Stable Gapless Bose Liquid Phases without any Symmetry

Alex Rasmussen, Yi‐Zhuang You, Cenke XuarXiv 2016 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: It is well-known that a stable algebraic spin liquid state (or equivalently an algebraic Bose liquid (ABL) state) with emergent gapless photon excitations can exist in quantum spin ice systems, or in a quantum dimer model on a bipartite $3d$ lattice. This photon phase is stable against any weak perturbation without assuming any symmetry. Further works concluded that certain lattice models give rise to more exotic stable algebraic Bose liquid phases with graviton-like excitations. In this paper we will show how these algebraic Bose liquid states can be generalized to stable phases with even more exotic types of gapless excitations and then argue that these new phases are stable against weak perturbations. We also explicitly show that these theories have an (algebraic) topological ground state degeneracy on a torus, and construct the corresponding topological invariants.

Introduction

In condensed matter physics, most "gapless" states—where particles can be excited with vanishingly small amounts of energy—are fragile. Usually, these states only exist at a specific critical point between two phases or are protected by a specific symmetry. If the system is perturbed, a "gap" typically opens, and the gapless excitations disappear.

However, rare exceptions exist, such as the $U(1)$ photon phase in 3+1 dimensions found in quantum spin ice. This phase remains stable against weak perturbations even without symmetry protection. This research explores whether an entire library of such stable, gapless quantum liquids can be systematically constructed.

Higher-Rank Gauge Theories

The core of this work involves generalizing standard gauge theories (like electromagnetism) to higher-rank tensors. By moving beyond the rank-1 vector potential $A_i$ of Maxwell's equations to rank-2 and rank-3 tensors, the authors define new classes of Algebraic Bose Liquids (ABLs). These theories are defined by specific local constraints (generalized Gauss's laws) and the gauge transformations they generate.

Table 1: Local constraints and gauge transformations for theories of rank n=1, 2, and 3.

As shown in the table above, increasing the rank $n$ introduces increasingly complex constraints on the electric field $E$ and corresponding gauge transformations for the potential $A$. For instance, a rank-2 tensor field $A_{ij}$ can mimic the behavior of linearized gravity, while rank-3 theories introduce even more exotic bosonic modes.

Lattice Realization and Stability

To demonstrate that these theories are more than abstract mathematical constructs, the authors developed specific lattice models. These models map the tensor degrees of freedom onto physical variables, such as boson occupations on a lattice. For higher-rank theories, these lattices become significantly more complex than standard cubic grids.

Figure 1: A representation of the unit cell and site degrees of freedom required for a higher-rank lattice gauge theory.

The stability of these phases is argued through "electromagnetic duality." The researchers demonstrated that if the "dual" magnetic sector of the theory possesses the same gauge structure as the original electric sector, the topological defects (like magnetic monopoles) that usually destroy gapless phases become "irrelevant" in a renormalization group sense. This self-duality acts as a shield, protecting the gapless nature of the liquid from collapsing into a gapped, trivial state.

Key Insights and Results

  1. Infinite Hierarchy: There is an infinite family of these states. By increasing the tensor rank and adding constraints (such as tracelessness), one can create increasingly exotic phases.
  2. Tunable Dispersion: Unlike photons which have linear dispersion ($\omega \sim k$), higher-rank ABLs can exhibit quadratic, cubic, or even softer dispersions (up to $\omega \sim k^5$).
  3. Algebraic Topological Order: Despite being gapless, these systems exhibit a unique form of topological order. On a torus, they possess a ground state degeneracy characterized by $6k$ integers, where $k$ depends on the tensor rank. The energy splitting between these sectors scales as a power law of the system size ($1/L$), leading to the term "algebraic" topological order.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The authors successfully proved that higher-rank ABLs are stable against all weak perturbations at the Gaussian infrared (IR) fixed point. While rank-1 ABLs are already linked to physical systems like quantum spin ice, the experimental realization of rank-2 and rank-3 versions remains a challenge. The complex unit cells required—such as the face-centered cubic lattice with multiple degenerate sites—make them difficult to engineer in current cold atom setups or to identify in natural materials. Future work may explore non-Abelian generalizations and more accessible lattice architectures.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is well-known that a stable algebraic spin liquid state (or equivalently an algebraic Bose liquid (ABL) state) with emergent gapless photon excitations can exist in quantum spin ice systems, or in a quantum dimer model on a bipartite $3d$ lattice. This photon phase is stable against any weak perturbation without assuming any symmetry. Further works concluded that certain lattice models give rise to more exotic stable algebraic Bose liquid phases with graviton-like excitations. In this paper we will show how these algebraic Bose liquid states can be generalized to stable phases with even more exotic types of gapless excitations and then argue that these new phases are stable against weak perturbations. We also explicitly show that these theories have an (algebraic) topological ground state degeneracy on a torus, and construct the corresponding topological invariants.
BibTeX
@misc{rasmussen2016stable,
  author = {Alex Rasmussen and Yi‐Zhuang You and Cenke Xu},
  title = {{Stable Gapless Bose Liquid Phases without any Symmetry}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1601.08235},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1601.08235},
}
Figure