Heon-Wook Park, Die Kirche als Leib Christi bei Paulus, 1992 TVG 378, Brunnen V.

Taïchi KawamuraTHEOLOGICAL 1993 · DOI

Author: Heon-Wook Park (1992)
Reviewer: Hidenori Kawamura
Series: TVG 378, Brunnen V.

Abstract

In Die Kirche als Leib Christi bei Paulus (The Church as the Body of Christ in Paul), Heon-Wook Park provides a comprehensive investigation into the origins and theological function of the "Body of Christ" (soma Christou) metaphor. Challenging the mid-20th-century scholarly consensus that sought the roots of this concept in Hellenistic political metaphors or Gnostic myths, Park argues that Paul’s ecclesiology is fundamentally grounded in Jewish Pharisaic traditions and "Adam-Christ" typology. Through a detailed exegetical analysis of the Pauline corpus, Park demonstrates that the Church as the Body of Christ is a salvific-historical reality centered on the "Second Adam."

Introduction

The central problem in Pauline studies addressed by Park is the provenance of the metaphor "the Church as the Body of Christ." For decades, the Religionsgeschichte (History of Religions) school debated whether Paul borrowed this concept from Stoic philosophy, Hellenistic political thought, or the Gnostic "Redeemer" myth. Park seeks to bridge a perceived gap in this discourse by proving that the concept is a unique theological construct arising from Paul’s specific interpretation of the Old Testament and his Pharisaic background.

Methodology

Park employs a rigorous historical-critical and exegetical methodology, focusing on three primary analytical lenses:

  1. Religionsgeschichte (History of Religions): A comparative study of Pauline texts against contemporary Jewish, Hellenistic, and Gnostic thought.
  2. Typological Analysis: An examination of the "Adam-Christ" motif—contrasting the first Adam of Genesis with Christ as the "last Adam"—as the structural backbone of Paul’s ecclesiology.
  3. Midrashic Interpretation: An analysis of how Paul utilizes "Midrash-style" techniques to reinterpret the Exodus narrative and the creation of humanity to explain the unity of the Church.

His primary datasets include the Pauline Corpus (specifically 1 Corinthians, Romans, and Ephesians), the Septuagint (LXX), and extensive Rabbinic literature, alongside Gnostic and Hellenistic fragments used for contrast.

Key Theological Insights

The "Second Adam" Framework

Park posits that the "Body of Christ" is not merely a social metaphor but a "salvific-historical" reality. Drawing on the Hebrew concept of "corporate personality," Park argues that just as all humanity was "in Adam," the Church exists as a "new humanity" or "new Israel" physically and spiritually incorporated into the resurrected Christ. The Church is the earthly extension of the heavenly, resurrected "Second Adam."

Eucharistic Unity and 1 Corinthians 10

In his analysis of 1 Corinthians 10:16-17, Park argues that the "one bread" of the Lord’s Supper does not merely represent unity; it constitutes the Church as the "one body." He links this directly to a reinterpretation of the Exodus manna tradition, suggesting that the liturgical act of the Eucharist is what realizes the corporate body of the Second Adam.

The Order of Creation vs. Newness in Christ

Addressing the controversial head-covering passage in 1 Corinthians 11, Park suggests that Paul’s instructions are not merely social conservatism. Instead, Paul attempts to balance the "spiritual equality" found in Christ with the "natural order of creation" (sexual difference). Park argues that for Paul, the "newness" of the Gospel does not erase the fundamental biological and created reality of the body, but rather recontextualizes it within the Body of Christ.

Scholarly Contribution and Critique

Park’s work is noted for its exhaustive survey of research history, which the reviewer, Hidenori Kawamura, describes as perhaps the most comprehensive ever written on the subject. By successfully validating the Jewish roots of Paul’s ecclesiology, Park provides a unified theory connecting Christology (the nature of Christ) directly to Ecclesiology (the nature of the Church).

However, Kawamura identifies several limitations:

  • Underestimation of Hellenism: Park may have been too dismissive of Hellenistic and Gnostic influences, focusing almost exclusively on Jewish sources and Philo of Alexandria.
  • The Heavenly vs. Local Church: The book focuses heavily on the "heavenly, invisible Church" as a theological construct. Kawamura suggests this may overlook the "lived reality" of the local, often fractured congregations Paul was addressing, such as the specific social conflicts in Corinth.
  • Technical Oversight: The reviewer notes several typographical errors in the original German text (e.g., "Christoloie" instead of "Christologie"), though these do not undermine the core scholarly argument.

Conclusion

Heon-Wook Park’s Die Kirche als Leib Christi bei Paulus remains a significant contribution to New Testament studies. By rooting the soma Christou in the soil of Jewish messianism and creation theology, Park offers a robust alternative to the Gnostic theories of the early 20th century, emphasizing the Church as a corporate, historical, and liturgical reality in the resurrected Christ.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{kawamura1993heon,
  author = {Taïchi Kawamura},
  title = {{Heon-Wook Park, Die Kirche als Leib Christi bei Paulus, 1992 TVG 378, Brunnen V.}},
  booktitle = {THEOLOGICAL},
  year = {1993},
  doi = {10.5873/nihonnoshingaku.1993.107},
}
Figure