Stone Spout Water Quality for Drinking Purposes in Kathmandu Metropolitan: An Assessment Using Water Quality Index

Pramod Kumar Yadav, Santosh Kandel, Bijaya Adhikari, Bindra Devi Shakya, Sudarshana Shakya, Pawan Raj ShakyaJournal of Nepal Chemical Society 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Traditional stone spouts, or Dhungedhara, are integral to the cultural and economic fabric of the Kathmandu Valley. This study assesses the water quality of 20 such spouts in Kathmandu Metropolitan City using the Water Quality Index (WQI) based on ten physicochemical parameters. Findings reveal that most spouts are unsuitable for drinking (Grade E), primarily due to high levels of ammonia, fluoride, nitrate, and iron. Only two spouts met Grade A standards. The study emphasizes the urgent need for treatment measures to ensure the sustainability of these traditional water systems.

Introduction: The Vital Role of Dhungedhara

In the Kathmandu Valley, traditional stone spouts—locally known as Dhungedhara or Hiti—have served as essential hydraulic infrastructure for centuries. As rapid urbanization and population growth strain modern water supplies, many residents continue to rely on these ancient systems. However, these spouts are fed by shallow aquifers and ancient canals (Rajkulos), making them highly vulnerable to contamination from urban runoff, sewage, and industrial waste. This research provides a systematic, index-based assessment to determine the safety of these sources according to Nepal's National Drinking Water Quality Standards (NDWQS).

Methodology and Data Collection

The study was conducted in May 2024, during the pre-monsoon period. Out of 40 flowing spouts identified in Kathmandu Metropolitan City, 20 were selected for detailed analysis via a lottery system.

Map of the study area showing the 20 sampled stone spouts in Kathmandu Metropolitan City.

The researchers employed the Weighted Arithmetic Water Quality Index (WQI) to synthesize ten physicochemical parameters into a single score. These parameters included pH, Electrical Conductivity (EC), Total Dissolved Solids (TDS), Total Hardness, Ammonia, Fluoride, Chloride, Nitrate, Sulfate, and Total Iron. Physical parameters were measured on-site, while chemical analyses followed standard APHA methods in a laboratory setting.

Key Insights: The Water Quality Crisis

The assessment painted a concerning picture of the city's traditional water sources:

  • Widespread Contamination: A significant majority of the sampled spouts were classified as Grade E, meaning they are unsuitable for drinking. WQI values ranged from 19 to 330, with most falling into the highest pollution category.
  • Primary Pollutants: Ammonia, fluoride, nitrate, and iron were the most frequent contaminants exceeding NDWQS limits. For instance, nitrate levels at Pakku Dhara (SS08) reached 135.8 mg/L, nearly triple the permissible limit of 50 mg/L.
  • The Exceptions: Only two spouts—Gyan Dhara and Pepsicola Dhungedhara—achieved a Grade A (Excellent) rating, demonstrating that safe traditional sources are rare but still exist.

Predictive Correlations in Water Quality

The study identified strong linear correlations between specific parameters. Notably, the relationship between Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) and Electrical Conductivity (EC) was clearly defined, reflecting the overall mineral and ionic content of the water.

Linear regression plot showing the strong correlation between Electrical Conductivity (EC) and Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) across the sampled sites.

Furthermore, regression analysis confirmed that increases in TDS and Iron levels are strong predictors of a higher (worse) WQI score. In resource-constrained environments, monitoring these specific markers could serve as an efficient early warning system for broader contamination.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The findings serve as a critical call to action for municipal authorities. While stone spouts are culturally precious, they currently pose significant health risks due to human influence, such as septic system leakage and urban runoff. Immediate interventions, such as localized filtration and disinfection, are necessary. Future research should expand to include microbial testing (e.g., E. coli) and seasonal variations to provide a comprehensive safety profile for these historic water systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Stone spouts, emblematic of the Kathmandu Valley culture, represent traditional water supply systems with religious, cultural, spiritual, and economic importance. The water sources in the valley partially meet the drinking water requirements of the residents. The study aims to assess the water quality of the traditional stone spouts located in Kathmandu Metropolitan City by using the water quality index (WQI). Water samples were collected from twenty stone spouts within the metropolitan area during the pre-monsoon period (May 2024). Ten selected physicochemical parameters viz., electrical conductivity, total dissolved solids, pH, total hardness, ammonia, fluoride, chloride, nitrate, sulfate, and total iron were examined, and the water quality was assessed using the WQI. Ammonia, fluoride, nitrate, and iron were identified as the main issues in many sampled stone spouts exceeding the permissible limits of NDWQS (2022). The results indicated that the WQI values varied between 19 and 330, with the majority of samples collected from the stone spouts classified as grade E, suggesting that they are unsuitable for drinking. Out of the stone spouts examined, only Gyan dhara and Pepsicola dhungedhara fall under grade A according to the WQI. Linear regression analysis indicated that as TDS and iron levels increase, the WQI also increases. Results suggested that prompt measures are needed to properly treat spout water to reduce contaminants. The study's results are expected to provide the concerned authorities with essential information about the water quality of the Kathmandu metropolitan stone spouts for the continued sustainability of the traditional water supply systems.
BibTeX
@article{yadav2025stone,
  author = {Pramod Kumar Yadav and Santosh Kandel and Bijaya Adhikari and Bindra Devi Shakya and Sudarshana Shakya and Pawan Raj Shakya},
  title = {{Stone Spout Water Quality for Drinking Purposes in Kathmandu Metropolitan: An Assessment Using Water Quality Index}},
  journal = {Journal of Nepal Chemical Society},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3126/jncs.v45i1.74490},
}
Figure