Abstract
In this paper, we introduce the exposed secondary users problem in underlay cognitive radio systems, where both the secondary-to-primary and primary-to-secondary channels have a Line-of-Sight (LoS) component. Based on a Rician model for the LoS channels, we show, analytically and numerically, that LoS interference hinders the achievable secondary user capacity when interference constraints are imposed at the primary user receiver. This is caused by the poor dynamic range of the interference channels fluctuations when a dominant LoS component exists. In order to improve the capacity of such system, we propose the usage of an Electronically Steerable Parasitic Array Radiator (ESPAR) antennas at the secondary terminals. An ESPAR antenna involves a single RF chain and has a reconfigurable radiation pattern that is controlled by assigning arbitrary weights to M orthonormal basis radiation patterns via altering a set of reactive loads. This scheme, termed as Random Aerial Beamforming (RAB), creates artificial channel fluctuations that can perfectly eliminate the undesired impact of LoS interference.
Introduction
In underlay cognitive radio (CR) systems, a Secondary User (SU) is permitted to transmit on the same frequency as a Primary User (PU), provided the SU's interference remains below a predefined threshold. Traditional research often assumes these channels are subject to Rayleigh fading, where signal fluctuations are beneficial: the SU can wait for a "deep fade" in the interference channel to transmit at high power without disrupting the PU.
However, in modern wireless scenarios such as Device-to-Device (D2D) or satellite communications, a strong Line-of-Sight (LoS) component is frequently present, modeled as Rician fading. This leads to the Exposed Secondary User problem. When the interference channel is stable and LoS-dominant, the deep fades disappear. The SU is constantly "exposed" to the PU, forcing it to maintain low transmission power. This kills the multiuser diversity that typically makes spectrum sharing efficient, causing the system's capacity to scale poorly as more users are added.
Methodology: Random Aerial Beamforming (RAB)
To address the limitations of LoS-dominant channels, we propose a hardware-software co-design utilizing Random Aerial Beamforming (RAB).
ESPAR Antennas
The hardware foundation is the Electronically Steerable Parasitic Array Radiator (ESPAR) antenna. Unlike traditional MIMO arrays that require multiple expensive RF chains, an ESPAR antenna uses a single RF chain connected to an active element, surrounded by parasitic elements.
By adjusting the reactive loads (varactors) on these parasitic elements, the antenna's radiation pattern can be reconfigured on the fly. This allows the generation of $M$ orthonormal basis radiation patterns.
System Model and Artificial Fading
RAB treats these basis patterns as "virtual dumb antennas." By randomly varying the weights assigned to these patterns over time, the SU artificially induces the channel fluctuations that the LoS component had suppressed.
This "artificial fading" restores the dynamic range of the interference channel. To ensure the SU's own data link remains reliable, a "smart" version of RAB can be employed, using Maximum Ratio Combining (MRC) at the receiver to reconstruct the desired signal while maintaining the randomizing effect on the interference links.
Key Results and Discussion
The proposed RAB scheme was evaluated through Monte-Carlo simulations using Rician and Rayleigh fading models with varying K-factors.
- Capacity Recovery: In LoS-heavy (Rician-Rician) scenarios, SU capacity is significantly degraded. Applying RAB with just a few basis patterns (e.g., $M=5$) recovers this lost capacity, effectively making a Rician channel behave like a Rayleigh channel.
- Restoring Scaling Laws: In multiuser environments, LoS interference causes SU capacity to grow slowly at a rate of $\log(\log(N))$. RAB restores the much faster $\log(N)$ scaling law, significantly improving multiuser diversity gains.
- Opportunistic Nulling: With as few as two basis patterns, the SU can perform "opportunistic nulling." This allows the system to perform even better than in standard Rayleigh fading environments because the SU can more frequently find "nulls" to hide its interference from the PU.
Conclusion
Random Aerial Beamforming offers a low-cost, hardware-efficient solution to the exposed secondary user problem in cognitive radio. By intentionally creating artificial fading through reconfigurable ESPAR antennas, SUs can effectively share spectrum even in the presence of strong LoS components. Future work will address practical challenges such as obtaining Channel State Information (CSI) for primary users and exploring blind interference alignment techniques.
Summary updated