Simultaneous Bilateral Ocular Trauma: Clinical Presentation, Epidemiology and Patterns of Injury

Rajendra P Maurya, Virendra Singh, Syeed Mehbub Ul Kadir, Jayant Kumar Das, Sanjay Kumar Bosak, Manish Prajapat, Meghna Roy, Brijesh Kumar Kushwaha, Anil Kumar, Abdullah Al-MujainiResearch Square 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Purpose: This study aimed to determine the frequency, sociodemographic profile, clinical presentation, patterns of injury, treatment and outcomes of cases of simultaneous bilateral ocular trauma. Methods: This retrospective study was conducted from May 2015 to April 2019. The medical records of patients presenting with bilateral ocular injuries were reviewed. Results: Among the 402 patients presenting with ocular injuries, 34 (8.46%) had simultaneous bilateral ocular trauma. The majority were male (70.59%) and the mean age was 26.82 ± 15.86 years. Most injuries occurred away from home (64.71%) and were non-occupational (91.18%). Mechanical injuries were most frequent (47.05%). Assault (26.47%) and road traffic injuries (20.59%) were the leading causes. A vast majority (82.35%) were not using protective devices. Overall, 13.24% were blinded as a result of the trauma. Conclusion: Simultaneous bilateral ocular trauma is rare but severe, primarily affecting younger males and often resulting in poor visual outcomes.

Introduction

Ocular trauma is a global health concern, with an estimated 55 million injuries occurring annually. While most clinical literature focuses on monocular trauma, simultaneous bilateral ocular trauma (SBOT) is significantly rarer and carries a much higher socioeconomic and psychological burden. SBOT can lead to total blindness and permanent disability, yet there is limited epidemiological data regarding specific risk factors and injury patterns. This study analyzes a cohort in Eastern Uttar Pradesh, India, to provide a roadmap for better clinical management and public health prevention strategies.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective clinical study at Sir Sunderlal Hospital (Banaras Hindu University) covering a four-year period (May 2015 to April 2019).

  • Cohort Selection: Out of 402 total ocular trauma cases, 34 patients (68 eyes) met the criteria for simultaneous bilateral injury.
  • Data Extraction: Medical records were reviewed for sociodemographic profiles, injury mechanisms (mechanical, chemical, thermal, etc.), and clinical findings.
  • Standardized Scoring: The Ocular Trauma Score (OTS) was used to categorize injury severity and predict visual prognosis.
  • Statistical Analysis: Data were processed using SPSS version 15, employing student’s t-tests and Chi-squared tests (p < 0.05) to determine significance.

Key Insights and Results

The Vulnerability Profile

The typical victim of SBOT is a young male (mean age ~27) from a rural background. This demographic is likely more prone to such injuries due to higher exposure to manual labor, outdoor activities, and a higher propensity for risk-taking or involvement in conflicts.

Injury Patterns and Circumstances

Unlike many previous studies that cited industrial accidents as primary causes, this research found that assault (26.47%) was the leading cause of bilateral injury, followed by road traffic accidents (20.59%). Mechanical injuries accounted for nearly half of all cases (47.05%).

Table 2: Distribution of cases by time, season, place, circumstances, and type of injury.

Risk Factors and Protective Measures

A staggering 82.35% of victims were not using any form of ocular protective device at the time of injury. Additionally, alcohol consumption was noted in 38.24% of cases, suggesting it may be a significant contributing factor to the circumstances leading to injury.

Table 3: Traumatic agents, modes of injury, and use of protective devices.

Clinical Outcomes and Polytrauma

Nearly 60% of SBOT cases were associated with "polytrauma" (injuries to other body parts), necessitating a multidisciplinary medical approach. While initial assessments showed 38.24% of eyes were effectively blind, surgical intervention improved outcomes over six months, with 55.88% of eyes achieving "good vision" (≥ 6/12). However, 13.24% of patients remained permanently blinded.

Limitations and Future Work

The study is limited by its retrospective design and single-center scope in North India, which may affect the global generalizability of specific injury causes like cracker burns. The sample size of 34 cases, while clear in trend, limits robust subgroup analysis.

Future efforts should focus on larger, multi-center studies to refine the Ocular Trauma Score for bilateral cases. Public health initiatives must emphasize mandatory protective eyewear in high-risk environments and community-level conflict resolution to mitigate assault-related trauma.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Purpose This study aimed to determine the frequency, sociodemographic profile, clinical presentation, patterns of injury, treatment and outcomes of cases of simultaneous bilateral ocular trauma. Methods This retrospective study was conducted from May 2015 to April 2019. The medical records of patients presenting with bilateral ocular injuries were reviewed. Results Among the 402 patients presenting with ocular injuries, 34 (8.46%) had simultaneous bilateral ocular trauma. The majority were male (70.59%) and the mean age was 26.82 ± 15.86 years (range: 2–70 years).Most injuries occurred away from home (64.71%), mainly in roads (32.36%) or playgrounds (14.71%), and the vast majority (91.18%) were non-occupational in nature. Mechanical injuries were most frequent (47.05%), followed by cracker (17.65%), chemical (17.65%) and thermal (11.76%) injuries. Most cases occurred due to assault (26.47%), road traffic injury(20.59%) or sports/recreational activities (17.65%). The majority of victims were not using protective devices at the time of injury (82.35%) and had associated polytrauma (58.82%).Closed and open globe injuries accounted for 29.41% and 14.71% of cases, respectively, mostly involving zones I (55.00%) and II (40.00%). Orbital fractures occurred in 27.94% of eyes. Category I and II ocular trauma scores were noted in 5.88% and 7.35% of eyes, respectively. Overall, 13.24% were blinded as a result of the trauma. Conclusion Simultaneous bilateral ocular trauma is rare and occurs mostly following traffic accidents, assault or recreational activities. In particular, younger males are more prone to bilateral ocular injuries, the majority of which are severe and associated with poor outcomes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{maurya2021simultaneous,
  author = {Rajendra P Maurya and Rajendra P Maurya and Virendra Singh and Syeed Mehbub Ul Kadir and Jayant Kumar Das and Sanjay Kumar Bosak and Manish Prajapat and Meghna Roy and Brijesh Kumar Kushwaha and Anil Kumar and Abdullah Al-Mujaini},
  title = {{Simultaneous Bilateral Ocular Trauma: Clinical Presentation, Epidemiology and Patterns of Injury}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-160490/v1},
}
Figure