Strategic Prompt Pricing for AIGC Services: A User-Centric Approach

Xiang Li, Bing Luo, Jianwei Huang, Yuan Luo

Introduction

As Generative AI (GAI) services like Poe and Monica proliferate, platforms face a critical challenge: how to price access to diverse models effectively. Traditional pricing models often rely on operational costs or raw performance metrics. However, these methods fail to account for the strategic behavior of users, who must decide not only which model to use but also how many prompts to send to achieve their desired output. This paper introduces a user-centric pricing strategy that models the interaction between platforms and users as a strategic game, leading to the development of the Optimal Prompt Pricing (OPP) algorithm.

The Strategic User Model

Unlike static software services, AI-Generated Content (AIGC) platforms involve a two-step decision process for the user:

  1. Model Selection: Choosing between high-performance, high-cost models (e.g., GPT-4o) and more economical, lower-tier alternatives.
  2. Utilization Strategy: Determining the optimal frequency of prompting to reach a specific goal.

To capture the variance in user skill, the researchers introduced the concept of Prompt Ambiguity ($\epsilon$). This variable represents the probability that a user's prompt fails to accurately convey their intent. An expert user possesses low ambiguity (high success probability per prompt), while a novice faces high ambiguity. A pricing model that ignores this heterogeneity risks alienating novice users or failing to capture value from experts.

The OPP Framework: A Stackelberg Game

The problem is framed as a two-stage Stackelberg game. In the first stage, the platform (the leader) sets a price per prompt for various models. In the second stage, users (the followers) observe these prices and optimize their own "payoff"—defined as the utility of the generated content minus the cumulative cost of prompting.

Mathematically, this creates a bi-level, non-convex optimization problem, which is traditionally difficult to solve. The authors developed the Optimal Prompt Pricing (OPP) Algorithm to address this. By utilizing theoretical bounds to decompose the problem into manageable sub-problems and reducing the search space to a single dimension, the algorithm efficiently identifies the price points that maximize platform revenue while respecting user utility constraints.

Experimental Methodology

The authors validated the OPP algorithm using a combination of simulated environments and language models:

  • Model Architecture: A character-level GPT-like model featuring 21 million parameters and a block size of 256.
  • Data Generation: Task environments were simulated using a doubly-embedded Markov chain model to create diverse language datasets.
  • User Simulation: To represent a spectrum of user capabilities, the researchers injected varying levels of noise into the transition matrices of the language tasks, simulating ambiguity levels from $\epsilon_{min}$ to $\epsilon_{max}$.

Key Insights and Results

The "Inverse U" Usage Pattern

A significant finding of the study is the non-monotonic relationship between user skill and prompt frequency. In low-price scenarios, users with moderate capability (medium ambiguity) actually send more prompts than both experts and novices. Experts succeed quickly, requiring fewer prompts, while novices find the marginal utility of repeated attempts too low to justify the cost. Identifying this "active" middle segment is crucial for platform profitability.

Impact of Ambiguity

The research demonstrates that high prompt ambiguity is a "lose-lose" scenario. As ambiguity increases across the user base, the optimal payoff for both the platform and the users decreases. This underscores the importance of user education and intuitive prompting interfaces to reduce systemic ambiguity.

Performance Gains

The OPP algorithm significantly outperformed traditional methods:

  • Revenue Increase: The algorithm achieved a 31.72% improvement in platform payoff compared to modified cost-based pricing.
  • High-Utility Scenarios: In specific contexts where content utility was high, the improvement reached up to 75.05%.
  • Price Ceilings: The study identified a theoretical ceiling—$(1-\epsilon)U_s$—beyond which users with ambiguity $\epsilon$ will cease using the service entirely.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The Optimal Prompt Pricing algorithm provides a robust framework for AIGC platforms to maximize revenue by aligning prices with user behavior and skill levels. While the current model focuses on a binary choice between high and low-performance models, future work will extend the OPP algorithm to support more granular model tiers. Additionally, the researchers plan to incorporate "learning curves" to account for how users improve their prompting skills over time, moving beyond the assumption of static ambiguity.

Summary updated

Abstract

The rapid growth of AI-generated content (AIGC) services has created an urgent need for effective prompt pricing strategies, yet current approaches overlook users' strategic two-step decision-making process in selecting and utilizing generative AI models. This oversight creates two key technical challenges: quantifying the relationship between user prompt capabilities and generation outcomes, and optimizing platform payoff while accounting for heterogeneous user behaviors. We address these challenges by introducing prompt ambiguity, a theoretical framework that captures users' varying abilities in prompt engineering, and developing an Optimal Prompt Pricing (OPP) algorithm. Our analysis reveals a counterintuitive insight: users with higher prompt ambiguity (i.e., lower capability) exhibit non-monotonic prompt usage patterns, first increasing then decreasing with ambiguity levels, reflecting complex changes in marginal utility. Experimental evaluation using a character-level GPT-like model demonstrates that our OPP algorithm achieves up to 31.72% improvement in platform payoff compared to existing pricing mechanisms, validating the importance of user-centric prompt pricing in AIGC services.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025strategic,
  author = {Xiang Li and Bing Luo and Jianwei Huang and Yuan Luo},
  title = {{Strategic Prompt Pricing for AIGC Services: A User-Centric Approach}},
  booktitle = {Wiopt},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.23919/wiopt66569.2025.11123230},
}
Figure