Abstract
The Directory for Masses with Children (1973) includes, as one of the human values present in the Eucharistic Celebration, the experience of symbolic actions (DMC, 9). Children are particularly adept at using symbolic actions from the very tiny child who plays “boo!” with un-scary people to pre-adolescent children who are capable of complex symbolic actions. To incorporate enriching symbolic actions into liturgy celebrated with children certainly supports this important value but must be achieved in a manner which does not reduce the actions to entertainment which then seems to deserve applause. Liturgical movement has deserved criticism when it has drawn the focus away from liturgy towards personal performance. Sacrosanctum Concilium (1963) called for provisions to be made for “legitimate variations and adaptations to different groups, regions, and peoples” (SC, 38). Among the norms presented for the reform of the sacred liturgy, there was a call to “promote active participation” where the “people should be encouraged to take part by means of acclamations, responses, psalmody, antiphons, and songs, as well as by actions; gestures, and bearing. And at the proper times all should observe a reverent silence” (SC, 30). A result of this call for adaptation was for the provision of the Children’s Eucharistic Prayers where the specific needs of children were taken into account in an unprecedented way. Recent musical settings of the responses of these Children’s Eucharistic Prayers have greatly assisted children in responding during this important part of the Mass (e.g. Michael Mangan’s Mass of Jubilee and Patricia Spencer’s Mass of Spirited Praise). To be faithful to the directives of the Second Vatican Council, any development of the use of gestures and bearing needs to be prepared with some sound liturgical principles.
Introduction: The Challenge of Active Participation
The Second Vatican Council’s Sacrosanctum Concilium (1963) famously called for the "full, conscious, and active participation" of the faithful in liturgical celebrations. For children, this participation often necessitates a move beyond purely verbal or intellectual engagement toward embodied, symbolic action. However, integrating physical movement into the Mass presents a significant challenge: how to facilitate developmentally appropriate expression without transforming the sacred ritual into a "performance" or "entertainment" that invites applause rather than prayer.
This paper explores a framework for integrating gesture and movement into the Catholic Mass for children, balancing the need for active engagement with the dignity of the Western liturgical tradition.
A Framework for Liturgical Movement
To ensure that movement remains a prayerful response rather than a distraction, the author proposes five core principles derived from the Directory for Masses with Children (1973) and Sacrosanctum Concilium:
- Integration: Movement must be an organic part of the ritual structure, not an external "add-on" or intermission.
- Appropriateness: The complexity of actions and the accompanying music must align with the children’s developmental stage and lived experience.
- Dignity: Gestures should be reverent and relevant to the liturgical moment, such as reaching forward to receive or bowing in blessing.
- Symbolic Worth: Any physical symbols used must be of high quality and easily accessible to the children's imagination.
- Non-Performance: To avoid the "performance trap," movement should be avoided during moments intended for silence, such as the period following Communion.
Case Study: The "Open Circle" Symbolism
A practical application of these principles was observed in a 2008 liturgical intervention involving First Communicants. During the Eucharistic Prayer, children utilized a long piece of white fabric to form an "open-ended circle." This circle was physically completed by the altar, creating a powerful visual metaphor for the community's unity in Christ.
Crucially, the children moved only during sung responses. When the music ceased and the priest spoke, the children remained still. This rhythmic coordination reinforced the idea that their movement was a communal prayerful response, deeply integrated into the flow of the Mass.
Key Insights: Theology through Embodiment
The study highlights that children often absorb complex theological truths through symbolic images long before they can articulate them intellectually. The "open circle" represents the idea that Christ’s sacrifice completes the community's relationship with God. By physically holding the cloth and connecting to the altar, children experience the "saving act of Jesus" in a way that is "natural and Spirit-filled."
Furthermore, the author distinguishes this "liturgical movement" from "liturgical dance." In many Western contexts, dance can feel "profane" or performative. By focusing on "gestures and bearing"—as encouraged by Sacrosanctum Concilium—the liturgy remains authentic to the participants' cultural experience while fostering deep engagement.
Results and Conclusion
The integration of specific gestures, such as lifting arms in praise or clapping during acclamations, was found to enliven the entire congregation. More importantly, the pedagogical impact was lasting; when the movement was repeated months later at a thanksgiving Mass, the children engaged with the gestures in a dignified and joyous manner without needing re-instruction.
This suggests that the embodiment of prayer serves as a profound form of "catechesis." When movement is guided by sound liturgical principles and high-quality musical settings—such as those by Michael Mangan or Patricia Spencer—it allows children to move from being passive observers to active, embodied participants in the life of the Church.
Summary updated