Abstract
We are motivated by the problem of learning policies for robotic systems with rich sensory inputs (e.g., vision) in a manner that allows us to guarantee generalization to environments unseen during training. We provide a framework for providing such generalization guarantees by leveraging a finite dataset of real-world environments in combination with a (potentially inaccurate) generative model of environments. The key idea behind our approach is to utilize the generative model in order to implicitly specify a prior over policies. This prior is updated using the real-world dataset of environments by minimizing an upper bound on the expected cost across novel environments derived via Probably Approximately Correct (PAC)-Bayes generalization theory. We demonstrate our approach on two simulated systems with nonlinear/hybrid dynamics and rich sensing modalities: (i) quadrotor navigation with an onboard vision sensor, and (ii) grasping objects using a depth sensor. Comparisons with prior work demonstrate the ability of our approach to obtain stronger generalization guarantees by utilizing generative models. We also present hardware experiments for validating our bounds for the grasping task.
Introduction
Deep learning has revolutionized robotic perception, yet the challenge of generalization remains a significant hurdle. A robot trained in a controlled laboratory setting often fails when deployed in novel, real-world environments. For safety-critical applications, empirical success is insufficient; we require formal guarantees of performance. This research introduces a framework that leverages generative models to provide significantly tighter generalization guarantees by combining synthetic data with limited real-world observations.
The Challenge of Generalization Guarantees
Standard approaches to providing formal guarantees often rely on Probably Approximately Correct (PAC)-Bayes theory. This mathematical framework provides an upper bound on the expected failure rate in unseen environments. However, a major limitation of PAC-Bayes is its dependence on a "prior"—an initial distribution over policies chosen before seeing any real-world data.
If the prior is poorly chosen, the resulting performance bound is often "vacuous" (e.g., guaranteeing a failure rate of less than 100%). In high-dimensional spaces like neural network weights, finding an informative prior is notoriously difficult. This paper addresses this by using generative models to ground the prior in environmental context.
Methodology: Generative Models as Priors
The authors propose a novel approach to constructing informative priors by utilizing generative models of environments.
The framework consists of four key steps:
- Generative Prior Specification: Instead of guessing network weights, the researchers use a generative model to produce a large volume of synthetic environments.
- Implicit Parameterization: Policies are trained on these synthetic environments using deterministic algorithms like Evolutionary Strategies. This process implicitly defines a prior distribution over policies based on the generative model's output.
- PAC-Bayes Refinement: A small dataset of real-world environments is used to update this prior into a "posterior" distribution. This is achieved by solving a convex optimization problem that minimizes an upper bound on the expected cost across novel environments.
- Certified Performance: The result is a policy distribution with a mathematically rigorous bound on its performance in the true distribution of environments.
Experimental Evaluation
The approach was evaluated on two challenging tasks involving rich sensory inputs:
Vision-based Drone Navigation
In a simulated PyBullet environment, a drone must navigate tunnels filled with cylindrical obstacles. The "real" world contains a fixed number of obstacles, while the generative model varies this number to test the framework's robustness to inaccurate priors.
Robotic Grasping
This task involved grasping diverse objects using depth sensing. In simulation, 500 unique mug models from the ShapeNet dataset served as the "real" world, while a simplified model generating basic hollow cylinders was used as the prior. The system was further validated on hardware using a Franka Panda arm with 10 physical mugs of varying shapes and sizes.
Key Results
The proposed method consistently yielded tighter generalization bounds than baseline approaches that rely solely on splitting real-world data.
- Drone Navigation: The framework achieved a PAC-Bayes bound of 16.76% expected cost, guaranteeing success in at least 83.24% of novel environments. This significantly outperformed the baseline bound of ~21.5%.
- Grasping Success: In simulation, the method provided a theoretical success guarantee of 94.6%.
- Sim-to-Real Validation: Hardware experiments confirmed the theoretical bounds. The Franka Panda arm achieved a 96.67% success rate (29/30 successful grasps) on physical mugs, demonstrating that the PAC-Bayes guarantees hold in real-world deployment.
Discussion and Future Work
A key insight of this work is that generative models do not need to be perfect to be useful. Even a simplified prior (e.g., treating complex mugs as simple cylinders) allows the PAC-Bayes framework to extract useful information while the real-world data corrects for inaccuracies.
Future research directions include utilizing more advanced generative models like GANs or VAEs, and directly optimizing the generative model parameters within the PAC-Bayes framework. By bridging the gap between synthetic data and formal theory, this framework provides a robust path toward deploying learning-based robotic systems with high-confidence performance guarantees.
Summary updated