Information Seeking Responses to News of Local COVID-19 Cases: Evidence from Internet Search Data

Ana I. Bento, Thuy Nguyen, Coady Wing, Felipe Lozano-Rojas, Yong-Yeol Ahn, Kosali SimonarXiv 2020 · arXiv

Abstract Public health officials rely heavily on voluntary adoption of Non-Pharmaceutical Interventions (NPIs) to manage pandemics. This study investigates the "collective attention" of the public during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic in the United States. By analyzing Google search data following the announcement of the first local case in each state, the researchers identify a "spike and fade" pattern of attention. While interest in basic information and hygiene products surged immediately, complex mitigation strategies were initially ignored, and the window of heightened awareness lasted less than two weeks.

Introduction

The effectiveness of public health measures like social distancing and quarantines depends on public cooperation. Understanding when and how the public seeks information is critical for timing policy rollouts. This paper explores whether the announcement of the first local COVID-19 case serves as a "wake-up call" and characterizes the nature and duration of the resulting information-seeking behavior.

Methods

The study employed an event-study framework using a Poisson regression model to analyze daily search intensity data from the Google Health Trends API between January 1 and March 18, 2020. The "event" was defined as the public announcement of the first confirmed COVID-19 case in each of the 50 U.S. states and D.C. To isolate local effects from national trends, the model controlled for state fixed effects (accounting for permanent differences) and date fixed effects (accounting for national trends). The primary metric was the differential percentage change in search frequency for specific keywords relative to the announcement date.

The Spike and Fade of Public Attention

The researchers found that public attention is a finite and fleeting resource. The announcement of the first local case triggered a massive surge in interest, but this heightened state of awareness was temporary.

Relative change in searches for "coronavirus" following the first local case announcement.

As shown in Figure 1, searches for "coronavirus" increased by approximately 36% (95% CI: 27% to 44%) the day after the announcement. However, this interest returned to baseline levels in less than two weeks. This suggests a narrow "window of opportunity" for officials to disseminate critical guidance before public attention shifts.

Information Hierarchy and the Durability of Hygiene

The study also revealed a clear hierarchy in the types of information sought. Initially, the public prioritized basic questions ("What is this?") over actionable mitigation strategies ("What should I do?").

Differential search responses for various keywords including symptoms, treatment, and hygiene.

As illustrated in Figure 2, searches for "coronavirus symptoms" saw the most significant immediate jump at 52%. In contrast, there was no statistically significant increase in searches for complex strategies like "quarantine," "testing near me," or "school closures" immediately following the report.

A notable exception was "hand sanitizer," which saw a 35% increase in searches that remained elevated throughout the study period. This suggests that specific, actionable hygiene habits may take root more firmly than general information seeking. Interestingly, official announcements did not significantly impact searches for "hoaxes" or "conspiracies," indicating that official news did not immediately displace misinformation.

Conclusion and Limitations

The findings highlight a critical challenge for public health communication: the public's window of engagement is brief. Officials must be prepared to provide clear, actionable guidance immediately following high-profile local events.

However, the study has limitations. Search volume is a proxy for attention, not a direct measure of behavior. Furthermore, the analysis focuses on the very beginning of the pandemic; public response likely evolved as the "new normal" set in and NPIs became mandatory rather than suggested. Future work is needed to track how these patterns changed during subsequent waves of the pandemic.

Summary updated

Abstract

The novel coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak is a global pandemic with community circulation in many countries, including the U.S. where every state is reporting confirmed cases. The course of this pandemic will be largely shaped by how governments enact timely policies, disseminate the information, and most importantly, how the public reacts to them. Here, we examine informationseeking responses to the first COVID-19 case public announcement in a state. By using an eventstudy framework, we show that such news increases collective attention to the crisis right away, but the elevated level of attention is short-lived, even though the initial announcements were followed by increasingly strong measures. We find that people respond to the first report of COVID-19 in their state by immediately seeking information about COVID-19, as measured by searches for coronavirus, coronavirus symptoms and hand sanitizer. On the other hand, searches for information regarding community level policies (e.g., quarantine, school closures, testing), or personal health strategies (e.g., masks, grocery delivery, over-the-counter medications) do not appear to be immediately triggered by first reports. These results are encouraging given our study period is relatively early in the epidemic and more elaborate policy responses were not yet part of the public discourse. Further analysis will track evolving patterns of responses to subsequent flows of public information.
BibTeX
@misc{bento2020information,
  author = {Ana I. Bento and Thuy Nguyen and Coady Wing and Felipe Lozano-Rojas and Yong-Yeol Ahn and Kosali Simon},
  title = {{Information Seeking Responses to News of Local COVID-19 Cases: Evidence from Internet Search Data}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2004.04591},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.04591},
}
Figure