Strategic Prompt Pricing for AIGC Services: A User-Centric Approach

Xiang Li, Bing Luo, Jianwei Huang, Yuan Luo

TL;DR

This paper introduces a user-centric pricing strategy for AI-Generated Content (AIGC) services that accounts for how users strategically choose models and prompt frequencies. By modeling "prompt ambiguity"—the probability that a user's prompt fails to convey their intent—the authors developed an Optimal Prompt Pricing (OPP) algorithm that increases platform revenue by up to 31.72% compared to traditional cost-based methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Current AIGC platforms (like Poe or Monica) typically set prices based on the operational cost of the underlying model or its raw performance metrics. However, this ignores the strategic two-step decision process of the user:

  1. Model Selection: Choosing between a high-performance, expensive model (e.g., GPT-4o) versus a cheaper, lower-tier model.
  2. Utilization Strategy: Deciding exactly how many prompts to send to achieve a desired result.

The challenge lies in the fact that users have varying levels of "prompt engineering" skill. A pricing model that ignores these heterogeneous behaviors risks either leaving money on the table or discouraging lower-capability users from using the service at all. The authors seek to find the "sweet spot" where the platform maximizes its payoff while accounting for how different users react to price changes.

Methods

The researchers framed the problem as a two-stage Stackelberg game:

  • Stage 1 (Platform): The platform sets a price per prompt for different GAI models.
  • Stage 2 (Users): Users observe the prices and decide which model to use and how many times to prompt it to maximize their own "payoff" (utility of the content minus the cost of prompting).

To make this mathematically tractable, they introduced Prompt Ambiguity ($\epsilon$). This variable quantifies a user's capability: an expert has low ambiguity (high probability of success per prompt), while a novice has high ambiguity.

The core technical contribution is the Optimal Prompt Pricing (OPP) Algorithm. Because the resulting optimization problem is "bi-level" and "non-convex" (notoriously difficult to solve), the authors used theoretical bounds to decompose the problem into smaller, solvable sub-problems. This allows the platform to calculate optimal prices even when the user base has a wide distribution of skill levels.

Datasets

The authors validated their theory using a mix of simulated environments and language models:

  • Model: A character-level GPT-like model with 21 million parameters and a block size of 256.
  • Synthetic Data: They generated language datasets using a doubly-embedded Markov chain model to simulate various tasks.
  • Ambiguity Simulation: To represent different user skill levels, they injected varying levels of noise into the transition matrices of the language tasks, creating a spectrum of prompt ambiguity from $\epsilon_{min}$ to $\epsilon_{max}$.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Non-Monotonic "Inverse U" Pattern: One of the most counterintuitive findings is that prompt usage doesn't just go up or down linearly with skill. In "Low Price" scenarios, users with moderate capability actually send more prompts than both experts (who get it right the first time) and novices (who find the marginal utility of a 10th prompt too low to justify the cost).
  • The Price Ceiling: There is a theoretical "price ceiling" $(1-\epsilon)U_s$ beyond which a user with ambiguity $\epsilon$ will simply refuse to use the service.
  • Ambiguity is a Lose-Lose: The study proves that as prompt ambiguity increases across the population, the optimal payoff for both the platform and the users decreases. High ambiguity creates a "suboptimal outcome for all stakeholders," emphasizing the value of user education and better prompting interfaces.
  • Strategic Lowering of Prices: To maximize payoff, the platform sometimes lowers prices as ambiguity grows to encourage more prompts, but only up to a certain "critical ambiguity threshold," after which it must raise prices to prioritize high-margin users.

Key Results

  • Payoff Improvement: The OPP algorithm achieved a 31.72% improvement in platform payoff compared to modified cost-based pricing and a 75.05% improvement in specific high-utility scenarios.
  • Algorithm Efficiency: By reducing the search space to a single dimension (inspired by finite element methods), the OPP algorithm remains computationally efficient despite the underlying complexity of the problem.
  • Validation of User Behavior: Experimental results confirmed the "Inverse U" usage pattern, showing that users with moderate ambiguity are the most "active" (and thus potentially most profitable) segment if priced correctly.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Granularity: The current study focuses on a binary model set (Low-performance vs. High-performance). Real-world platforms often have dozens of models. The authors plan to extend the OPP algorithm to support more granular performance tiers.
  • Static Ambiguity: The model assumes a user's ambiguity is constant for a task. In reality, users learn and improve their prompts over a session. Future work could incorporate "learning curves" into the pricing model.
  • Practical Data: While the GPT-like model and synthetic data provided a controlled environment, the authors aim to validate these findings using large-scale, real-world user interaction logs from AIGC platforms.

Summary updated

Abstract

The rapid growth of AI-generated content (AIGC) services has created an urgent need for effective prompt pricing strategies, yet current approaches overlook users' strategic two-step decision-making process in selecting and utilizing generative AI models. This oversight creates two key technical challenges: quantifying the relationship between user prompt capabilities and generation outcomes, and optimizing platform payoff while accounting for heterogeneous user behaviors. We address these challenges by introducing prompt ambiguity, a theoretical framework that captures users' varying abilities in prompt engineering, and developing an Optimal Prompt Pricing (OPP) algorithm. Our analysis reveals a counterintuitive insight: users with higher prompt ambiguity (i.e., lower capability) exhibit non-monotonic prompt usage patterns, first increasing then decreasing with ambiguity levels, reflecting complex changes in marginal utility. Experimental evaluation using a character-level GPT-like model demonstrates that our OPP algorithm achieves up to 31.72% improvement in platform payoff compared to existing pricing mechanisms, validating the importance of user-centric prompt pricing in AIGC services.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025strategic,
  author = {Xiang Li and Bing Luo and Jianwei Huang and Yuan Luo},
  title = {{Strategic Prompt Pricing for AIGC Services: A User-Centric Approach}},
  booktitle = {Wiopt},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.23919/wiopt66569.2025.11123230},
}

Loading related content...

Figure