Scalable Generation of Multi-mode NOON States for Quantum Multiple-phase Estimation

Lu Zhang, Kam Wai Clifford Chan

TL;DR

This paper proposes four scalable methods to generate multi-mode NOON states—quantum states essential for measuring multiple physical parameters with "super-sensitivity" beyond classical limits. By comparing linear and nonlinear optical techniques, the authors identify a practical path to creating these complex states using standard lasers and "Fock state filtration," bypassing the need for hard-to-produce high-photon-number sources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In quantum metrology, researchers aim to measure physical quantities (like the phase of light passing through a biological sample) with the highest possible precision. NOON states are the "gold standard" for this because they allow measurements to reach the Heisenberg Limit, providing a precision boost that scales with the number of photons ($N$).

While two-mode NOON states (light split between two paths) are well-studied, many real-world applications—like 3D microscopy or quantum sensing—require measuring multiple parameters simultaneously. This requires multi-mode NOON states ($d$ modes). Until this paper, there was no known scalable method to generate these states for more than two modes and two photons. The challenge lies in the "quantum bookkeeping" required to ensure that all $N$ photons end up in exactly one of the $d$ possible modes, in a coherent superposition.

Methods

The authors propose and compare four distinct architectures:

  1. Method 1 (Linear + Coherent States): Uses standard laser light (coherent states) and single photons. It employs Fock State Filtration (FSF)—a technique using a "single photon catalyst" and beam splitters to selectively "filter out" unwanted photon number components. It relies on postselection, meaning you only keep the data when exactly $N$ photons are detected at the end.
  2. Method 2 (Linear + Distributed $N$-photon State): Starts with a deterministic $N$-photon state split across $d$ modes. It uses the same FSF units as Method 1 but uses "preselection" (triggering) instead of postselection.
  3. Method 3 (Linear + Cascading Fock States): A "binary tree" approach that uses $d$ separate $N$-photon Fock states. It uses quantum interference to funnel photons into the correct NOON configuration.
  4. Method 4 (Nonlinear + Cross-Kerr Medium): Uses a nonlinear optical effect (the cross-Kerr effect) to create entanglement between a single photon and an $N$-photon state. This is the only nonlinear method discussed.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a theoretical physics study, the work relies on mathematical derivations and numerical simulations of quantum state evolution rather than experimental datasets or training benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Laser-First" Advantage: Method 1 is highlighted as the most experimentally feasible. While other methods are theoretically more efficient, they require "high-$N$ Fock states" (sources that reliably output exactly $N$ photons), which are notoriously difficult to create in a lab. Method 1 uses lasers, which are ubiquitous.
  • Fock State Filtration as a Scalable Tool: The paper demonstrates that by cascading simple FSF units, one can systematically remove lower-order photon terms ($|1\rangle, |2\rangle, \dots, |M\rangle$) to distill a pure NOON state from a messy laser input.
  • Efficiency vs. Feasibility Trade-off: There is a clear tension between how easy a system is to build and how often it successfully produces the desired state. The nonlinear method (Method 4) is the most efficient but requires a level of optical nonlinearity (cross-Kerr) that current technology cannot yet provide reliably.

Key Results

  • Efficiency Scaling: The nonlinear method (Method 4) has a constant generation probability of $1/d$, making it the most efficient as the number of photons ($N$) increases.
  • Linear Comparison: For large $N$, Method 2 is shown to be $\sqrt{2\pi N}$ times more efficient than Method 1.
  • Concrete Example: For a 4-mode, 4-photon NOON state:
  • Method 4 (Nonlinear): 25% success probability.
  • Method 2 (Linear): $\sim 0.0021\%$ success probability.
  • Method 1 (Linear/Laser): $\sim 0.00042\%$ success probability.
  • Despite the lower probability, Method 1 remains the "winner" for near-term experiments because the components (lasers and single-photon detectors) already exist.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hardware Constraints: Methods 2, 3, and 4 depend on high-quality Fock states or strong nonlinearities that are currently at the edge of experimental capability.
  • Idealized Components: The primary calculations assume "lossless" components (perfect beam splitters and 100% efficient detectors). In a real lab, photon loss would significantly drop the generation probabilities.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that the next step is to model "imperfect" Fock state filters to see how robust these methods are to real-world noise and detector inefficiency. Experimental demonstration of Method 1 is the most immediate practical goal.

Summary updated

Abstract

Multi-mode NOON states have been attracting increasing attentions recently for their abilities of obtaining supersensitive and superresolved measurements for simultaneous multiple-phase estimation. In this paper, four different methods of generating multi-mode NOON states with a high photon number were proposed. The first method is a linear optical approach that makes use of the Fock state filtration to reduce lower-order Fock state terms from the coherent state inputs, which are jointly combined to produce a multi-mode NOON state with the triggering of multi-fold single-photon coincidence detections (SPCD) and appropriate postselection. The other three methods (two linear and one nonlinear) use N-photon Fock states as the inputs and require SPCD triggering only. All of the four methods can theoretically create a multi-mode NOON state with an arbitrary photon number. Comparisons among these four methods were made with respect to their feasibility and efficiency. The first method is experimentally most feasible since it takes considerably fewer photonic operations and, more importantly, requires neither the use of high-N Fock states nor high-degree of nonlinearity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018scalable,
  author = {Lu Zhang and Kam Wai Clifford Chan},
  title = {{Scalable Generation of Multi-mode NOON States for Quantum Multiple-phase Estimation}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-018-29828-2},
}

Loading related content...

Figure