Spectral Variational Integrators

James Hall, Melvin Leok

Abstract

In this paper, we present a new variational integrator for problems in Lagrangian mechanics. Using techniques from Galerkin variational integrators, we construct a scheme for numerical integration that converges geometrically, and is symplectic and momentum preserving. Furthermore, we prove that under appropriate assumptions, variational integrators constructed using Galerkin techniques will yield numerical methods that are in a certain sense optimal, converging at the same rate as the best possible approximation in a certain function space. We further prove that certain geometric invariants also converge at an optimal rate, and that the error associated with these geometric invariants is independent of the number of steps taken. We close with several numerical examples that demonstrate the predicted rates of convergence.

Introduction

In computational physics and engineering, simulating the motion of systems over long periods—such as satellites or planetary systems—requires high precision and physical fidelity. Standard numerical methods, like Runge-Kutta, often suffer from "drift," where energy or momentum is artificially gained or lost over time.

Variational integrators solve this by deriving simulation steps from a discrete version of Hamilton’s Principle. This ensures the methods are symplectic (preserving phase space geometry) and momentum-preserving. However, most existing variational integrators are low-order, requiring very small time steps for high accuracy. This paper introduces "Spectral Variational Integrators" which achieve geometric (exponential) convergence by increasing the complexity of the approximation within each step.

Methodology

The authors utilize a Galerkin variational framework. Instead of discrete points, they approximate the path of the system over a single time step using a high-dimensional function space, typically employing Lagrange interpolating polynomials at Chebyshev points.

The internal discretization of a single time step using a Galerkin approach, showing quadrature and interpolation points.

As illustrated above, the trajectory $Q$ is sampled at specific internal points within the interval $[0, h]$. By increasing the degree ($n$) of the polynomial rather than just decreasing the time step ($h$), the method achieves spectral accuracy. This internal approximation is used to evaluate the "action" of the system via high-order quadrature rules (like Gauss quadrature), which is then minimized to find the next state.

Commutative diagram illustrating the relationship between discrete flows and Legendre transforms in variational mechanics.

The resulting discrete equations define a mapping that preserves the underlying geometric structure of the mechanics. The diagram above shows how the discrete flow $F_{L_d}$ and the discrete Legendre transforms $\mathbb{F}^{\pm} L_d$ relate the configuration space to the phase space $(q, p)$, ensuring the simulation remains physically consistent.

Key Insights and Results

  • Geometric Convergence: The error decreases geometrically ($O(K^n)$). In tests with a harmonic oscillator, the method reached double-precision limits ($10^{-14}$) with only 30 Chebyshev points per step.
  • Optimal Error Bounds: The integrators are proven to be optimal, converging at the same rate as the best possible approximation allowed by the chosen function space.
  • Bounded Noether Invariants: For these methods, errors in conserved quantities (like angular momentum) are bounded and independent of the number of steps taken, making them ideal for long-duration simulations.
  • Stability with Large Steps: The method successfully simulated the solar system (Sun, eight planets, and Pluto) with a massive time step of 100 days, maintaining stable, precession-free orbits.

Limitations and Future Work

While highly accurate, the "cost per step" is higher than simple methods because each step requires solving a system of $n$ nonlinear equations. However, this is often offset by the ability to take much larger steps and parallelize internal calculations. Future research directions include extending these techniques to Lie Groups (for rotations) and Multisymplectic integrators for partial differential equations like fluid dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we present a new variational integrator for problems in Lagrangian mechanics. Using techniques from Galerkin variational integrators, we construct a scheme for numerical integration that converges geometrically, and is symplectic and momentum preserving. Furthermore, we prove that under appropriate assumptions, variational integrators constructed using Galerkin techniques will yield numerical methods that are in a certain sense optimal, converging at the same rate as the best possible approximation in a certain function space. We further prove that certain geometric invariants also converge at an optimal rate, and that the error associated with these geometric invariants is independent of the number of steps taken. We close with several numerical examples that demonstrate the predicted rates of convergence.
BibTeX
@misc{hall2012spectral,
  author = {James Hall and Melvin Leok},
  title = {{Spectral Variational Integrators}},
  year = {2012},
  eprint = {1211.4534},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1211.4534},
}
Figure