Beyond the carbon footprint: Virtual conferences increase diversity, equity, and inclusion

Matthew J. Skiles, Euijin Yang, Orad Reshef, Diego Muñoz, Diana Cintron, Mary Laura Lind, Alexander M. Rush, Andrea M. Armani, Kasey M. Faust, Manish KumarResearch Square 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Scientific conferences are essential for knowledge dissemination and professional networking, yet they carry significant environmental and social costs. This study performs a meta-analysis of STEM conferences that transitioned to virtual formats during the COVID-19 pandemic. By comparing demographic and travel data, we demonstrate that virtual formats significantly lower barriers to entry, leading to increased participation from women, students, and researchers from non-research-intensive countries. Our findings suggest that the "diversity dividend" of virtual meetings is a critical factor in building a more equitable global scientific community.

Introduction

For decades, the in-person conference has been the cornerstone of scientific exchange. However, this "legacy" model is increasingly scrutinized for its massive carbon footprint and its role in perpetuating global inequities. Attending a major international meeting often requires significant financial resources and the ability to travel, creating a high barrier for many in the global scientific community. The shift to virtual formats during the COVID-19 pandemic provided a unique opportunity to quantify how removing these physical barriers impacts diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI).

The Economic and Social Barriers of In-Person Meetings

The exclusionary nature of in-person events is often rooted in geography and wealth. For a researcher based in the United States, attending a domestic conference typically costs about 3% of the annual per capita GDP. In stark contrast, a researcher from Africa or parts of Asia attending that same conference may face costs soaring to 142% of their annual per capita GDP.

Beyond finances, the "obligations of presence"—requiring researchers to be away from home for extended periods—disproportionately affects those with childcare and domestic responsibilities. This burden still falls predominantly on women, creating a structural barrier to career advancement. Virtual formats effectively zero out these disparities by allowing participation from any location with an internet connection.

Meta-Analysis Methodology

This research involved a quantitative meta-analysis of three major STEM conference series that transitioned to virtual formats in 2020: the International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR), the American Astronomical Society (AAS) summer meeting, and the North American Membrane Society (NAMS) annual conference. The Photonics Online Meetup (POM) served as a control for an "always-virtual" format. The team utilized registration data, survey responses, and tools like the Google Maps API and the Hotel Carbon Measurement Initiative (HCMI) to calculate travel distances and carbon footprints. Gender was assessed through a combination of voluntary survey data and name-based estimation via the Gender API.

Results: The Diversity Dividend

The transition to virtual formats led to explosive growth in overall attendance: 118% for ICLR, 97% for AAS, and 41% for NAMS. More importantly, the demographic makeup of these delegations shifted significantly toward greater inclusion:

  • Gender Parity: Attendance by women increased by 66% to 253% across the analyzed conferences. Survey responses indicated that the ability to balance professional participation with domestic responsibilities was a primary driver for this increase.
  • Geographic Diversity: Participation from scientists in "non-research-intensive" nations (those outside the top 10 in the Nature Index) increased by 29% to 482%.
  • Early-Career Engagement: The proportion of student attendees rose from a historical average of 29% to 43%.

Environmental Impact

The carbon reduction was near-total. For the 2020 virtual ICLR, the total carbon footprint was estimated at just 0.80 tonnes of CO2e (derived from computer processing and server use). In contrast, the estimated footprint for an in-person version of the same event would have reached thousands of tonnes. To put this in perspective, a single international flight for one attendee can exceed the entire annual carbon budget recommended for an individual.

Challenges and the Future of Scientific Exchange

Despite the gains in DEI and sustainability, virtual conferences face a significant "networking gap." Between 75% and 96% of surveyed attendees still preferred in-person interactions for networking, describing virtual alternatives as "contrived" or "inauthentic." Furthermore, the format of the virtual event matters; asynchronous (pre-recorded) content is far more effective at accommodating global time zones than live-only sessions, which can still exclude researchers in conflicting regions.

Ultimately, this study proves that "visibility" in the scientific community should not require a trans-oceanic flight. While hybrid models—utilizing local hubs connected to a global virtual event—may offer a middle ground, the success of virtual formats in 2020 provides a blueprint for a more accessible and sustainable future for global research.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Among many roles, conferences disseminate research, grow professional networks, and train employees. They also significantly contribute to climate change due to their sizable carbon footprint. More recently, additional negative aspects have surfaced. Namely, they present significant barriers to achieving Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI). Here, we perform a meta-analysis of events that transitioned to virtual formats during the COVID-19 pandemic and show that this approach may provide a solution. Our analysis compared demographic and travel data of the same scientific conferences. When evaluating DEI, we considered factors including cost, gender, career stage, and geographic location. Costs associated with attending in-person conferences varied between 3% to 142% of attendees’ regional annual per capita Gross Domestic Product (GDP). An increase in the fractional make-up of 2020 virtual conference delegations was observed for students (29% to 43%). Notable increases in attendance were observed for women (66% to 253% increase) and non-research-intensive countries (29% to 482% increase).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{skiles2020beyond,
  author = {Matthew J. Skiles and Euijin Yang and Orad Reshef and Diego Muñoz and Diana Cintron and Mary Laura Lind and Alexander M. Rush and Andrea M. Armani and Kasey M. Faust and Manish Kumar},
  title = {{Beyond the carbon footprint: Virtual conferences increase diversity, equity, and inclusion}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-106316/v1},
}
Figure