Secure Swarm UAV-Assisted Communications With Cooperative Friendly Jamming

Hanh Dang-Ngoc, Diep N. Nguyen, Khuong Ho-Van, Dinh Thai Hoang, Eryk Dutkiewicz, Quoc-Viet Pham, Won-Joo Hwang

Abstract

This paper investigates a secure communication framework for Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) networks where a swarm of energy-constrained drones harvests power from a source signal to serve as relays and "friendly jammers." We analyze a Collaborative Time-Switching Relaying (TSR) protocol and derive closed-form expressions for the Secrecy Outage Probability (SOP) under Shadowed-Rician fading. The results highlight a critical trade-off in energy harvesting timing and demonstrate that cooperative jamming effectively breaks the "secrecy floor" inherent in conventional relaying systems, providing robust protection against sophisticated eavesdropping.

Introduction

UAVs are increasingly deployed as "flying base stations" to provide connectivity in disaster zones or complex urban environments where direct line-of-sight is obstructed. However, these systems face two primary bottlenecks: limited onboard battery life and vulnerability to wireless eavesdropping. While "friendly jamming"—the use of interference to degrade an eavesdropper's channel—is a potent defense, its implementation in energy-starved UAV swarms is challenging. This paper addresses these hurdles by coordinating a swarm to harvest energy from the source signal and then split their roles into data relaying and cooperative jamming.

System Model and Protocol

The proposed system consists of a source ($S$), a destination ($D$), an eavesdropper ($E$), and a swarm of $U$ UAVs. The UAVs are positioned to overcome obstacles that block the direct $S \to D$ link. To model realistic urban environments, the authors employ a Shadowed-Rician fading model, which accounts for both line-of-sight components and shadowing from buildings.

Figure 1: System architecture illustrating the source, relaying UAV, jamming swarm, and the eavesdropper.

The communication is governed by a Collaborative Time-Switching Relaying (TSR) protocol, which divides the transmission block $T$ into three distinct phases:

  1. Energy Harvesting (EH): For a duration of $\alpha T$, all UAVs scavenge Radio Frequency (RF) energy from the source's initial broadcast.
  2. Source-to-UAV: In the next $(1-\alpha)T/2$ interval, the source transmits data. All UAVs receive the signal, though the eavesdropper may also intercept it.
  3. Relaying & Jamming: In the final $(1-\alpha)T/2$ interval, the UAV with the best link quality acts as an Amplify-and-Forward (AF) relay. Simultaneously, the remaining $U-1$ UAVs utilize their harvested energy to transmit jamming signals toward the eavesdropper.
Figure 2: The three-phase Collaborative Time-Switching Relaying (TSR) protocol.

Secrecy Analysis and Key Insights

The performance of the system is evaluated using the Secrecy Outage Probability (SOP), which measures the likelihood that the secrecy rate falls below a target threshold. The study identifies several critical design factors:

  • The Secrecy Floor: In standard relaying, increasing transmit power eventually fails to improve security because the eavesdropper benefits from the stronger signal as much as the destination. Cooperative jamming breaks this "floor" by specifically targeting the eavesdropper's reception.
  • The $\alpha$ Trade-off: The time-switching factor $\alpha$ is a double-edged sword. A low $\alpha$ provides insufficient energy for effective jamming, while a high $\alpha$ leaves too little time for data transmission. The research indicates that with jamming, the optimal $\alpha$ is significantly higher (approximately 0.85) than in non-jamming systems.
  • Strategic Hovering: To maximize secrecy, the swarm should ideally hover at low altitudes and near the source. This positioning maximizes energy harvesting efficiency and the impact of the jamming signal on the eavesdropper.

Results and Discussion

Monte Carlo simulations validated the derived analytical formulas for SOP, confirming their accuracy across various scenarios, including different eavesdropper combining techniques (Selection Combining and Maximum-Ratio Combining). Key results include:

  • Jamming Effectiveness: At high Signal-to-Noise Ratios (SNR), the proposed cooperative jamming framework reduced the SOP by orders of magnitude compared to conventional relaying.
  • Swarm Scaling: Increasing the number of UAVs in the swarm consistently improved the secrecy rate, as more "jammers" create a more hostile environment for the eavesdropper without requiring more power from the source.

Limitations and Future Work

While the model provides a robust theoretical foundation, it assumes perfect cancellation of the jamming signal at the destination. Future research should consider residual interference from imperfect hardware. Additionally, moving from static hovering to trajectory optimization would allow UAVs to dynamically adapt to mobile eavesdroppers. Finally, incorporating non-linear energy harvesting models would better reflect the physical limitations of actual RF-to-DC conversion hardware.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article proposes a cooperative friendly jamming framework for swarm unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV)-assisted amplify-and-forward (AF) relaying networks with wireless energy harvesting. Due to the limited energy of the UAVs, we develop a collaborative time-switching relaying protocol which allows the UAVs to collaborate to harvest wireless energy, relay information, and jam the eavesdropper. To evaluate the secrecy rate, we derive the secrecy outage probability (SOP) for two popular detection techniques at the eavesdropper, i.e., selection combining and maximum-ratio combining. Monte Carlo simulations are then used to validate the theoretical SOP derivation and to show the effectiveness of the proposed framework in terms of SOP as compared with the conventional amplify-and-forward relaying system. Using the derived SOP, one can obtain engineering insights to optimize the energy harvesting time and the number of UAVs in the swarm to achieve a given secrecy protection level. The analytical SOP derived in this work can also be helpful in future UAV secure-communications optimizations (e.g., trajectory, locations of UAVs). As an example, we present a case study to find the optimal corridor to locate the swarm so as to minimize the system SOP.
BibTeX
@article{dangngoc2022secure,
  author = {Hanh Dang-Ngoc and Diep N. Nguyen and Khuong Ho-Van and Dinh Thai Hoang and Eryk Dutkiewicz and Quoc-Viet Pham and Won-Joo Hwang},
  title = {{Secure Swarm UAV-Assisted Communications With Cooperative Friendly Jamming}},
  journal = {IEEE Internet of Things Journal},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/jiot.2022.3197975},
}
Figure