The Vitrectomy Timing Individualization System for Ocular Trauma (VTISOT)

Longhui Han, Jinchen Jia, Yi‐Ming Fan, Lu-Yong Yang, Zhiqiang Yue, Wei Zhang, Fang Liu, Huan-jun Kang, Tao Huo, Shaolei Han, Hua Shen, Genquan Tian, Xuemin SuScientific 2019 · DOI

Introduction

Ocular trauma remains a primary cause of monocular blindness globally. While vitrectomy is a standard intervention, the optimal timing for this surgery has been a subject of intense debate for decades. Operating too early risks severe intraoperative hemorrhage, while delaying surgery increases the risk of traumatic proliferative vitreoretinopathy (tPVR)—a scarring process that leads to retinal detachment and permanent vision loss. Because every injury is unique, a standardized "one-size-fits-all" approach is often inadequate. To address this, researchers developed the Vitrectomy Timing Individualization System for Ocular Trauma (VTISOT), a data-driven framework designed to optimize surgical timing based on individual risk profiles.

Methods and Risk Factor Identification

The study analyzed 305 eyes from patients treated at the Hebei Provincial Eye Hospital. Researchers first identified clinical features that independently predicted tPVR development using univariate and multivariate statistical analyses. These factors were then integrated into a binary logistic regression model to create a mathematical "tPVR score."

The Six Pillars of Risk

The multivariate analysis identified six independent risk factors for tPVR: Zone 3 injury (posterior segment), Zone 3 retinal laceration, massive vitreous hemorrhage, retinal disorder (detected via ultrasound), timing of surgery, and the specific type of injury (e.g., rupture vs. penetration). Based on these factors, patients were categorized into high-risk or low-risk groups, with specific timing recommendations: early vitrectomy (Days 2–4) for high-risk cases and delayed vitrectomy (Days 8–14) for low-risk cases.

Multivariate logistic regression analysis identifying the six independent risk factors for tPVR.

Results and Validation

The combined tPVR score proved to be a robust predictor of outcomes. Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) analysis showed that the tPVR score achieved an Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 0.783, significantly outperforming any single clinical marker in predicting tPVR development.

ROC curve comparing the predictive performance of the tPVR score against individual clinical factors.

The efficacy of the VTISOT was validated by comparing patients whose surgical timing aligned with the system's principles (Consistency Group) against those who did not (Inconsistency Group). The results were stark:

  • tPVR Incidence: 27.0% in the Consistency Group vs. 79.3% in the Inconsistency Group.
  • Retinal Detachment: Post-operative detachment occurred in only 9.9% of the Consistency Group vs. 39.65% of the Inconsistency Group.
  • Globe Survival: The rate of saving the physical eye was 98.6% for those following the system, compared to 90.9% for those who didn't.
  • Visual Outcomes: Patients in the Consistency Group showed significantly higher post-operative visual acuity and greater overall improvement in vision.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While VTISOT offers a promising objective framework for personalizing surgical care, the study's retrospective nature and single-center focus mean that prospective, multi-center trials are needed for global validation. Future iterations may also incorporate genetic biomarkers to further refine risk assessment, as individual scarring responses can vary significantly. Nonetheless, VTISOT represents a major step toward data-driven decision-making in ocular traumatology, potentially improving the prognosis for thousands of patients worldwide.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ocular trauma is a major cause of monocular blindness worldwide. Vitrectomy at correct timing can significantly improve the efficacy and prognosis, but the timing of vitrectomy has remained highly controversial for decades. Trauma cases are different from each other, thus, a flexible timing system based on the details of each individual case is recommended. Unfortunately, no such a timing system is available for clinical application up to now. To establish the vitrectomy timing individualization system for ocular trauma (VTISOT), we first identified 6 independent tPVR risk factors (including Zone 3 Injury, Zone 3 retinal Laceration, Massive Vitreous Hemorrhage, Retinal Disorder, Timing of Vitrectomy and Type of Injury) by retrospective study. Then, the tPVR score was established by binary logistic regression analysis. Most importantly and critically, the vitrectomy timing individualization system for ocular trauma was established based on the identified tPVR risk factors and the tPVR score. The following evaluation of the VTISOT showed that the patients consistent with the VTISOT principles exhibited reduced tPVR incidence and better surgical results. In short, the VTISOT principles were established, which may provide a new approach to individualize the timing of vitrectomy and improve the prognosis after trauma.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2019vitrectomy,
  author = {Longhui Han and Jinchen Jia and Yi‐Ming Fan and Lu-Yong Yang and Zhiqiang Yue and Wei Zhang and Fang Liu and Huan-jun Kang and Tao Huo and Shaolei Han and Hua Shen and Genquan Tian and Xuemin Su},
  title = {{The Vitrectomy Timing Individualization System for Ocular Trauma (VTISOT)}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-48862-2},
}
Figure