Random Aerial Beamforming for Underlay Cognitive Radio With Exposed Secondary Users

Ahmed M. Alaa, Mahmoud H. Ismail, Hazim Tawfik

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of reduced capacity in cognitive radio systems when direct line-of-sight (LoS) interference exists between primary and secondary users. They propose a novel "Random Aerial Beamforming" (RAB) technique using reconfigurable ESPAR antennas to artificially induce channel fluctuations, thereby mitigating LoS interference and even exploiting it to improve performance, especially in multi-user scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In underlay cognitive radio, secondary users (SUs) share spectrum with primary users (PUs) while ensuring interference to PUs remains below a certain threshold. A key challenge arises when there's a direct Line-of-Sight (LoS) path between the SU and the PU receiver, or vice-versa. This LoS component, often modeled by a Rician distribution, leads to a limited dynamic range in the interference channels. This lack of fluctuation makes it difficult for SUs to opportunistically transmit during favorable channel conditions, significantly hindering their achievable capacity. This problem is termed the "exposed secondary user problem," where the SU is essentially "exposed" to the PU's interference. The paper also extends this to a multi-user setting, showing how LoS interference degrades the benefits of multiuser diversity.

Methods

The core innovation is Random Aerial Beamforming (RAB). This technique leverages Electronically Steerable Parasitic Array Radiator (ESPAR) antennas. ESPAR antennas are unique because they use a single RF chain but can reconfigure their radiation patterns by adjusting reactive loads. The paper views the ESPAR's orthonormal basis patterns as "virtual dumb antennas." RAB works by randomly varying the weights assigned to these virtual antennas over time. This randomization effectively creates artificial fluctuations in the interference channels, mimicking the behavior of fading channels and overcoming the limitations imposed by dominant LoS components.

For the multi-user case, RAB is used to induce "opportunistic nulling," where SUs can exploit the induced fluctuations to minimize interference to PUs, thereby improving multiuser diversity. A variation called "smart basis patterns" is also introduced to maintain the reliability of the SU-to-SU link while still inducing fluctuations in interference channels.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on analytical derivations and numerical simulations based on established channel models (Rician, Rayleigh).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LoS interference is a significant bottleneck: Dominant LoS components in interference channels drastically reduce the dynamic range of fluctuations, negating the benefits of opportunistic transmission in cognitive radio.
  • ESPAR antennas are key enablers: Their reconfigurable nature and single RF chain make them ideal for compact, low-cost mobile devices to implement advanced beamforming techniques.
  • Artificial fluctuations are powerful: Randomly varying antenna weights (RAB) can effectively "fake" fading, restoring the dynamic range needed for opportunistic communication.
  • Exploiting interference: RAB can not only mitigate LoS interference but also be used to improve multiuser diversity through opportunistic nulling.
  • Multiuser capacity scaling: LoS interference degrades the capacity scaling law from log(N) to log(log(N)), but RAB can restore it to log(N).

Key Results

  • Capacity Restoration: RAB can make LoS interference "transparent," achieving capacity comparable to symmetric Rayleigh channels.
  • Multiuser Diversity Gain: In multi-user scenarios, RAB restores the log(N) capacity scaling law, which is hindered by LoS interference to log(log(N)).
  • Exploiting Interference: With just two basis patterns, RAB can improve multiuser diversity gain beyond what's achievable with Rayleigh fading.
  • Practicality: The proposed RAB scheme using ESPAR antennas is suitable for compact, low-cost mobile terminals due to its single RF chain requirement.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Channel State Information (CSI): While the proposed schemes require overall CSI for power allocation, the paper assumes perfect knowledge of channels at the SU transmitter and receiver. Obtaining this perfect CSI in real-world scenarios can be challenging.
  • Complexity of RAB: While RAB is presented as a solution for compact devices, the implementation of random weight adjustments and the associated control mechanisms might introduce some complexity.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending the analysis to cognitive MAC channels and exploring the deployment of reconfigurable antennas for blind interference alignment. They also mention investigating the impact of different numbers of basis patterns on the capacity scaling and the effectiveness of artificial diversity.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we introduce the exposed secondary-user (SU) problem in underlay cognitive radio systems, where both the secondary-to-primary and primary-to-secondary channels have a line-of-sight (LoS) component. Based on a Rician model for the LoS channels, we show, both analytically and numerically, that LoS interference hinders the achievable SU capacity when interference constraints are imposed at the primary user (PU) receiver. This is caused by the poor dynamic range of interference channel fluctuations when a dominant LoS component exists. To improve the capacity of such a system, we propose the use of an electronically steerable parasitic array radiator (ESPAR) antenna at the secondary terminals. An ESPAR antenna involves a single radio frequency (RF) chain and has a reconfigurable radiation pattern that is controlled by assigning arbitrary weights to $M$ orthonormal basis radiation patterns via altering a set of reactive loads. By viewing the orthonormal patterns as multiple virtual dumb antennas, we randomly vary their weights over time, creating artificial channel fluctuations that can perfectly eliminate the undesired impact of LoS interference. This scheme is termed as random aerial beamforming (RAB) and is well suited for compact and low-cost mobile terminals as it uses a single RF chain. Moreover, we investigate the exposed-SU problem in a multiuser setting, showing that LoS interference hinders multiuser interference diversity and affects the growth rate of the SU capacity as a function of the number of users. Using RAB, we show that LoS interference can, in fact, be exploited to improve multiuser diversity by boosting the effective number of users.
BibTeX
@article{alaa2016random,
  author = {Ahmed M. Alaa and Mahmoud H. Ismail and Hazim Tawfik},
  title = {{Random Aerial Beamforming for Underlay Cognitive Radio With Exposed Secondary Users}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology},
  year = {2016},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=23XI2Nl7rB},
}
Figure