Apps, Places and People: strategies, limitations and trade-offs in the physical and digital worlds

Marco De Nadai, Ângelo Cardoso, Antonio Lima, Bruno Lepri, Nuria Oliver

Abstract

Human behavior is often governed by cognitive constraints that limit the size of social circles and the number of physical locations frequented. This study investigates whether these limitations extend to the digital realm, specifically mobile application usage. Analyzing a dataset of 400,000 individuals, we find that humans exhibit a "conserved capacity" for apps, maintaining a stable repertoire even as they explore new ones. Contrary to the "couch potato" hypothesis, high digital activity correlates with high physical mobility, suggesting that smartphones complement rather than replace physical exploration.

Introduction

Social scientists have long observed that human cognition imposes a "ceiling" on our social and physical lives—concepts like Dunbar’s Number suggest we can only maintain a finite number of meaningful relationships and "favorite" places. With the digital economy offering millions of apps, a critical question arises: Does the digital world break these cognitive barriers, or are we still bound by the same mental limits? Furthermore, does increased digital engagement come at the cost of physical mobility?

Methods

The researchers analyzed pseudonymized data from 400,000 European users over six months. Two primary metrics were defined: Activity Space (physical locations visited at least twice) and App Space (mobile apps used at least twice). To determine if capacity is an inherent behavioral trait or merely a result of time constraints, the team used local and global randomization of usage data. Additionally, a Random Forest Classifier was employed to test if digital behavior (e.g., being a "Keeper" or "Explorer") could predict physical mobility strategies.

Results

Usage Distribution and Exploration

App usage and location visits both follow a truncated power law, with time heavily concentrated on a few top items. Surprisingly, the rate of exploration is higher in the physical world than in the digital one. While a "mobility explorer" might find a new favorite spot every 17 weeks, an "app explorer" adopts a new app only every 28 weeks.

Figure 2: Frequency distributions of app usage (A) and mobility (B) follow similar power-law patterns. Panel (C) shows that the cumulative exploration of new locations outpaces the adoption of new apps over time.

The "One-In, One-Out" Rule

The study found that 97.3% of users exhibit a stable capacity for both apps and locations. When a user adopts a new favorite app, an existing one is typically dropped from their regular rotation, maintaining a repertoire of approximately 27 apps. This "conserved capacity" suggests that the limits on our digital lives are as rigid as those in our physical ones.

Figure 4: Density plots (A, B) show a strong balance between added and removed items in both domains. Panels (C, D) illustrate that the vast majority of users maintain a stable average gain near zero, confirming the conserved capacity hypothesis.

Age and Cross-Domain Correlation

App capacity peaks in the early 20s and declines monotonically with age. Mobility follows a more complex trajectory, peaking later (around age 28) and dropping sharply after age 56. Crucially, the data refutes the "zero-sum game" hypothesis; there is a positive correlation between app usage and mobility, indicating that active individuals tend to be prolific in both domains.

Discussion and Limitations

While the study provides strong evidence for conserved capacity, it is limited by its cross-sectional nature, which cannot distinguish between aging effects and generational differences. The data is also specific to Android users and lacks qualitative insights into why specific apps or locations are abandoned. Future research should explore whether these behavioral profiles are linked to stable personality traits across life domains.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cognition has been found to constrain several aspects of human behaviour, such as the number of friends and the number of favourite places a person keeps stable over time. This limitation has been empirically defined in the physical and social spaces. But do people exhibit similar constraints in the digital space? We address this question through the analysis of pseudonymised mobility and mobile application (app) usage data of 400,000 individuals in a European country for six months. Despite the enormous heterogeneity of apps usage, we find that individuals exhibit a conserved capacity that limits the number of applications they regularly use. Moreover, we find that this capacity steadily decreases with age, as does the capacity in the physical space but with more complex dynamics. Even though people might have the same capacity, applications get added and removed over time. In this respect, we identify two profiles of individuals: app keepers and explorers, which differ in their stable (keepers) vs exploratory (explorers) behaviour regarding their use of mobile applications. Finally, we show that the capacity of applications predicts mobility capacity and vice-versa. By contrast, the behaviour of keepers and explorers may considerably vary across the two domains. Our empirical findings provide an intriguing picture linking human behaviour in the physical and digital worlds which bridges research studies from Computer Science, Social Physics and Computational Social Sciences.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nadai2019apps,
  author = {Marco De Nadai and Ângelo Cardoso and Antonio Lima and Bruno Lepri and Nuria Oliver},
  title = {{Apps, Places and People: strategies, limitations and trade-offs in the physical and digital worlds}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-47493-x},
}
Figure