Safe RuleFit: Learning Optimal Sparse Rule Model by Meta Safe Screening

Hiroki Kato, Hiroyuki Hanada, Ichiro Takeuchi

TL;DR

This paper introduces Safe RuleFit (SRF), a novel algorithm for learning optimal sparse rule models. SRF tackles the computational challenge of an astronomically large number of potential rules by employing a "meta safe screening" (mSS) technique, which efficiently prunes irrelevant rules without sacrificing optimality. This allows for more interpretable and accurate prediction models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the problem of learning "sparse rule models." These models represent predictions as a linear combination of simple "rules," where each rule is an indicator function for a hyper-rectangle in the input space. The core challenge is that the number of all possible hyper-rectangles (and thus rules) is combinatorially explosive, making it computationally infeasible to identify the truly optimal set of active rules. Existing methods often resort to constructing a limited dictionary of rules, which can lead to suboptimal solutions. SRF aims to overcome this by considering all possible rules while efficiently managing the computational complexity.

Methods

The key innovation is Meta Safe Screening (mSS). This is an extension of existing "Safe Screening" (SS) techniques. While SS can identify and discard individual features that are guaranteed to be inactive in the optimal model, mSS leverages the hierarchical relationships between hyper-rectangles (inclusion relations). If a larger hyper-rectangle satisfies the mSS condition, then all smaller hyper-rectangles contained within it are also guaranteed to be inactive. This allows for pruning entire branches of potential rules, significantly reducing the search space. SRF uses a tree representation of rules to efficiently implement this pruning strategy. The learning itself is framed as a convex optimization problem, solved using coordinate descent.

Datasets

The paper uses several standard benchmark datasets for evaluation, including:

  • Regression: CONCRETE, ABALONE, WHITEWINE, CASP, SERVO, YACHT, COOL, HEAT, AIRFOIL.
  • Classification: CONTRACEPTIVE, REDWINE, PAGEBLOCKS, MAGIC.

These datasets are standard in machine learning research and cover a range of sizes and complexities.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Hierarchy: The inclusion relationship between hyper-rectangles is not just a geometric property but a crucial computational lever. mSS exploits this hierarchy to achieve massive pruning.
  • "Safe" Pruning is Key: The "safe" aspect of screening means that no optimal solutions are discarded. This guarantees that SRF finds the true optimal sparse rule model, unlike methods that rely on heuristic rule selection.
  • Interpretability Through Optimality: By finding the optimal sparse rule set, SRF aims to provide more stable and interpretable models compared to methods that might select different rules based on random initialization or minor data variations.
  • Scalability Through Efficiency: The core problem is scalability. mSS is the mechanism that makes learning from an astronomically large rule space computationally tractable.

Key Results

  • SRF demonstrates competitive or superior prediction accuracy compared to linear models and is often comparable to nonlinear kernel models, while offering better interpretability.
  • Experiments show that SRF is significantly more computationally efficient than REPR, another method that aims for optimal rule selection, especially when retrieving multiple rules.
  • The mSS technique effectively prunes the search space, with the number of candidate rules identified by SRF being orders of magnitude smaller than the total number of possible rules.
  • The paper also explores an extension called Group Safe RuleFit (GSRF) which uses a sparse group LASSO penalty to further improve interpretability by grouping rules with similar feature sets, with minimal loss in prediction accuracy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While SRF is significantly more efficient than prior optimal methods, the computational cost can still grow rapidly with the number of input features and discretizations.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring further reductions in computation time by combining SRF with other non-safe but less conservative methods, such as active set methods. They also highlight the potential for further research into combining SRF with other regularization techniques.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the problem of learning a sparse rule model , a prediction model in the form of a sparse linear combination of rules, where a rule is an indicator function defined over a hyper-rectangle in the input space. Since the number of all possible such rules is extremely large, it has been computationally intractable to select the optimal set of active rules. In this paper, to solve this difficulty for learning the optimal sparse rule model, we propose Safe RuleFit (SRF) . Our basic idea is to develop meta safe screening (mSS) , which is a non-trivial extension of well-known safe screening (SS) techniques. While SS is used for screening out one feature, mSS can be used for screening out multiple features by exploiting the inclusion-relations of hyper-rectangles in the input space. SRF provides a general framework for fitting sparse rule models for regression and classification, and it can be extended to handle more general sparse regularizations such as group regularization. We demonstrate the advantages of SRF through intensive numerical experiments.
BibTeX
@article{kato2023safe,
  author = {Hiroki Kato and Hiroyuki Hanada and Ichiro Takeuchi},
  title = {{Safe RuleFit: Learning Optimal Sparse Rule Model by Meta Safe Screening}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Pattern Anal. Mach. Intell.},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=o5zjnlot9a},
}
Figure