Scirghi, Thomas. Everything Is Sacred. Brewster, Massachusetts: Paraclete Press, 2012.

Angela McCarthyFrontiers in Pharmacology 2013

The University of Notre Dame Australia

Abstract

This paper reviews Thomas Scirghi’s Everything Is Sacred (2012), evaluating its attempt to bridge the gap between academic sacramental theology and contemporary pastoral practice. By grounding the sacraments in their Jewish historical roots and the "sacramental principle," Scirghi provides a roadmap for re-engaging a modern audience with the foundational rituals of the Christian faith.

Introduction: The Challenge of Religious Literacy

In her review for Pastoral Liturgy, Angela McCarthy highlights a significant challenge facing the modern Church: a diminishing understanding of sacramental theology among the laity. This creates a disconnect when individuals seek out rituals like Baptism or funerals without a grasp of their deeper significance. Thomas Scirghi’s work addresses this "gap" by offering a readable and accessible bridge between complex theology and the practical needs of parish life.

Methodology and Historical Foundations

Scirghi’s approach is rooted in several key analytical frameworks:

  • Historical-Critical Analysis: He traces the development of the term "sacrament" back to early Christian experiences and its scriptural basis in the Gospel of Matthew.
  • Comparative Ritual Studies: The book explores the Jewish roots of Christian rituals, such as the Mikvah (ritual washing) and anointing. By showing that these were evolutions of existing cultural practices, Scirghi provides a more grounded historical narrative.
  • The Sacramental Principle: Central to the work is the idea of God as the "artist of all creation." This principle suggests that the entire physical world serves as a medium for the divine, using symbols to communicate spiritual work.

Key Insights: Baptism as the Narrative Anchor

A primary argument in Scirghi’s work is that all sacramental understanding must be anchored in Baptism. He suggests that religious instruction (catechesis) often fails when it relies solely on abstract doctrine. Instead, grounding rituals in their scriptural foundations and historical story makes them more resilient to the challenges of a secular or skeptical world.

Scirghi also addresses the evolution of ritual, such as how infant baptismal practices shifted to focus on the faith of the parents as a proxy for the child in response to historical pressures like high infant mortality. Finally, the book tackles contemporary questions regarding Limbo and the "indelibility" of sacraments, providing rational answers intended to stand up to modern critiques.

Conclusion

Scirghi successfully translates complex sacramental concepts into an entirely accessible format. For pastoral workers, the book provides "rich catechetical moments" that help explain the symbolic nature of rituals to those who find them opaque. While the focus remains heavily on Baptism, the work serves as a valuable resource for anyone seeking to understand how the sacred interacts with the physical world.

ResearchOnline@ND

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{mccarthy2013scirghi,
  author = {Angela McCarthy},
  title = {{Scirghi, Thomas. Everything Is Sacred. Brewster, Massachusetts: Paraclete Press, 2012.}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Pharmacology},
  year = {2013},
}
Figure