Social inequality and cultural factors impact the awareness and reaction during the cryptic transmission period of pandemic

Zhuoren Jiang, Xiaozhong Liu, Yangyang Kang, Changlong Sun, Yong-Yeol Ahn, Johan Bollen

Abstract

During the "cryptic transmission period" of a pandemic—the window between initial biological spread and official government declarations—public awareness is often the first line of defense. However, access to information is rarely equitable. By analyzing 150 billion e-commerce records from 94 million users in China, this study tracks how awareness of COVID-19 spread through social and economic strata before the official emergency declaration. The findings reveal significant "awareness inequalities," where socioeconomic status, education levels, and familial networks created a tiered response to the emerging threat. This research highlights the need for targeted public health interventions that address the information gap in vulnerable populations.

Introduction

Public health crises are characterized by a critical period of cryptic transmission. During this time, rumors and unofficial news circulate, but the ability to interpret and act upon this noise varies significantly across a population. Traditional surveillance methods, such as surveys, are often too slow to capture these fleeting dynamics, while social media data can be overwhelmed by misinformation.

This paper addresses the challenge of measuring pandemic awareness in real-time by using e-commerce search and purchase data for Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) as a proxy. By identifying who reacted first to the emerging threat, the study provides a roadmap for understanding how social inequality shapes the trajectory of a pandemic.

Methodology

The researchers utilized a massive-scale data mining approach on the Alibaba e-commerce platform, covering the period from December 2019 to February 2020.

Data Sources and Labeling

  • E-commerce Data: Anonymized records of 150 billion queries and purchases from 94 million individuals.
  • Awareness Proxy: An individual was labeled "aware" if they submitted three or more queries for specific PPE (e.g., "N95," "Face mask") within a specific timeframe.
  • Social Network Inference: Using a decade of longitudinal shipping and gifting data, the authors reconstructed social ties, identifying 43.7 million families and millions of schoolmate and workmate relations.

Analytical Framework

The study period was divided into five phases: Normal, Beginning, Growth, Peak, and Post-Peak. The team employed logistic regression to calculate Odds Ratios (OR) for various demographic factors and used Spearman’s rank correlation to link awareness levels with external factors like GDP, distance to the epicenter (Wuhan), and cultural indices.

Key Findings

The Education and Income Advantage

Socioeconomic status was a primary determinant of early awareness. Highly educated individuals (those with a Master’s or PhD) exhibited a massive head start; during the "Beginning" phase, their awareness levels were 4.39 times higher than those with a college education or lower. Similarly, high-income groups recognized the threat much faster than low-income groups. This disparity had practical consequences: by the time lower-income populations began searching for masks, PPE supplies were already largely exhausted.

Occupational and Gender Dynamics

Occupational roles also dictated the speed of response. Hospital staff were the first to react, followed by individuals in the research and education sectors. Conversely, blue-collar workers and those in the agricultural sector were the slowest to respond.

Gender differences were also observed in the early stages. Women were initially more sensitive to early indicators of the pandemic, with the male-to-female awareness ratio dropping to 0.6 in early January. However, this gap narrowed as the crisis became undeniable and government declarations were made.

Social Networks and the "Parental Shield"

While professional and educational networks facilitated information flow, familial relations were the most efficient channel for awareness diffusion in the earliest stages. Interestingly, the study found a "parental shield" effect: individuals with children were significantly more likely to react early to rumors of a mysterious virus, suggesting that caregiving responsibilities drive higher sensitivity to health risks.

Cultural and Geographic Factors

Geography initially played a major role, with awareness tightly correlated with proximity to Wuhan. However, following the Wuhan lockdown on January 23, awareness decoupled from geography and spread nationwide almost instantly.

On a provincial level, "cultural tightness"—the degree to which a region adheres to strict social norms and monitoring—was a significant predictor of response speed. Regions with higher cultural tightness exhibited faster reactions and higher levels of awareness during the peak of the crisis.

Discussion and Implications

The study reveals a staggering 102,792% increase in PPE-related queries compared to the previous year, yet this surge was not uniform. The data suggests that information poverty is a critical component of social inequality during a pandemic.

Limitations

The study is limited by platform bias, as it only includes users of the Alibaba platform, potentially underrepresenting the elderly or those in extreme poverty without internet access. Furthermore, while PPE searches are a strong proxy for awareness, they do not account for individuals who were aware but already possessed supplies or those who chose not to act on the information they received.

Conclusion

To mitigate the impact of future pandemics, public health authorities must address the awareness gap. Integrating real-time e-commerce and social network data into surveillance systems could allow for the identification of "information-poor" communities. By targeting these groups with early, accessible, and trusted information, authorities can ensure a more equitable and effective response to emerging health threats.

Summary updated

Abstract

The World Health Organization (WHO) declared the COVID-19 outbreak a Public Health Emergency of International Concern on 2020 January 31. However, rumors of a "mysterious virus" had already been circulating in China in 2019 December, possibly preceding the first confirmed COVID-19 case. Understanding how awareness about an emerging pandemic spreads through society is vital not only for enhancing disease surveillance, but also for mitigating demand shocks and social inequities, such as shortages of personal protective equipment and essential supplies. Here we leverage a massive e-commerce dataset comprising 150 billion online queries and purchase records from 94 million people to detect the traces of early awareness and public response during the cryptic transmission period of COVID-19. Our analysis focuses on identifying information gaps across different demographic cohorts, revealing significant social inequities and the role of cultural factors in shaping awareness diffusion and response behaviors. By modeling awareness diffusion in heterogeneous social networks and analyzing online shopping behavior, we uncover the evolving characteristics of vulnerable populations. Our findings expand the theoretical understanding of awareness spread and social inequality in the early stages of a pandemic, highlighting the critical importance of e-commerce data and social network data in effectively and timely addressing future pandemic challenges. We also provide actionable recommendations to better manage and mitigate dynamic social inequalities in public health crises.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiang2025social,
  author = {Zhuoren Jiang and Xiaozhong Liu and Yangyang Kang and Changlong Sun and Yong-Yeol Ahn and Johan Bollen},
  title = {{Social inequality and cultural factors impact the awareness and reaction during the cryptic transmission period of pandemic}},
  booktitle = {PNAS},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1093/pnasnexus/pgaf043},
}
Figure