Rate-Distortion Theoretic Generalization Bounds for Stochastic Learning Algorithms

Milad Sefidgaran, Amin Gohari, Gaël Richard, Umut Simsekli

Introduction

A central challenge in modern machine learning is understanding why overparameterized neural networks generalize effectively to unseen data rather than simply memorizing training sets. Traditional statistical measures, such as the Vapnik-Chervonenkis (VC) dimension, often provide vacuous bounds in the context of deep learning. In response, researchers have developed several alternative frameworks: information-theoretic bounds based on mutual information, model compressibility arguments, and fractal geometry perspectives focusing on the intrinsic dimension of the weight space.

While these "lenses" have individually advanced our understanding, they have largely remained mathematically disconnected. This research introduces a "Grand Unified Theory" that bridges these gaps by applying Rate-Distortion Theory from information science.

The Rate-Distortion Framework

Originally developed by Claude Shannon, Rate-Distortion Theory determines the minimum number of bits (the "rate") required to represent a signal given a specific tolerance for error (the "distortion"). This paper adapts this concept to machine learning by treating a learning algorithm as an information source.

The authors define a "distortion function" based on the difference in generalization performance between an original model and its compressed counterpart. By employing block-coding techniques—analyzing multiple independent runs of a learning algorithm—they demonstrate how the compression error rate directly constrains the generalization gap.

Unifying Information, Compression, and Geometry

The power of this framework lies in its ability to recover existing theories as special cases:

  1. Information Theory: In the lossless case (zero distortion), the framework recovers and refines existing mutual information-based bounds. Crucially, it addresses the "infinite MI" problem. Previous bounds often became infinite for models with continuous weights; by allowing for lossy compression, this framework provides finite, practical bounds even when exact mutual information is undefined.
  2. Compressibility: The theory formalizes the intuition that generalization is fundamentally about compression. If a model's performance can be represented using very few bits, it is less likely to have overfitted to the specific noise of the training data.
  3. Fractal Geometry: The authors establish a formal link to the rate-distortion dimension, a specific type of fractal dimension. They show that the intrinsic dimension of a model's weight space is effectively the rate at which the required bits increase as the demand for lower distortion grows.

Key Results and Mathematical Bounds

The paper provides several significant theoretical contributions:

  • Unified Generalization Bounds: The authors derive new bounds on the expected generalization gap (Theorems 2 and 4) and the "tail" of the generalization gap (Theorem 10).
  • Improved Tail Bounds: A technical highlight is the logarithmic dependence on the failure probability ($1/\delta$), a significant improvement over previous information-theoretic approaches.
  • Recovery of Classical Theory: The framework is flexible enough to recover classical VC-dimension bounds (Corollary 18), demonstrating its comprehensiveness.
  • Fractal Recovery: Through Corollary 7, the authors provide a formal bridge between information theory and the fractal analysis of deep learning trajectories.

Limitations and Future Work

Despite its mathematical elegance, the rate-distortion function is computationally intensive to calculate for high-dimensional neural networks. Future research is needed to develop efficient numerical methods for estimating these values. Additionally, the authors identify promising connections to PAC-Bayesian theory and the potential for "chaining" techniques to further tighten these bounds.

By unifying disparate theories under the umbrella of Rate-Distortion Theory, this work provides a more cohesive foundation for understanding the mechanisms of generalization in complex learning systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding generalization in modern machine learning settings has been one of the major challenges in statistical learning theory. In this context, recent years have witnessed the development of various generalization bounds suggesting different complexity notions such as the mutual information between the data sample and the algorithm output, compressibility of the hypothesis space, and the fractal dimension of the hypothesis space. While these bounds have illuminated the problem at hand from different angles, their suggested complexity notions might appear seemingly unrelated, thereby restricting their high-level impact. In this study, we prove novel generalization bounds through the lens of rate-distortion theory, and explicitly relate the concepts of mutual information, compressibility, and fractal dimensions in a single mathematical framework. Our approach consists of (i) defining a generalized notion of compressibility by using source coding concepts, and (ii) showing that the `compression error rate' can be linked to the generalization error both in expectation and with high probability. We show that in the `lossless compression' setting, we recover and improve existing mutual information-based bounds, whereas a `lossy compression' scheme allows us to link generalization to the rate-distortion dimension -- a particular notion of fractal dimension. Our results bring a more unified perspective on generalization and open up several future research directions.
BibTeX
@misc{sefidgaran2022rate,
  author = {Milad Sefidgaran and Amin Gohari and Gaël Richard and Umut Simsekli},
  title = {{Rate-Distortion Theoretic Generalization Bounds for Stochastic Learning Algorithms}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2203.02474},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2203.02474},
}
Figure