Reasons and Solutions for the Decline in Model Performance after Editing

Xiusheng Huang, Jiaxiang Liu, Yequan Wang, Kang Liu

Abstract

Knowledge editing technology has emerged as a low-cost alternative for updating incorrect or outdated information in large-scale language models (LLMs). However, recent studies indicate that edited models often suffer from significant performance degradation. This paper investigates the underlying causes of this decline from both data and model perspectives. We introduce the Multi-Question Dataset (MQD) to evaluate how editing data types impact model integrity, finding that target diversity and sequence length are critical factors. Furthermore, we identify a strong correlation between the L1-norm of the editing layer and performance bottlenecks. To address these issues, we propose Dump for Sequence (D4S), a method that stabilizes sequential updates by reducing L1-norm growth, enabling thousands of effective edits with minimal damage to the model's general capabilities.

Introduction

Large Language Models (LLMs) are static snapshots of the information available at the time of their training. As the world evolves, these models inevitably become outdated or exhibit hallucinations. While full fine-tuning is computationally prohibitive for frequent updates, "knowledge editing" offers a surgical approach, modifying a tiny fraction of parameters to inject new facts.

Despite its promise, knowledge editing faces a significant hurdle: the "side-effect" problem. After a series of edits, the model’s performance on unrelated downstream tasks—such as logic, math, or general reasoning—often plummets, and the model begins to "forget" previously injected facts. This research seeks to diagnose why this degradation occurs and provides a scalable solution for long-term, continuous model maintenance.

Investigating the Performance Decline

1. The Data Perspective: Complexity and Perplexity

To understand how the nature of the data affects the model, we constructed the Multi-Question Dataset (MQD). Derived from the ATOMIC database, MQD categorizes questions into three formats: True/False, Multiple Choice, and Direct Generation.

Our experiments revealed a strong correlation between the Perplexity (PPL) of the editing target and the resulting model damage. Editing a model to produce a simple "yes/no" answer is relatively safe. However, editing it to generate complex, multi-word sequences (high-perplexity targets) forces the internal weights to shift more drastically. This "complexity penalty" suggests that the more diverse and lengthy the editing target, the higher the risk of collateral damage to the model's pre-trained knowledge.

2. The Model Perspective: The L1-Norm Bottleneck

From a structural standpoint, we discovered that the primary culprit for performance collapse in methods like ROME or MEMIT is the explosive growth of the L1-norm in the edited layers. As the number of sequential edits increases, the weights in these layers become disproportionately "loud," effectively drowning out the model's original features. This norm growth acts as a performance bottleneck; once the L1-norm exceeds a certain threshold, the model loses its ability to generalize across tasks.

The Solution: Dump for Sequence (D4S)

To overcome the limitations of sequential editing, we propose Dump for Sequence (D4S). Standard sequential editing treats each new fact as an isolated intervention, which allows errors and weight distortions to compound over time.

D4S mathematically reformulates sequential editing into a continuous batch process. By maintaining two fixed-size matrices that store the "history" of previous edits in $O(1)$ space, D4S integrates new facts as if they were part of a single, stable update. This "dump" mechanism prevents the explosive growth of the L1-norm, keeping the model's parameters within a healthy functional range even after thousands of modifications.

Experimental Results

Stability and Efficacy

We tested D4S on GPT-J (6B) and Llama-2 (7B) across various benchmarks, including zsRE, CounterFact, and MQuAKE. D4S maintained high editing efficacy (approximately 88-91%) after 1,000 sequential edits. In contrast, baseline methods often saw their success rates or general intelligence collapse under the same conditions.

Minimal Collateral Damage

The most striking result was the preservation of general performance. After 10,000 sequential edits on Llama-2, D4S showed remarkably low degradation on the Open LLM Leadership Board tasks. For instance, on the MMLU benchmark, the score only dropped from 41.35 to 39.76. This demonstrates that D4S can support long-term "life-long learning" without the catastrophic forgetting typical of earlier editing techniques.

Conclusion

The decline in model performance after editing is driven by the complexity of the target data and the resulting instability in parameter norms. By identifying the L1-norm as a key metric for model health, we developed D4S to stabilize the editing process. D4S provides a memory-efficient, $O(1)$ space solution that allows LLMs to be updated continuously. Future work will focus on scaling D4S to frontier models exceeding 70B parameters and further optimizing the training duration to enhance stability.

Summary updated

Abstract

Knowledge editing technology has received widespread attention for low-cost updates of incorrect or outdated knowledge in large-scale language models. However, recent research has found that edited models often exhibit varying degrees of performance degradation. The reasons behind this phenomenon and potential solutions have not yet been provided. In order to investigate the reasons for the performance decline of the edited model and optimize the editing method, this work explores the underlying reasons from both data and model perspectives. Specifically, 1) from a data perspective, to clarify the impact of data on the performance of editing models, this paper first constructs a Multi-Question Dataset (MQD) to evaluate the impact of different types of editing data on model performance. The performance of the editing model is mainly affected by the diversity of editing targets and sequence length, as determined through experiments. 2) From a model perspective, this article explores the factors that affect the performance of editing models. The results indicate a strong correlation between the L1-norm of the editing model layer and the editing accuracy, and clarify that this is an important factor leading to the bottleneck of editing performance. Finally, in order to improve the performance of the editing model, this paper further proposes a Dump for Sequence (D4S) method, which successfully overcomes the previous editing bottleneck by reducing the L1-norm of the editing layer, allowing users to perform multiple effective edits and minimizing model damage. Our code is available at https://github.com/nlpkeg/D4S.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2024reasons,
  author = {Xiusheng Huang and Jiaxiang Liu and Yequan Wang and Kang Liu},
  title = {{Reasons and Solutions for the Decline in Model Performance after Editing}},
  booktitle = {Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=xjXYgdFM5M},
}
Figure