Abstract
People living in squatter settlements are more vulnerable to health hazards due to a lack of potable drinking water. The key mission of this study was to evaluate the water quality from different sources at squatter settlements of Bagmati river corridors in Kathmandu. For this, a total of 131 water samples (24 KUKL pipelines, 29 wells, 35 tube wells, 9 stone spouts, 15 tankers, and 19 jars) were collected from different communities of the settlements from December 2021 to May 2022. The water quality of these sources was assessed using physicochemical and microbiological parameters. The water quality index (WQI) was also used to classify the suitability of different water sources. The results of all parameters were compared against the safe limits of the National Drinking Water Quality Standards (NDWQS, 2005). Out of 131 water samples, 11.5%, 24.4%, 11.5%, 16.0%, 28.2%, and 16.8% exceeded the NDWQS safe limits for total dissolved solids, total hardness, chloride, ammonia, iron, and manganese respectively. Likewise, 11.5% and 31.3% of the total water samples were contaminated with fecal and total coliform respectively. Tube well source was found highly contaminated both in physicochemical and microbiological form whereas jar water demonstrated more suitability for drinking purposes. Estimated WQI values also revealed well and tube well sources as poor, KUKL pipeline, stone spout, tanker sources as good, and jar as an excellent class of water. Since most of the water sources in this study were polluted, the implementation of appropriate water treatment processes as well as regular monitoring of water sources are strongly recommended.
Introduction
Rapid, unplanned urbanization in the Kathmandu Valley has led to the proliferation of squatter settlements along riverbanks. These communities often lack formal infrastructure, forcing residents to rely on a patchwork of water sources, including government pipelines (KUKL), shallow wells, tube wells, ancient stone spouts, private tankers, and 20-liter jars.
This study addresses a critical public health gap: while general water quality in Kathmandu is documented, there is a lack of specific, source-comparative data for these highly vulnerable squatter populations. By using the Water Quality Index (WQI), the researchers provide a simplified, standardized metric to communicate the relative safety of these diverse water sources to policymakers and the community.
Study Area and Datasets
The research team conducted a cross-sectional study from December 2021 to May 2022, generating a primary dataset from 131 samples collected across various squatter communities along major river corridors in the Kathmandu Valley.
The sample breakdown included:
- 24 KUKL (government) pipelines
- 29 shallow wells
- 35 tube wells
- 9 stone spouts
- 15 private tankers
- 19 commercial jars
Methods
The methodology followed a standard environmental health framework:
- Physicochemical Analysis: Ten parameters were tested, including pH, Electrical Conductivity (EC), Total Dissolved Solids (TDS), Dissolved Oxygen (DO), Total Hardness (TH), Chloride, Nitrate, Ammonia, Iron, and Manganese.
- Microbiological Analysis: Samples were tested for Total Coliform and Fecal Coliform using the Pour Plate Technique.
- Water Quality Index (WQI) Calculation: This tool aggregates multiple parameters into a single score by assigning "relative weights" to each based on its importance for drinking water.
- Benchmarking: All results were compared against the Nepal National Drinking Water Quality Standards (NDWQS, 2005).
Key Insights and Results
Water Quality Index (WQI) Categorization
The WQI categorized the sources into three distinct classes of suitability:
- Excellent (WQI < 50): Jar water (41.35).
- Good (WQI 50–100): Stone spouts (63.18), KUKL pipelines (69.26), and Tankers (75.61).
- Poor (WQI 100–200): Wells (124.79) and Tube wells (165.23).
Groundwater Vulnerability
Tube wells were identified as the most contaminated source. This vulnerability is likely due to their proximity to the Bagmati River and the settlements' poor sanitation infrastructure (e.g., leaking latrines and open waste dumping), which allows pollutants to leach into shallow aquifers. Notably, 48.6% of tube well samples exceeded the 0.3 mg/L safety limit for iron.
Chemical vs. Biological Disconnect
While sources like KUKL pipelines and tankers achieved "good" WQI scores based on chemical parameters, they still showed significant Total Coliform contamination (29.2% and 53.3% respectively). This highlights that a water source can be chemically acceptable but biologically hazardous due to secondary contamination during transport or storage.
Major Physicochemical Failures
High levels of iron (exceeded in 28.2% of total samples) and total hardness (24.4%) were the most common physicochemical failures, particularly in groundwater. Ammonia levels also exceeded limits in 16% of samples, with tube wells showing the highest mean concentration (3.02 mg/L vs. the 1.5 mg/L limit), indicating significant organic pollution.
Conclusion and Recommendations
Commercially bottled "jar" water currently offers the most reliable protection against chemical and microbial hazards for residents of these settlements. In contrast, groundwater sources—particularly tube wells—frequently fail to meet national safety standards.
Because the study was conducted during the pre-monsoon season, water quality may fluctuate further during the monsoon. The authors recommend the implementation of appropriate point-of-use (POU) treatment processes (such as boiling or filtration) and regular government monitoring of water sources to mitigate health risks in these vulnerable communities.
Summary updated