Search for charge nonconservation and Pauli exclusion principle violation with the Majorana Demonstrator

Majorana Collaboration, I. J. Arnquist, F. T. Avignone, A. S. Barabash, C. J. Barton, K. H. Bhimani, E. Blalock, B. Bos, M. Busch, M. Buuck, T. S. Caldwell, Y-d. Chan, C. D. Christofferson, P.-h. Chu, M. L. Clark, C. Cuesta, J. A. Detwiler, Y. V. Efremenko, H. Ejiri, S. R. Elliott, G. K. Giovanetti, M. P. Green, J. Gruszko, I. S. Guinn, V. E. Guiseppe, C. R. Haufe, R. Henning, D. Hervas Aguilar, E. W. Hoppe, A. Hostiuc, M. F. Kidd, I. Kim, R. T. Kouzes, T. E. Lannen V, A. Li, A. M. Lopez, J. M. López-Castaño, E. L. Martín, R. D. Martin, R. Massarczyk, S. J. Meijer, T. K. Oli, G. Othman, L. S. Paudel, W. Pettus, A. W. P. Poon, D. C. Radford, A. L. Reine, K. Rielage, N. W. Ruof, D. Tedeschi, R. L. Varner, S. Vasilyev, J. F. Wilkerson, C. Wiseman, W. Xu, C.-h. Yu, B. X. Zhu

Abstract

Charge conservation and the Pauli exclusion principle result from fundamental symmetries in the standard model of particle physics, and are typically taken as axiomatic. High-precision tests for small violations of these symmetries could point to new physics. Here we consider three models for violation of these processes, which would produce detectable ionization in the high-purity germanium detectors of the MAJORANA DEMONSTRATOR experiment. Using a 37.5 kg-yr exposure, we report a lower limit on the electron mean lifetime, improving the previous best limit for the $e \rightarrow \nu_e \bar{\nu}_e \nu_e$ decay channel by more than an order of magnitude. We also present searches for two types of violation of the Pauli exclusion principle, setting limits on the probability of an electron to be found in a symmetric quantum state.

Introduction

In the Standard Model of particle physics, certain principles are considered foundational: electric charge is always conserved, and identical fermions, such as electrons, must obey the Pauli Exclusion Principle (PEP). These are not merely arbitrary rules but consequences of deep underlying symmetries. Detecting a violation—such as an electron decaying into neutrinos or two electrons sharing an orbital—would signal physics beyond the Standard Model, potentially linked to extra dimensions, electron substructure, or quantum gravity. However, such violations are hypothesized to be extremely rare, requiring detectors with exceptionally low background noise and high sensitivity.

Experimental Methodology

The research utilized the MAJORANA DEMONSTRATOR, an array of high-purity germanium (HPGe) detectors situated nearly a mile underground at the Sanford Underground Research Facility. This location provides significant shielding from cosmic radiation, essential for rare-event searches.

The experimental strategy focuses on detecting atomic cascades. If an electron disappears (violating charge conservation) or transitions to a filled lower shell (violating PEP), it leaves a vacancy. Electrons from higher shells then cascade down to fill this "hole," emitting characteristic X-rays or Auger electrons. For germanium, these signals appear at specific energies: 11.1 keV for a missing K-shell electron and 10.6 keV for a PEP-violating transition.

Schematic representations of the three search models: Charge Non-Conservation (CNC), and two types of Pauli Exclusion Principle violation (PEPV1 and PEPV3).

The study investigated three specific scenarios:

  1. Charge Non-Conservation (CNC): The decay of an electron into three neutrinos ($e \to \nu_e \bar{\nu}_e \nu_e$).
  2. PEP Type I (PEPV1): Testing whether "newly born" electrons (from pair production via a $^{228}$Th source) can enter a forbidden symmetric state.
  3. PEP Type III (PEPV3): Searching for spontaneous transitions of existing electrons into forbidden states.

Key Results and Analysis

The experiment leveraged two primary datasets: 37.5 kg-yr of low-energy background data from enriched $^{76}$Ge detectors and calibration data from $^{228}$Th sources. The high energy resolution of the HPGe detectors allowed for precise modeling of background peaks from isotopes like $^{68}$Ge and $^{65}$Zn.

Energy spectrum in the region of interest for the CNC search, showing the 90% upper limit (UL) at 11.10 keV alongside known background peaks.

The findings significantly improved upon existing constraints:

  • Electron Lifetime: The lower limit for the electron mean lifetime was extended to $\tau_e > 2.83 \times 10^{25}$ years (90% CL), an improvement by a factor of 11.8 over the previous best result.
  • PEP Type I: The limit on the probability of an electron entering a symmetric state was set at $\beta^2/2 < 3.69 \times 10^{-4}$, a 70% improvement over prior HPGe experiments.
  • PEP Type III: The limit was refined to $\beta^2/2 < 1.03 \times 10^{-48}$, an 8.3-fold improvement over the experiment's previous benchmarks.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

These results represent some of the most stringent tests of charge conservation and the Pauli Exclusion Principle to date. While current limits are constrained by cosmogenic backgrounds, the next generation of experiments, such as LEGEND, aims for even larger detector masses and lower background levels. Such advancements could push these limits by another order of magnitude, continuing the search for subtle deviations from the Standard Model.

Summary updated

Abstract

Charge conservation and the Pauli exclusion principle result from fundamental symmetries in the standard model of particle physics, and are typically taken as axiomatic. High-precision tests for small violations of these symmetries could point to new physics. Here we consider three models for violation of these processes, which would produce detectable ionization in the high-purity germanium detectors of the \MJD\ experiment. Using a 37.5 kg-yr exposure, we report a lower limit on the electron mean lifetime, improving the previous best limit for the $e \rightarrow ν_e \overline{ν_e} ν_e$ decay channel by more than an order of magnitude. We also present searches for two types of violation of the Pauli exclusion principle, setting limits on the probability of an electron to be found in a symmetric quantum state.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{collaboration2024search,
  author = {MAJORANA Collaboration and I. J. Arnquist and F. T. Avignone and A. S. Barabash and C. J. Barton and K. H. Bhimani and E. Blalock and B. Bos and M. Busch and M. Buuck and T. S. Caldwell and Y-D. Chan and C. D. Christofferson and P.-H. Chu and M. L. Clark and C. Cuesta and J. A. Detwiler and Y. V. Efremenko and H. Ejiri and S. R. Elliott and G. K. Giovanetti and M. P. Green and J. Gruszko and I. S. Guinn and V. E. Guiseppe and C. R. Haufe and R. Henning and D. Hervas Aguilar and E. W. Hoppe and A. Hostiuc and M. F. Kidd and I. Kim and R. T. Kouzes and T. E. Lannen V and A. Li and A. M. Lopez and J. M. López-Castaño and E. L. Martín and R. D. Martin and R. Massarczyk and S. J. Meijer and T. K. Oli and G. Othman and L. S. Paudel and W. Pettus and A. W. P. Poon and D. C. Radford and A. L. Reine and K. Rielage and N. W. Ruof and D. Tedeschi and R. L. Varner and S. Vasilyev and J. F. Wilkerson and C. Wiseman and W. Xu and C.-H. Yu and B. X. Zhu},
  title = {{Search for charge nonconservation and Pauli exclusion principle violation with the Majorana Demonstrator}},
  booktitle = {Nature Physics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41567-024-02437-9},
}
Figure