Stochastic Modeling of Distance to Collision for Robot Manipulators

Nikhil Das, Michael C. Yip

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approach using Gaussian Processes (GPs) with a specialized Forward Kinematics (FK) kernel to efficiently and accurately estimate a robot manipulator's distance to collision, even with noisy sensor data. This method significantly speeds up calculations and improves accuracy compared to traditional geometric methods, enabling safer and faster robot motion planning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ensuring robot safety, especially in dynamic or human-robot interaction scenarios, requires knowing how close a robot is to colliding with its environment. Traditional collision detection provides a binary "yes/no" answer, which isn't granular enough for robust control. Estimating the actual distance to collision is crucial, but it's computationally expensive and often relies on noisy sensor data (like depth cameras). This noise introduces uncertainty, making it challenging to plan safe and efficient robot movements. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method that can accurately and quickly estimate this distance, while also accounting for the inherent uncertainty in sensor measurements.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution lies in Gaussian Process (GP) Regression combined with a Forward Kinematics (FK) kernel.

  • Gaussian Processes (GPs): GPs are powerful non-parametric models that can learn complex functions and, importantly, provide a measure of uncertainty (confidence intervals) for their predictions. This is key for handling noisy data.
  • Forward Kinematics (FK) Kernel: Instead of comparing robot configurations directly in joint space, the FK kernel compares the actual physical locations of control points along the robot's links in the workspace. This is more intuitive for collision detection as it directly relates to the robot's shape and position relative to obstacles. The paper argues this kernel is particularly well-suited for robot manipulator problems.
  • Confidence-Based Hybrid Model: To leverage the speed of GPs while ensuring safety in critical situations, the authors propose a hybrid approach. When the GP is highly confident (i.e., far from obstacles and predicting a safe distance), it uses its own prediction. However, when confidence drops (i.e., near obstacles), it switches to a more expensive but reliable sensor-based distance estimation method.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention or introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it generates synthetic datasets for training and evaluation. These datasets consist of robot configurations and corresponding noisy distance-to-collision measurements. The "ground truth" for these measurements is obtained using standard geometric methods like GJK/EPA. The noise is simulated by adding Gaussian noise to these true distances.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Workspace-centric similarity is key: The FK kernel's success highlights that comparing robot configurations based on their physical workspace representation (via FK) is more effective for distance estimation than purely joint-space comparisons. This is because it directly captures the robot's geometric interaction with the environment.
  • GPs offer a powerful uncertainty-aware alternative: The ability of GPs to provide confidence intervals is not just a nice-to-have; it's fundamental to building robust systems that can adapt to varying levels of certainty in their predictions.
  • Hybrid models are pragmatic: Combining fast, approximate models (like GPs) with slower, precise methods in a confidence-aware manner offers a practical way to achieve both efficiency and safety. This "best of both worlds" approach is crucial for real-time robotics.
  • Noisy data doesn't have to be a showstopper: The research demonstrates that GPs can effectively learn from and account for noisy sensor data, a common challenge in robotics.

Key Results

  • Speed: The GP with FK kernel achieved distance evaluations that were up to 70 times faster than standard geometric techniques (GJK/EPA).
  • Accuracy: The GP-FK model was up to 18 times more accurate (lower MSE) than other regression models, even when trained on noisy data.
  • Trajectory Optimization: Using the GP-FK model in trajectory optimization tasks resulted in 13 times faster optimization compared to a noise-free geometric approach, while achieving similar optimized motion plans.
  • Hybrid Model Performance: The confidence-based hybrid model successfully switched to sensor-based estimation in critical situations (e.g., navigating a narrow passage), demonstrating its ability to maintain safety when GP confidence was low.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost of GP Inversion: The paper notes that the inversion step in GP calculations can be costly for large datasets. While reduced-rank approximations and subsets of data can mitigate this, it remains a consideration.
  • Training Time: While query times are significantly improved, GP training can still be time-consuming.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest several avenues for future research:
  • More efficient sampling strategies.
  • Online training and updating of the GP models.
  • Parallelization of computations.
  • Exploring other kernel functions or GP variants.

Summary updated

Abstract

Evaluating distance to collision for robot manipulators is useful for assessing the feasibility of a robot configuration or for defining safe robot motion in unpredictable environments. However, distance estimation is a time-consuming operation, and the sensors involved in measuring the distance are always noisy. A challenge thus exists in evaluating the expected distance to collision for safer robot control and planning. In this work, we propose the use of Gaussian process (GP) regression and the forward kinematics (FK) kernel (a similarity function for robot manipulators) to efficiently and accurately estimate distance to collision. We show that the GP model with the FK kernel achieves almost 70 times faster distance evaluations compared to a standard geometric technique, and up to 18 times more accurate evaluations compared to other regression models, even when the GP is trained on noisy distance measurements. We employ this technique in trajectory optimization tasks and observe 13 times faster optimization than with the noise-free geometric approach yet obtain similar optimized motion plans. We also propose a confidence-based hybrid model that uses model-based predictions in regions of high confidence and switches to a more expensive sensor-based approach in other areas, and we demonstrate the usefulness of this hybrid model in an application involving reaching into a narrow passage.
BibTeX
@article{das2021stochastic,
  author = {Nikhil Das and Michael C. Yip},
  title = {{Stochastic Modeling of Distance to Collision for Robot Manipulators}},
  journal = {IEEE Robotics Autom. Lett.},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=P4ya5Ri0YDd},
}
Figure