Scalable Generation of Multi-mode NOON States for Quantum Multiple-phase Estimation

Lu Zhang, Kam Wai Clifford Chan

Abstract

Multi-mode NOON states are critical for achieving super-sensitive and super-resolved measurements in quantum metrology, particularly for simultaneous multiple-phase estimation. This paper proposes four scalable methods for generating these states with high photon numbers. While nonlinear methods offer higher theoretical efficiency, a linear optical approach utilizing "Fock state filtration" (FSF) is identified as the most experimentally feasible. This method allows for the creation of multi-mode NOON states using standard coherent state inputs (lasers) and single-photon coincidence detections, bypassing the need for difficult-to-produce high-N Fock states or extreme nonlinearities.

The Challenge of Multi-mode Sensing

In quantum metrology, the goal is to measure physical quantities with precision exceeding the standard quantum limit. NOON states—quantum superpositions where $N$ photons are in one mode and zero in another—are the "gold standard" because they allow measurements to reach the Heisenberg Limit, where precision scales with $1/N$.

While two-mode NOON states are well-understood, many advanced applications like 3D microscopy and complex quantum sensing require measuring multiple parameters simultaneously. This necessitates multi-mode NOON states ($d$ modes). Until now, generating these states for more than two modes and two photons has lacked a scalable, practical methodology. The primary difficulty lies in ensuring all $N$ photons end up in exactly one of the $d$ possible modes in a coherent superposition.

Proposed Architectures

The authors propose and compare four distinct architectures to solve this scaling problem:

Method 1: Linear Optics with Coherent States

This is the most practical approach. It uses standard laser light (coherent states) and single photons. The core of this method is Fock State Filtration (FSF). By using a "single photon catalyst" and beam splitters, the system selectively filters out unwanted lower-order photon number components. Through post-selection—keeping data only when exactly $N$ photons are detected—a pure multi-mode NOON state is distilled from the laser input.

Schematic of Method 1 (a) and the Fock state filter unit (b).

Method 2: Linear Optics with Distributed N-photon States

This method starts with a deterministic $N$-photon state split across $d$ modes. It utilizes the same FSF units as Method 1 but relies on "pre-selection" (triggering) rather than post-selection, improving efficiency at the cost of requiring more complex initial states.

Method 3: Linear Optics with Cascading Fock States

A "binary tree" approach that uses $d$ separate $N$-photon Fock states. It relies on quantum interference to funnel photons into the desired NOON configuration.

Method 4: Nonlinear Optics with Cross-Kerr Media

This is the only nonlinear method discussed. It uses the cross-Kerr effect to create entanglement between a single photon and an $N$-photon state. While theoretically the most efficient, it requires optical nonlinearities beyond current technological capabilities.

Performance and Feasibility

The study highlights a significant trade-off between theoretical efficiency and experimental feasibility.

  • Efficiency: The nonlinear method (Method 4) is the most efficient, maintaining a constant generation probability of $1/d$ regardless of photon number $N$. Among linear methods, Method 2 is $\sqrt{2\pi N}$ times more efficient than Method 1 for large $N$.
  • Feasibility: Despite lower success probabilities, Method 1 is the clear winner for near-term implementation. For a 4-mode, 4-photon state, Method 1 has a success probability of approximately $0.00042\%$. While small, the components required—lasers and single-photon detectors—are readily available and mature, unlike the high-N Fock sources or strong Kerr media required by other methods.

Conclusion

This work provides a roadmap for scaling quantum multi-mode sensing. By demonstrating that multi-mode NOON states can be synthesized using cascaded Fock state filters and standard laser sources, the authors move these high-precision states from theoretical constructs toward practical laboratory tools. Future work will focus on the impact of real-world noise and detector inefficiencies on these generation schemes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Multi-mode NOON states have been attracting increasing attentions recently for their abilities of obtaining supersensitive and superresolved measurements for simultaneous multiple-phase estimation. In this paper, four different methods of generating multi-mode NOON states with high photon number are proposed. The first method is a linear optical approach that makes use of the Fock state filtration to reduce lower-order Fock state terms from the coherent state inputs, which are jointly combined to produce a multi-mode NOON state with the triggering of single-photon coincidence detections (SPCD) and appropriate postselection. The other three methods (two linear and one nonlinear) use N photon Fock states as the inputs and require SPCD triggering only. All of the four methods can theoretically create a multi-mode NOON state with arbitrary photon number. Comparisons among these four methods were made with respect to the feasibility and efficiency. The first method is experimentally most feasible since it takes considerably fewer photonic operations and, more importantly, requires neither the use of high-N Fock states nor high-degree of nonlinearity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018scalable,
  author = {Lu Zhang and Kam Wai Clifford Chan},
  title = {{Scalable Generation of Multi-mode NOON States for Quantum Multiple-phase Estimation}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-018-29828-2},
}

Loading related content...

Figure