can be computationally expensive, potentially limiting real-time deployment for very fast control loops. The authors suggest training a faster policy by imitating the model-based solution as a potential workaround.
  • Manual Constraint Tuning: The choice of error bounds ($\epsilon$) for the constraints is currently determined manually. Future work could explore automated methods for selecting these constraints.
  • Generalization to Real Robots: While the simulation demonstrates the concept, testing the framework on real robotic systems to handle various error types is a crucial next step.
  • Exploring Other Constraints and Controllers: Investigating different types of constraints and how various controllers and planners interact with these "Sufficiently Accurate" models is also suggested for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Modeling how a robot interacts with the environment around it is an important prerequisite for designing control and planning algorithms. In fact, the performance of controllers and planners is highly dependent on the quality of the model. One popular approach is to learn data driven models in order to compensate for inaccurate physical measurements and to adapt to systems that evolve over time. In this paper, we investigate a method to regularize model learning techniques to provide better error characteristics for traditional control and planning algorithms. This work proposes learning "Sufficiently Accurate" models of dynamics using a primal-dual method that can explicitly enforce constraints on the error in pre-defined parts of the state-space. The result of this method is that the error characteristics of the learned model is more predictable and can be better utilized by planning and control algorithms. The characteristics of Sufficiently Accurate models are analyzed through experiments on a simulated ball paddle system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2020sufficiently,
  author = {Clark Zhang and Arbaaz Khan and Santiago Paternain and Alejandro Ribeiro},
  title = {{Sufficiently Accurate Model Learning}},
  booktitle = {IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/icra40945.2020.9197502},
}
Figure