Reply on RC2

Paul SchandaOpenalex Unknown 2025 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract Conference travel contributes to the climate footprint of academic research. Here, we provide a quantitative estimate of the carbon emissions associated with conference attendance by analyzing travel data from participants of ten international conferences in the field of magnetic resonance, namely EUROMAR, ENC and ICMRBS. We find that attending a EUROMAR conference produces on average approximately 1 ton CO2eq. For the analysed conferences outside Europe the corresponding value is about 2–3 times higher. We compare these conference-related emissions to other activities associated to research, and show that conference travel is a substantial portion of the total climate footprint of a researcher in magnetic resonance. We explore several strategies to reduce these emissions, including the impact of selecting conference venues more strategically and the possibility of decentralized conferences. Through a detailed comparison of train versus air travel — accounting for both direct and infrastructure-related emissions — we demonstrate that train travel offers considerable carbon savings. This data may provide a basis for strategic choices of future conferences in the field and for individuals deciding on their conference attendance.

Introduction

While the scientific community is increasingly aware of the climate crisis, academic research itself has a significant carbon footprint. In fields like Magnetic Resonance (NMR), focus is often placed on the energy consumption of high-field magnets or the production of consumables. However, the "hidden" cost of international travel remains poorly quantified. This study addresses this gap by providing a data-driven analysis of the carbon emissions associated with attending major international NMR conferences, moving the conversation from vague awareness to quantitative strategy.

Methodology

The researchers analyzed participant data from ten international conferences held between 2016 and 2025, including EUROMAR, ENC, and ICMRBS.

  • Trajectory Mapping: Participant affiliations were used to determine travel origins and mapped to conference venues.
  • Emission Modeling: Distances were converted into CO2 equivalents (CO2eq) using the Carbontracer API, accounting for indirect emissions (infrastructure maintenance) and radiative forcing at high altitudes.
  • Comparative Analysis: Conference travel was compared to other research activities, such as running NMR spectrometers, using data from the ISTA sustainability office.

Geographical Distribution and Carbon Impact

The analysis revealed significant differences in the carbon footprint based on conference location and attendee demographics. For instance, attending a EUROMAR (European) conference produces roughly 1 ton of CO2eq per person. In contrast, conferences held outside Europe, such as those in North America, result in footprints 2–3 times higher (2–3 tons CO2eq).

Attendee distribution by continent for a European conference.

The "local effect" is prominent: hosting a conference in a specific region significantly increases local attendance, which lowers the average per-person footprint but does not mitigate the high impact of long-haul international attendees.

Attendee distribution and travel distance frequency for ENC/ISMAR 2025.

Key Insights

  • The Carbon Budget: The IPCC suggests an annual per-person carbon budget of ~4.5 tons CO2eq to limit warming to 1.5°C. A single transatlantic trip can exhaust this entire yearly allowance.
  • Travel vs. Lab Work: For a typical NMR researcher, attending one 5-day conference in Europe has a larger carbon impact than their share of running three high-field NMR spectrometers for an entire year.
  • The Train Advantage: Even accounting for infrastructure costs, train travel is 4 to 20 times more efficient than flying.
  • Strategic Venue Selection: Choosing central locations (e.g., Frankfurt or Paris) for European conferences can reduce total emissions by over 50% compared to remote locations.

Strategies for Reduction

Modeling a "two-site" decentralized conference suggested a potential emission reduction of approximately 25%. Furthermore, virtual meetings reduce the footprint by a factor of 1,000 to 3,000, though they lack social serendipity.

Limitations and Future Directions

The study assumes an 800 km cutoff for train travel and direct flights, which may underestimate real-world emissions (connecting flights add ~20% more CO2). Future work should explore "hub-and-spoke" models and encourage organizers to include estimated travel footprints in venue bidding processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> Conference travel contributes to the climate footprint of academic research. Here, we provide a quantitative estimate of the carbon emissions associated with conference attendance by analyzing travel data from participants of ten international conferences in the field of magnetic resonance, namely EUROMAR, ENC and ICMRBS. We find that attending a EUROMAR conference produces on average approximately 1 ton CO<sub>2</sub>eq. For the analysed conferences outside Europe the corresponding value is about 2&ndash;3 times higher. We compare these conference-related emissions to other activities associated to research, and show that conference travel is a substantial portion of the total climate footprint of a researcher in magnetic resonance. We explore several strategies to reduce these emissions, including the impact of selecting conference venues more strategically and the possibility of decentralized conferences. Through a detailed comparison of train versus air travel &mdash; accounting for both direct and infrastructure-related emissions &mdash; we demonstrate that train travel offers considerable carbon savings. This data may provide a basis for strategic choices of future conferences in the field and for individuals deciding on their conference attendance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schanda2025reply,
  author = {Paul Schanda},
  title = {{Reply on RC2}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.5194/mr-2025-9-ac3},
}
Figure