Stronger Generalization Guarantees for Robot Learning by Combining Generative Models and Real-World Data

Abhinav Agarwal, Sushant Veer, Allen Z. Ren, Anirudha Majumdar

This paper, "Stronger Generalization Guarantees for Robot Learning by Combining Generative Models and Real-World Data," presents a clever way to give robots "formal guarantees" that they will perform well in new, unseen environments. By combining plentiful (but potentially inaccurate) synthetic data from generative models with scarce (but accurate) real-world data, the authors provide a framework that yields significantly tighter performance bounds than previous methods.

TL;DR

The researchers use generative models to create a "prior" for robot behavior, which is then refined using a small amount of real-world data through PAC-Bayes generalization theory. This approach allows them to provide formal, high-confidence guarantees on a robot's success rate in novel environments, outperforming existing methods in both drone navigation and robotic grasping tasks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Deep learning has made robots much better at processing complex sensory inputs like vision. However, these robots often struggle to generalize—they might work perfectly in the lab but fail when they encounter a slightly different mug or a new obstacle course.

For safety-critical systems (like a drone flying near people), we need more than just a "feeling" that it will work; we want a formal guarantee. The standard tool for this is PAC-Bayes (Probably Approximately Correct - Bayes) theory, which provides a mathematical upper bound on the expected failure rate in new environments.

The catch? PAC-Bayes requires a "prior" (an initial guess at a good policy) before seeing any real-world data. If your prior is bad, your final guarantee will be "vacuous"—meaning the math might say "we guarantee you'll fail less than 100% of the time," which is useless. Finding a good prior for high-dimensional neural networks is notoriously difficult.

Methods

The authors introduce a novel way to build this prior:

  1. Generative Models as Priors: Instead of guessing neural network weights, they use a generative model (which can be a simple hand-crafted rule or a trained model) to produce thousands of synthetic environments.
  2. Implicit Parameterization: They use a deterministic algorithm (like Evolutionary Strategies) to train policies on these synthetic environments. This "implicitly" defines a prior distribution over policies based on the generative model's output.
  3. PAC-Bayes Optimization: They then take a small dataset of real-world environments and use it to update this prior into a "posterior" distribution. They solve a convex optimization problem to find the best balance: staying close to the generative prior while performing well on the real data.
  4. The Result: A policy distribution with a mathematically certified bound on its performance in the "true" distribution of environments.

Datasets

The paper evaluates the approach on two distinct tasks:

  • Vision-based Drone Navigation: Simulated in PyBullet. The "real" world consists of tunnels with 23 cylindrical obstacles. The generative model creates similar tunnels but varies the number of obstacles to test how the system handles "inaccurate" priors.
  • Robotic Grasping:
    • Simulation: Used 500 unique mug models from the ShapeNet dataset as a proxy for the real world.
  • Generative Model: A simple model that generates basic hollow cylinders (much simpler than real mugs).
  • Hardware: Validated using a Franka Panda arm and a set of 10 physical mugs with diverse shapes and sizes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Generative Models Don't Need to Be Perfect: One of the most powerful insights is that the generative model (the prior) can be "wrong" or simplified (e.g., treating all mugs as cylinders). The PAC-Bayes framework is robust enough to use the useful parts of the prior while letting the real-world data correct the inaccuracies.
  • Tighter Bounds with Less Data: By starting with a generative prior, the researchers obtained much "stronger" (lower) bounds on failure rates than previous methods that relied on splitting the real-world data to create a prior.
  • Closing the Sim-to-Real Loop: The framework provides a theoretical bridge. If the math says the robot has a 95% success rate in simulation, the authors show that this actually holds up when you put the robot in front of a physical table with real mugs.

Key Results

  • Drone Navigation: The authors achieved a PAC-Bayes bound of 16.76% expected cost. This means they can formally guarantee the drone will successfully navigate at least 83.24% of novel real-world environments. This bound was significantly tighter than the baseline method (which gave a ~21.5% bound).
  • Grasping: In simulation, they achieved a theoretical success guarantee of 94.6%.
  • Hardware Validation: When they moved to the real Franka Panda arm with 10 different mugs, the robot achieved a 96.67% success rate (29 out of 30 successful grasps), successfully validating the theoretical bound.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hand-Crafted Models: For the grasping task, the generative model was a simple hand-crafted distribution of cylinders. The authors suggest that using state-of-the-art generative models (like GANs or VAEs) could lead to even stronger priors.
  • Discrete vs. Continuous: The current optimization uses a finite number of sampled synthetic datasets. Future work could involve directly optimizing the generative model itself within the PAC-Bayes framework.
  • Hardware Complexity: While grasping was tested on hardware, the high-speed drone navigation was only tested in simulation. Implementing the vision-based navigation on a physical UAV remains a future milestone.

Summary updated

Abstract

We are motivated by the problem of learning policies for robotic systems with rich sensory inputs (e.g., vision) in a manner that allows us to guarantee generalization to environments unseen during training. We provide a framework for providing such generalization guarantees by leveraging a finite dataset of real-world environments in combination with a (potentially inaccurate) generative model of environments. The key idea behind our approach is to utilize the generative model in order to implicitly specify a prior over policies. This prior is updated using the real-world dataset of environments by minimizing an upper bound on the expected cost across novel environments derived via Probably Approximately Correct (PAC)-Bayes generalization theory. We demonstrate our approach on two simulated systems with nonlinear/hybrid dynamics and rich sensing modalities: (i) quadrotor navigation with an onboard vision sensor, and (ii) grasping objects using a depth sensor. Comparisons with prior work demonstrate the ability of our approach to obtain stronger generalization guarantees by utilizing generative models. We also present hardware experiments for validating our bounds for the grasping task.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{agarwal2022stronger,
  author = {Abhinav Agarwal and Sushant Veer and Allen Z. Ren and Anirudha Majumdar},
  title = {{Stronger Generalization Guarantees for Robot Learning by Combining Generative Models and Real-World Data}},
  booktitle = {IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Jja6jfeD9Rs},
}

Loading related content...

Figure