Stellar-reddening-based Extinction Maps for Cosmological Applications

Nayantara Mudur, Core Francisco Park, Douglas P. Finkbeiner

Abstract

Cosmological observations must be corrected for Galactic dust extinction, yet existing maps often contain spatial correlations with the large-scale structure (LSS) of the Universe. These correlations introduce systematic biases into sensitive cosmological measurements. We present two new high-latitude integrated extinction maps based on stellar reddenings, utilizing a rigorous selection process to filter out galaxies and quasars. Our maps demonstrate significantly reduced spatial correlation with LSS compared to previous emission-based and stellar-reddening-based maps.

Introduction: The Problem of Contamination

To study the distant Universe, astronomers must account for the "cosmic fog" of the Milky Way—interstellar dust that causes extinction. While dust maps are essential for dereddening extragalactic objects, current maps are often "contaminated" by the very structures they aim to study. Emission-based maps (e.g., SFD) can pick up the cosmic infrared background from unresolved galaxies, while stellar-reddening maps can be biased by misclassified extragalactic objects in stellar catalogs. If dust corrections are correlated with the target galaxies, it introduces systematic errors in measurements of primordial non-Gaussianity ($f_{NL}$) and gravitational lensing.

Methodology: Purity Over Completeness

The authors developed two high-latitude extinction maps with resolutions of 6.1′ and 15′. The core innovation lies in a multi-stage "veto" process designed to ensure only true stars are used for reddening estimation.

Strict Filtering with SVMs

Using the Bayestar framework, the researchers applied Support Vector Machines (SVMs) trained on optical (SDSS) and infrared (WISE) colors to distinguish stars from quasars and galaxies. This "purity over completeness" approach reduced quasar contamination in test samples from 15% to approximately 0.1%.

SVM classification of stars vs. galaxies/quasars using optical colors.

2D Reconstruction

Unlike 3D maps that can be noisy when integrated, these maps are reconstructed in 2D. This approach provides a cleaner signal for cosmological applications by avoiding the discretization artifacts inherent in 3D models.

Data and Validation

The study integrated data from Pan-STARRS1 (PS1), 2MASS, and Gaia EDR3. To prove the maps are "clean," the authors measured the angular cross-correlation between their dust maps and known tracers of LSS at various redshifts.

Redshift distribution of extragalactic tracers used for validation.

The tracers included samples from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample, BOSS (LOWZ and CMASS), and the DR14 Quasar catalog.

Key Results

The new maps show spatial correlations with extragalactic structures that are largely within the 1$\sigma$ noise level. In contrast, older maps like SFD or Bayestar19 show significant correlations at specific redshifts. Notably, the new maps successfully eliminated the "dip" in extinction previously found in stellar-based maps at redshifts where quasars are most dense ($z \approx 1.5$ to $2.5$). Despite the strict filtering, the maps remain consistent with the SFD map in low-extinction regions ($E(B-V) < 0.2$ mag).

Limitations and Future Outlook

The current maps are limited to the Pan-STARRS1 footprint ($\delta > -30^\circ$) and high Galactic latitudes ($|b| > 20^\circ$). Additionally, the strict filtering results in higher statistical noise in star-sparse regions. However, upcoming data from the Vera C. Rubin Observatory (LSST) will observe fainter stars, allowing for higher-resolution maps with lower noise while maintaining these high purity standards.

Reference: Mudur, N., Park, C. F., & Finkbeiner, D. P. (2023). Stellar-reddening-based Extinction Maps for Cosmological Applications. The Astrophysical Journal, 949:47. doi:10.3847/1538-4357/acc32c

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Cosmological surveys must correct their observations for the reddening of extragalactic objects by Galactic dust. Existing dust maps, however, have been found to have spatial correlations with the large-scale structure of the Universe. Errors in extinction maps can propagate systematic biases into samples of dereddened extragalactic objects and into cosmological measurements such as correlation functions between foreground lenses and background objects and the primordial non-Gaussianity parameter f NL . Emission-based maps are contaminated by the cosmic infrared background, while maps inferred from stellar reddenings suffer from imperfect removal of quasars and galaxies from stellar catalogs. Thus, stellar-reddening-based maps using catalogs without extragalactic objects offer a promising path to making dust maps with minimal correlations with large-scale structure. We present two high-latitude integrated extinction maps based on stellar reddenings, with a point-spread functions of FWHMs 6.′1 and 15′. We employ a strict selection of catalog objects to filter out galaxies and quasars and measure the spatial correlation of our extinction maps with extragalactic structure. Our galactic extinction maps have reduced spatial correlation with large-scale structure relative to most existing stellar-reddening-based and emission-based extinction maps.
BibTeX
@article{mudur2023stellar,
  author = {Nayantara Mudur and Core Francisco Park and Douglas P. Finkbeiner},
  title = {{Stellar-reddening-based Extinction Maps for Cosmological Applications}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/acc32c},
}
Figure