Search for charge non-conservation and Pauli exclusion principle violation with the Majorana Demonstrator

I. J. Arnquist, F. T. Avignone, A. S. Barabash, C. J. Barton, K. H. Bhimani, E. Blalock, B. Bos, M. Busch, M. Buuck, T. S. Caldwell, Y-d. Chan, C. D. Christofferson, P.-h. Chu, M. Clark, C. Cuesta, J. A. Detwiler, Yu. Efremenko, H. Ejiri, S. R. Elliott, G. K. Giovanetti, M. P. Green, J. Gruszko, V. E. Guiseppe, C. R. Haufe, R. Henning, D. Hervas Aguilar, E. W. Hoppe, A. Hostiuc, M. F. Kidd, I. Kim, R. T. Kouzes, T. E. Lannen, A. Li, J. M. López-Castaño, E. L. Martín, R. D. Martin, R. Massarczyk, S. J. Meijer, T. K. Oli, L. S. Paudel, W. Pettus, A. W. P. Poon, D. C. Radford, A. L. Reine, K. Rielage, N. W. Ruof, D. C. Schaper, D. Tedeschi, S. Vasilyev, J. F. Wilkerson, C. Wiseman, W. Xu, C.-h. Yu, B. X. Zhu

Introduction

The Standard Model of particle physics rests upon several fundamental pillars, including the conservation of electric charge and the Pauli Exclusion Principle (PEP). While these principles are considered absolute in current theory, many extensions to the Standard Model—such as those involving extra dimensions or quantum gravity—suggest that these symmetries might be violated at extremely low levels. The MAJORANA DEMONSTRATOR experiment has recently provided new, world-leading constraints on these "forbidden" processes, searching for evidence of electron decay and PEP violation in high-purity germanium (HPGe) detectors.

Theoretical Framework: Testing the "Impossible"

Two specific violations were targeted in this study:

  1. Charge Non-Conservation (CNC): This search looks for the spontaneous disappearance of an electron. Specifically, the experiment focused on the "invisibles" channel ($e \to \nu\nu\nu$), where an electron decays into three neutrinos. This process is theoretically interesting because it involves only known particles and conserves lepton number, yet violates charge conservation.
  2. Pauli Exclusion Principle (PEP) Violation: The PEP states that two identical fermions cannot occupy the same quantum state. A violation would manifest as an electron transitioning into an already occupied atomic shell (Type III violation) or a newly created electron entering a filled shell (Type I violation).

Experimental Methodology

The search was conducted using the MAJORANA DEMONSTRATOR, an array of HPGe detectors located 4,850 feet underground at the Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF) in Lead, South Dakota. The deep underground location provides a significant shield against cosmic rays, while the use of ultra-radiopure materials minimizes local radioactive backgrounds.

The experiment searched for specific energy signatures within the germanium crystals:

  • CNC Signature: The disappearance of a K-shell electron would leave a vacancy. The subsequent atomic relaxation (electrons cascading to fill the hole) would release the full binding energy of 11.1 keV.
  • PEP Violation Signature: Transitions into a filled K-shell would produce "echo" peaks. For both Type I and Type III violations, the researchers looked for a characteristic 10.6 keV signal.

The analysis utilized unbinned profile likelihood scans and advanced pulse-shape analysis to distinguish these potential signals from the residual background of cosmogenic radiation.

Datasets and Analysis

The study leveraged two distinct datasets:

  • Low-Energy Background Data: An exposure of 37.5 kg-yr collected between 2015 and 2019 was used for the CNC and Type III PEP searches.
  • Calibration Data: A unique aspect of this work was the use of 61.8 days of exposure from $^{228}$Th calibration runs. These runs, typically used for detector characterization, provided the necessary pair-production events to search for Type I PEP violation.

Key Results

The MAJORANA DEMONSTRATOR found no evidence of these forbidden processes, leading to the establishment of new, more stringent lower limits:

  • Electron Lifetime: The mean lifetime for an electron decaying to "invisibles" is now constrained to $\tau_e > 2.83 \times 10^{25}$ years (90% CL). This represents an 11.8-fold improvement over the previous best limit, which had remained unchallenged for over twenty years.
  • PEP Violation (Type I): A new atomic limit on the probability of forming a symmetric quantum state was set at $\beta^2/2 < 3.69 \times 10^{-4}$.
  • PEP Violation (Type III): The limit on internal PEP-violating transitions was improved to $\beta^2/2 < 1.03 \times 10^{-48}$, an 8.3-fold improvement over the collaboration's previous record.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

These results significantly narrow the phase space for physics beyond the Standard Model. While the MAJORANA DEMONSTRATOR has completed its primary mission, its legacy continues through the LEGEND-1000 experiment. By combining the technology of MAJORANA with a much larger detector mass and even lower backgrounds, LEGEND-1000 is poised to improve these limits by another order of magnitude, continuing the high-precision search for cracks in the foundations of modern physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Charge conservation and the Pauli exclusion principle result from fundamental symmetries in the standard model of particle physics, and are typically taken as axiomatic. High-precision tests for small violations of these symmetries could point to new physics. Here we consider three models for violation of these processes, which would produce detectable ionization in the high-purity germanium detectors of the \MJD\ experiment. Using a 37.5 kg-yr exposure, we report a lower limit on the electron mean lifetime, improving the previous best limit for the $e \rightarrow ν_e \overline{ν_e} ν_e$ decay channel by more than an order of magnitude. We also present searches for two types of violation of the Pauli exclusion principle, setting limits on the probability of an electron to be found in a symmetric quantum state.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{arnquist2024search,
  author = {I. J. Arnquist and F. T. Avignone and A. S. Barabash and C. J. Barton and K. H. Bhimani and E. Blalock and B. Bos and M. Busch and M. Buuck and T. S. Caldwell and Y-D. Chan and C. D. Christofferson and P.-H. Chu and M. Clark and C. Cuesta and J. A. Detwiler and Yu. Efremenko and H. Ejiri and S. R. Elliott and G. K. Giovanetti and M. P. Green and J. Gruszko and V. E. Guiseppe and V. E. Guiseppe and C. R. Haufe and R. Henning and D. Hervas Aguilar and E. W. Hoppe and A. Hostiuc and M. F. Kidd and I. Kim and R. T. Kouzes and T. E. Lannen and A. Li and J. M. López-Castaño and E. L. Martín and R. D. Martin and R. Massarczyk and S. J. Meijer and T. K. Oli and L. S. Paudel and W. Pettus and A. W. P. Poon and D. C. Radford and A. L. Reine and K. Rielage and N. W. Ruof and D. C. Schaper and D. Tedeschi and S. Vasilyev and S. Vasilyev and J. F. Wilkerson and C. Wiseman and W. Xu and C.-H. Yu and B. X. Zhu},
  title = {{Search for charge non-conservation and Pauli exclusion principle violation with the Majorana Demonstrator}},
  booktitle = {Nature Physics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41567-024-02437-9},
}
Figure