Reference Frame Unification of IMU-Based Joint Angle Estimation: The Experimental Investigation and a Novel Method

Jie Liu, Chunzhi Yi, Feng Jiang, Chifu Yang, Zhiyuan Chen, Zhen Ding, Jie Liu 0001

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of accurately estimating human joint angles using Inertial Measurement Units (IMUs). They introduce a novel method to unify the reference frames of different IMUs, which is crucial for improving accuracy, and experimentally demonstrate its effectiveness compared to existing techniques.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Estimating human joint angles is vital for applications ranging from rehabilitation and sports analysis to robotics. Inertial Measurement Units (IMUs) offer a portable and convenient solution, but their accuracy is hampered by inconsistencies in their individual reference frames. These "reference frame deviations" arise from subtle differences in how each IMU perceives orientation, leading to errors in joint angle calculations. While previous work has attempted to address this, the problem of reference frame unification (RFU) hasn't been systematically investigated, leading to confusion with "drift correction" and the use of overly simplistic metrics. This paper aims to clarify RFU, experimentally analyze these deviations, and propose a more robust and accurate unification method.

Methods

The authors first mathematically formulate the Reference Frame Unification (RFU) problem, distinguishing it from drift correction. They then design a mechanical gimbal experiment to isolate and study the deviations of IMU reference frames, excluding factors like sensor-to-body alignment and relative segment rotation. Based on experimental findings, they propose a novel RFU method that employs a comprehensive set of metrics. This method fuses information from:

  • Gravity acceleration: Assumes consistent gravitational pull across IMUs.
  • Local magnetic field: Utilizes magnetic field readings, accounting for potential distortions.
  • Joint axis consistency: Leverages the known constraint of a hinge-like joint axis.

This comprehensive approach allows for a pointwise compensation of the non-linearly time-varying deviations, addressing the limitations of static or linearly interpolated methods. The fusion coefficients are dynamically tuned using an L-M optimization method.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention training datasets. For evaluation, they collected data from ten healthy human subjects performing level walking experiments. This data was synchronized with an optical motion capture system (Vicon) to provide ground truth joint angles for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RFU is distinct from Drift Correction: The paper clearly differentiates RFU (making sensor frames align) from drift correction (correcting orientation errors, often due to magnetic distortion). This distinction is crucial for understanding the problem.
  • Deviations are Non-linear and Time-Varying: Experiments reveal that IMU reference frame deviations are not static or linear, necessitating a pointwise and adaptive compensation strategy.
  • Multiple Metrics are Better: Relying on a single metric (like joint axis or gravity) is insufficient. Combining information from gravity, magnetic fields, and joint axes provides a more robust and accurate unification.
  • Heterogeneous Magnetic Fields Increase Errors: The experiments were conducted in a deliberately heterogeneous magnetic field, highlighting the robustness of their method in challenging real-world conditions.

Key Results

The proposed RFU method significantly outperforms existing methods in terms of accuracy. The Root Mean Square Errors (RMSEs) for 3D joint angles were consistently lower across all joints (hip, knee, ankle) and movement types (flexion/extension, abduction/adduction, intra/extra rotation). For instance, the RMSE for ankle flexion/extension was 2.7 ± 0.6 degrees with their method, compared to 4.3 ± 0.4 degrees for the static method and 3.6 ± 0.8 for the joint axis method. The repeatability, measured by the dispersion of correction quaternions, was also competitive, suggesting reliable performance across multiple uses.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Functional Calibration: The evaluation was performed with functional calibration-based sensor-to-body alignment, which might limit overall accuracy. They suggest exploring alternative alignment methods.
  • Absolute Orientation Performance: The accuracy of their RFU method is dependent on the underlying absolute orientation estimation algorithm.
  • Level Walking Only: Experiments were limited to level walking. Future work should include more diverse motion patterns.

They propose future work to evaluate their method with different sensor-to-body alignment techniques and to test it across a wider range of human movements.

Summary updated

Abstract

Inertial measurement unit (IMU)-based joint angle estimation is an increasingly mature technique that has a broad range of applications in clinics, biomechanics and robotics. However, the deviations of different IMUs’ reference frames, referring to IMUs’ individual orientations estimating errors, is still a challenge for improving the angle estimation accuracy due to conceptual confusion, relatively simple metrics and the lack of systematical investigation. In this paper, we clarify the determination of reference frame unification, experimentally study the time-varying characteristics of reference frames’ deviations and accordingly propose a novel method with a comprehensive metric to unify reference frames. To be specific, we firstly define the reference frame unification (RFU) and distinguish it with drift correction that has always been confused with the term RFU. Secondly, we design a mechanical gimbal-based experiment to study the deviations, where sensor-to-body alignment and rotation-caused differences of orientations are excluded. Thirdly, based on the findings of the experiment, we propose a novel method to utilize the consistency of the joint axis under the hinge-joint constraint, gravity acceleration and local magnetic field to comprehensively unify reference frames, which meets the nonlinear time-varying characteristics of the deviations. The results on ten human subjects reveal the feasibility of our proposed method and the improvement from previous methods. This work contributes to a relatively new perspective of considering and improving the accuracy of IMU-based joint angle estimation.
BibTeX
@article{liu2021reference,
  author = {Jie Liu and Chunzhi Yi and Feng Jiang and Chifu Yang and Zhiyuan Chen and Zhen Ding and Jie Liu},
  title = {{Reference Frame Unification of IMU-Based Joint Angle Estimation: The Experimental Investigation and a Novel Method}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21051813},
}

Loading related content...

Figure