Revisiting the 1888 Hertz experiment

Daniele Faccio, Matteo Clerici, Davide TambuchiAmerican 2006 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We revisit the original experiment performed by Heinrich Hertz in 1888, utilizing a simplified modern setup to produce electromagnetic (EM) waves with a frequency in the 3 MHz range. By applying Fourier analysis to signals captured by a resonant antenna, we investigate the dynamics of RLC series circuits, the phenomenon of frequency splitting in coupled resonances, and the specific characteristics of near-field radiation emitted by a loop antenna.

Introduction

Heinrich Hertz’s 1888 experiments provided the first definitive proof of the existence of electromagnetic waves, confirming the theoretical predictions made by James Clerk Maxwell. While these experiments are foundational to modern telecommunications, they are often relegated to history books rather than active laboratory practice. This paper presents a reproduction of Hertz’s landmark work using contemporary tools—such as digital oscilloscopes and Fourier analysis—to bridge the gap between abstract Maxwellian theory and real-world field behavior.

Experimental Methodology

The core of the experiment involves a transmitter and a receiver designed to operate at radio frequencies. The transmitter consists of a 1-meter diameter copper loop antenna (A) connected in series with a 1 nF capacitor (C) and a spark switch (S). The spark switch is constructed from two rounded bolts. A 6 kV neon-sign transformer provides the necessary high voltage; when the potential difference across the gap exceeds the air's breakdown threshold (approximately 3 kV/mm), a spark occurs. This spark effectively closes the RLC circuit, initiating high-frequency oscillations.

The receiver (RA) is an identical copper loop antenna placed at varying distances from the transmitter. Unlike Hertz’s original method of observing secondary sparks, this setup utilizes a digital oscilloscope connected to the receiving antenna to capture the time-domain signal for subsequent analysis.

Schematic of the experimental setup showing the transmitter (right) with spark gap S and the receiver (left) connected to a probe.

Analysis and Key Insights

The primary data collected consists of voltage traces from the receiving antenna. By performing a Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) on these signals, the frequency characteristics of the system are revealed.

Frequency Splitting and Coupling

One of the most significant observations in this setup is the phenomenon of frequency splitting. Because the transmitting and receiving antennas are identical and positioned within each other's near-field, they experience strong mutual inductance. This coupling causes the natural resonance frequency ($\nu_0$) of the individual loops to split into two distinct modes: an up-shifted and a down-shifted frequency.

Frequency spectrum of the captured signal showing two distinct resonance peaks due to frequency splitting.

In our experiments, the circuit produced oscillations in the 3 MHz range. Fourier analysis identified two specific peaks at 1.95 MHz and 2.88 MHz. From these values, we calculated a natural resonance frequency of 2.28 MHz and a coupling coefficient ($q$) of 0.37. This splitting is physically manifested in the time domain as a "beating" effect, where the signal amplitude rises and falls as energy oscillates between the two coupled antennas.

Near-Field Decay Characteristics

Standard textbook treatments of EM radiation often focus on the "far-field," where both electric (E) and magnetic (B) fields decay as $1/r$. However, in the near-field region ($r \leq \lambda$), the decay patterns are more complex. Using an EM field meter, we experimentally verified that the electric field strength decays according to a $1/r^2$ relationship, while the magnetic field strength follows a $1/r^3$ decay. These measurements provide a rare and direct experimental confirmation of the theoretical gradients predicted for small loop antennas.

Discussion and Limitations

While the setup is highly effective for demonstrating RLC dynamics and field decay, it has inherent limitations. At a frequency of 3 MHz, the wavelength ($\lambda$) is approximately 100 meters. Observing far-field interference or standing waves—key components of Hertz’s original proof—would require a laboratory space significantly larger than a standard classroom. Additionally, the high-voltage nature of the spark gap generates substantial electromagnetic interference (EMI), necessitating caution with sensitive electronic equipment in the vicinity.

Conclusion

This modern revisit of the Hertz experiment demonstrates that "antique" physics can still provide profound pedagogical value. By combining simple hardware with sophisticated digital analysis, students can gain a hands-on understanding of complex concepts like mutual inductance, frequency splitting, and the distinct geometries of near-field radiation. This setup serves as a powerful bridge between the mathematical elegance of Maxwell’s equations and the practical realities of experimental physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

We revisit the original experiment performed by Hertz in 1888 and use a simple setup to produce electromagnetic waves with a frequency in the range of 3MHz. By doing a Fourier analysis of the signal captured by a resonant antenna, we can study the behavior of the RLC series circuit, frequency splitting of coupled resonances, and the characteristics of the near-field emitted by the loop antenna.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{faccio2006revisiting,
  author = {Daniele Faccio and Matteo Clerici and Davide Tambuchi},
  title = {{Revisiting the 1888 Hertz experiment}},
  booktitle = {American},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1119/1.2238886},
}
Figure