Sufficiently Accurate Model Learning for Planning

Clark Zhang, Santiago Paternain, Alejandro RibeiroarXiv 2021 · arXiv

Introduction

In robotics and control, learning a "dynamics model"—a mathematical description of a system's motion—is a fundamental task. Traditional approaches typically aim for "Uniformly Accurate" models by minimizing average error across all available data. However, this approach has two major drawbacks:

  1. Finite Capacity: Neural networks and other models have limited expressive power. Forcing accuracy everywhere can degrade performance in critical regions.
  2. Task Asymmetry: Not all errors are equal. A small prediction error during a high-altitude cruise is negligible, but the same error during a precision landing can be catastrophic.

This paper introduces Sufficiently Accurate Model Learning, a framework that allows designers to prioritize high accuracy in task-critical regions while accepting "good enough" performance elsewhere.

Methodology: Primal-Dual Constrained Learning

The core innovation is transforming model learning into a constrained optimization problem. Instead of a simple global loss, the user defines specific regions of the state-action space and sets hard constraints on the allowable error within them. This allows for "Selective Accuracy" in critical zones or "Normalized Objectives" where error is scaled by state magnitude.

To solve this, the authors employ a Stochastic Primal-Dual Algorithm. This method iterates between updating model parameters (primal step) and updating Lagrange multipliers (dual step). These multipliers act as dynamic weights, increasing the penalty whenever a constraint is violated to ensure the model focuses its resources correctly.

The Primal-Dual training process shows how the dual variable grows to penalize the loss until constraints are satisfied.

The authors also provide a theoretical guarantee (Theorem 1), proving that the gap between the empirical solution and the true optimal solution vanishes as data and model capacity increase.

Experimental Results

The framework was evaluated on three systems: a double integrator with friction, a ball bouncing task, and a 3D quadrotor landing.

In the double integrator experiment, the "Sufficiently Accurate" model focused its accuracy near the goal. While it had higher errors far from the origin, it achieved a lower Model Predictive Control (MPC) cost (4.73 vs 5.51) and eliminated oscillations near the target.

Comparison of velocity prediction errors. The top row (Sufficiently Accurate) shows much lower error near the center compared to the bottom row (Uniformly Accurate).

In the ball bouncing task, the failure rate was reduced from 20.8% to just 0.8%. For the quadrotor, the model successfully captured complex "ground effect" disturbances, leading to more precise and faster landings than the standard approach.

Conclusion

By using constraints to "steer" model expressivity, this framework allows engineering intuition to be encoded as a mathematical safety rail. A "Sufficiently Accurate" model may have higher total error, but it performs better in practice because its errors are strategically located where they do not impact the specific task. Future work will explore automatically identifying critical regions and applying the method to non-parametric models like Gaussian Processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Data driven models of dynamical systems help planners and controllers to provide more precise and accurate motions. Most model learning algorithms will try to minimize a loss function between the observed data and the model's predictions. This can be improved using prior knowledge about the task at hand, which can be encoded in the form of constraints. This turns the unconstrained model learning problem into a constrained one. These constraints allow models with finite capacity to focus their expressive power on important aspects of the system. This can lead to models that are better suited for certain tasks. This paper introduces the constrained Sufficiently Accurate model learning approach, provides examples of such problems, and presents a theorem on how close some approximate solutions can be. The approximate solution quality will depend on the function parameterization, loss and constraint function smoothness, and the number of samples in model learning.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2021sufficiently,
  author = {Clark Zhang and Santiago Paternain and Alejandro Ribeiro},
  title = {{Sufficiently Accurate Model Learning for Planning}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2102.06099},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2102.06099},
}
Figure