Abstract
This issue of Pastoral Liturgy (Volume 52, Issue 3) serves as a multidisciplinary collection of historical analysis, peer-reviewed liturgical theology, and practical resources for religious practitioners. Commemorating the 60th anniversary of the Second Vatican Council, the journal explores the intersection of modern "death studies" and traditional funeral rites. Its core contribution is a call to reclaim the "Christian Vigil" from the commercial funeral industry, advocating for community-led, ecologically conscious, and theologically grounded rituals for the dead.
Introduction: The Legacy of Vatican II
University of Notre Dame Australia Source, p. 1
The opening of the Second Vatican Council on 11 October 1962 remains a momentous event for the Catholic Church and the wider world. This issue marks the 60th anniversary of that milestone, reflecting on how the Council’s vision of aggiornamento—bringing the Church up to date—continues to shape contemporary worship and interfaith dialogue.
Fr. David Barry OSB, a monk of New Norcia with deep roots in the post-conciliar era, provides a lead article tracing the historical lead-up to the Council. He emphasizes that the true impact of a Council or Synod extends far beyond its written documents; it is felt in the "fully conscious and active participation" of the community. In Australia, this legacy is currently being navigated through the Plenary Council process and the upcoming Synod of 2023.
The Industrialization of Grief and the Marginalization of Death
A significant portion of this issue addresses the challenges within contemporary pastoral practice regarding death. In the modern West, death has largely been moved from the domestic and religious spheres into the commercial sector. This shift, which authors trace back to the American Civil War and the birth of the modern embalming trade, has fostered a culture of "death denial."
The journal argues that this commercialization has led to "liturgical underperformance." Specifically, the "Christian Vigil"—a vital component of the Order of Christian Funerals (OCF)—is frequently replaced by a simple Rosary or skipped entirely in Australian parishes. This omission represents a missed opportunity for communal healing and theological reflection during the grieving process.
Theology and "Death Studies": The Ritual Body
Journal Motif Source, p. 2
Samantha Wegner’s peer-reviewed research synthesizes liturgical theology with "death studies," drawing on sociology, psychology, and ritual theory. A central insight is the concept of the "ritual body"—a term borrowed from Catherine Bell—as a metaphor for how society organizes itself. The way a community treats a corpse reflects its deepest values regarding human dignity and the "Paschal Mystery."
Wegner advocates for the Vigil as a uniquely flexible rite. It can accommodate modern demands for "personalization" and "celebrations of life" while maintaining the integrity of Catholic liturgy. By reclaiming these rites, the Church can bypass the commodification of the mystical and return the care of the dead to the family and the faith community.
Practical Liturgy and Music
Beyond theoretical analysis, the journal provides practical tools for religious practitioners. Musicologists evaluate new Mass settings based on "pastoral hospitality," melodic range, and rhythmic accessibility. For instance, the Mass of St Catherine of Siena is recommended for its "moderately easy" rating, making it suitable for aging or non-musical congregations.
Furthermore, the issue highlights a growing grassroots movement in Australia, such as Tender Funerals and The Groundswell Project, which encourages home death care. This movement aligns with the theological call to move away from "industrial practices" and toward more intimate, communal rituals.
Conclusion: Future Directions
The research concludes by identifying critical areas for future investigation. In light of Pope Francis’s encyclical Laudato Si’, there is an urgent need to examine the environmental consequences of chemical embalming and high-energy disposal methods like cremation. Additionally, the "enormous upheaval" caused by the COVID-19 pandemic on funeral rituals requires long-term analysis, particularly regarding the psychological effects of restricted presence at the time of death.
By bridging the gap between 20th-century reform and 21st-century social realities, Pastoral Liturgy reaffirms the path to sanctity for the ordinary person—a "little way" that anticipates a universal call to holiness.
Summary updated