Abstract
And this does require deep, deep faith. And it is faith and not knowledge that we are asked to have. Because we do not often know what our following of Christ will entail. As the old adage says, 'If I knew then, what I know now, I would never have said yes.' Faith does not come with 20-20 hindsight. Sometimes, all we have is faith. Faith in the One who calls us to follow. And so, having declared ourselves for Christ, we believe that Christ will remain faithful to his promises. Christ will declare himself for us in the presence of God in heaven. For all of us, there are times of darkness and doubt. There are times when, like Jeremiah, we feel that what God is asking us to do seems too hard, almost impossible to carry out. But what we have heard in the dark, we must tell in the daylight; what we have heard in whispers, we must proclaim from the housetops. Whatever we face, however hard it seems, God never deceives us, and God remains true to his promises.
Introduction: The Liturgical Exile
Volume 50, Issue 3 (2020) of the journal Pastoral Liturgy serves as a critical theological response to the COVID-19 pandemic. While the issue contains a broad array of liturgical resources, its primary academic contribution is Glenn Morrison’s peer-reviewed article, "From Cave to Tomb: Vulnerability, Melancholy and Awakening to the ‘Silken Voice’ of God." This work addresses the sudden "exile" of the faithful from communal worship and sacraments during the 2020 global lockdowns. For a field centered on physical presence and ritual, the pandemic created a spiritual and psychological "void."
Methodology and Theoretical Framework
The research employs a qualitative hermeneutical and phenomenological approach to explore how meaning is found within "luminous darkness." The author performs a comparative biblical exegesis of two key narratives: Elijah’s encounter with God at Mount Horeb (1 Kings 19) and the account of the Empty Tomb in the Gospel of John (John 20).
This scriptural analysis is integrated with contemporary theological reflections from figures such as Henri Nouwen and Anthony Kelly. The "data" for this study includes the Revised Common Lectionary (Year A) readings for June through November 2020 and the lived experience of the pandemic in Australia, which necessitated the journal's transition to a digital, open-access format.
Key Insights: Melancholy as a Virtue
A central theme of the research is the reclamation of vulnerability and melancholy. Morrison argues that melancholy should be embraced as a "child of vulnerability"—a force that opens the human soul to God by providing a reality check on our inherent loneliness and need for relation.
Borrowing a metaphor from Chaim Potok, the author describes the "silken voice" of God. This represents the "soft and luminous quality of revelation" that emerges only when the "noisy gongs" of self-manufactured piety are silenced. Vulnerability is presented as a prerequisite for "personhood" (per-sonare, or "sounding through"), allowing God’s image to sound through the "cracks of brokenness" in human experience.
Results and Liturgical Application
The paper provides a theological framework for navigating "Ordinary Time" during extraordinary circumstances. It redefines pandemic-induced melancholy as a fertile ground for conversion rather than a purely negative state.
Practically, the journal issue provides 89 pages of curated resources—including music by Michael Mangan and Chris deSilva—designed to help practitioners navigate a "resurrected future" while still in isolation. Furthermore, the institutional shift of the journal to a digital-only model at The University of Notre Dame Australia represents a permanent democratization of these resources for a global audience.
Limitations and Future Directions
The authors acknowledge that these reflections are rooted in the early weeks of isolation and the specific Australian context. Future work is suggested to investigate the long-term impact of live-streamed liturgies on communal identity and to explore how the "melancholy of hope" translates back into physical spaces once restrictions are lifted. The "silken voice" phenomenology also holds potential for application in pastoral care, specifically in grief and trauma recovery.
Summary updated