Abstract
Conference travel contributes to the climate footprint of academic research. Here, we provide a quantitative estimate of the carbon emissions associated with conference attendance by analyzing travel data from participants of 10 international conferences in the field of magnetic resonance, namely EUROMAR, ENC and ICMRBS. We find that attending a EUROMAR conference produces, on average, more than 1 t CO2 eq. For the analyzed conferences outside Europe, the corresponding value is about 2-3 times higher, on average, with intercontinental trips amounting to up to 5 t. We compare these conference-related emissions to other activities associated with research and show that conference travel is a substantial portion of the total climate footprint of a researcher in magnetic resonance. We explore several strategies to reduce these emissions, including the impact of selecting conference venues more strategically and the possibility of decentralized conferences. Through a detailed comparison of train versus air travel - accounting for both direct and infrastructure-related emissions - we demonstrate that train travel offers considerable carbon savings. These data may provide a basis for strategic choices of future conferences in the field and for individuals deciding on their conference attendance.
Introduction
While the academic community is increasingly aware of climate change, the specific contribution of research activities—particularly conference travel—remains under-quantified. In fields like Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR), which require heavy instrumentation and global collaboration, there is a tension between the professional necessity of networking and the urgent need to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. This study provides a quantitative look at the environmental cost of scientific discourse by analyzing a decade of travel data from major Magnetic Resonance (MR) conferences.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-step quantitative approach:
- Trajectory Analysis: Participant lists from 10 major international MR conferences (EUROMAR, ENC, and ICMRBS) spanning 2016–2025 were compiled, assuming travel originated from the participant's home institution.
- Emission Modeling: Tools like Carbontracer and Ecopassenger converted travel distances into $\text{CO}_{2\text{eq}}$.
- Holistic Accounting: The study incorporates indirect emissions (infrastructure construction and maintenance) and the Radiative Forcing Index (RFI) for aviation, which accounts for the heightened impact of emissions at high altitudes.
- Comparative Analysis: Travel emissions were compared to the operational footprint of a typical NMR lab using the R-NMR project calculator and institutional sustainability metrics from the Institute of Science and Technology Austria (ISTA).
Results and Discussion
The analysis reveals that a single intercontinental trip can emit up to 5 tonnes of $\text{CO}_{2\text{eq}}$, which effectively consumes a researcher's entire estimated sustainable annual carbon budget (~4.5 t $\text{CO}_{2\text{eq}}$) required to limit global warming to 1.5°C.
The Impact of Venue Selection
The "Center of Mass" of the attendee population significantly influences the total footprint. Selecting a central venue (e.g., Frankfurt or Paris) for a European conference can halve average per-participant emissions compared to remote locations by shortening distances and making rail a viable option for more people.
As shown in the cumulative probability plots, conferences held in regions with high local concentrations of researchers (like EUROMAR in Europe) show a much higher proportion of short-distance trips compared to intercontinental meetings like ICMRBS or ENC-ISMAR.
Key Quantitative Findings
- Average Footprint: Attending a European conference (EUROMAR) produces ~1.2–1.3 t $\text{CO}_{2\text{eq}}$ per person. For conferences outside Europe, this jumps to 3–5 t $\text{CO}_{2\text{eq}}$.
- Rail vs. Air: Choosing a train over a plane for the same European route offers a 75% to 95% reduction in emissions, even when accounting for infrastructure.
- Decentralization Potential: Modeling a "two-site" conference suggests a potential 25% reduction in total travel emissions.
- Virtual Meetings: Online conferencing reduces the footprint by 2 to 3 orders of magnitude (~1.6 kg $\text{CO}_{2\text{eq}}$ for an 8-hour virtual day vs. hundreds of kilograms for in-person attendance).
Conclusion
Conference travel is a substantial portion of a researcher's total climate footprint, often outweighing the electricity required to run a high-tech laboratory for an entire year. While virtual meetings reduce footprints by orders of magnitude, they may lack the networking value of in-person events. Strategic venue selection, decentralized "hub" models, and a shift to rail travel are essential strategies for reducing the field's climate impact. Future work should focus on quantifying the "scientific value" of conferences to better weigh it against their carbon costs.
Summary updated