A spatio-temporal analysis for power grid resilience to extreme weather

Shixiang Zhu, Rui Yao, Yao Xie, Feng Qiu, Xuan Wu

Abstract

In recent years, extreme weather events frequently cause large-scale power outages, affecting millions of customers for extended duration. Resilience, the capability of withstanding, adapting to, and recovering from a large-scale disruption, has become a top priority for the power sector. However, a quantitative understanding of power grid resilience is still lacking. This study takes a data-driven approach by exploring real-world power outage data and weather records. We propose a spatio-temporal random process model that identifies key resilience capabilities and interdependence between service areas. Our analysis shows that weather only directly causes a small portion of outages; the majority result from planning vulnerabilities and the accumulation of weather effects, which then propagate through the grid.

Introduction

While "resilience" is a central theme in modern energy policy, quantifying it remains a significant challenge. Most existing research is either purely conceptual or focuses on isolated technical components, failing to capture the system-level dynamics of a complex power grid. Two major hurdles persist: the scarcity of high-resolution, real-world failure data and the inherent complexity of non-linear, cumulative weather impacts. This paper addresses these gaps by using a data-driven approach to measure four key aspects of resilience: planning vulnerability, maintenance sufficiency, criticality, and recoverability.

Conceptual Framework: The Resilience Trapezoid

To quantify resilience, the researchers developed the "Resilience Trapezoid" framework. This model conceptualizes a grid's response to an extreme event across five distinct states: prevention, degradation, degraded, restoration, and adaptation.

The Resilience Trapezoid conceptual model illustrating the five states of a grid's functionality over time during an extreme event.

This framework allows for the identification of specific resilience capabilities, such as infrastructural resistance (the ability to withstand the initial hit) and operational recoverability (the speed and efficiency of restoration).

Methodology

The study proposes a spatio-temporal non-homogeneous multivariate Poisson process. To capture the non-linear relationship between weather and outages, a Deep Neural Network (DNN) is integrated to estimate the "base intensity" of outages.

A key innovation is the distinction between direct and indirect impacts. The model separates outages directly triggered by weather from "triggering effects," where a failure in one node cascades into neighboring areas. Furthermore, the model incorporates an "accumulation effect," using a discounted sum of recent weather data to account for how stress builds up on infrastructure over time before failure occurs.

Datasets

The analysis leverages high-resolution datasets covering three major events: the 2018 Nor'easters in Massachusetts, Hurricane Michael in Georgia, and Hurricane Isaias in the Carolinas.

  • Outage Data: Quarter-hourly customer-level records from PowerOutage.us, encompassing over 1,100 geographical units and 9.6 million customers.
  • Weather Data: High-Resolution Rapid Refresh (HRRR) data with 34 variables at a 3km resolution.

Spatio-Temporal Analysis and Key Insights

The model reveals several critical dynamics of grid failure. One of the most significant findings is the "Disruption Tolerance Capacity" (DTC). Outage ratios do not increase linearly with weather intensity; instead, they remain low until a cumulative stress threshold is reached, after which outages spike sharply in a sigmoid pattern.

Spatio-temporal evolution of power outages in Massachusetts during the March 2018 Nor'easter, illustrating the lag between peak weather intensity and peak outages.

As shown in the spatio-temporal maps, there is a notable "lag factor." Large-scale outages typically peak 12–36 hours after the peak of the extreme weather event. This confirms that resilience acts as a "time-buying" mechanism that eventually becomes overwhelmed by cumulative damage.

Furthermore, the study identifies "propagation hubs"—often mid-sized urban areas rather than major metropolitan centers—that serve as critical bottlenecks. Protecting these specific nodes could reduce total customer outages by approximately 45.5%. Similarly, hardening infrastructure in the top 12 most vulnerable units could reduce outages by nearly 50%.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that massive blackouts are often the result of local failures propagating through critical hubs rather than direct weather hits alone. By identifying these hubs and quantifying the cumulative effects of weather, utilities can move beyond conceptual resilience to targeted, actionable interventions. Future work will aim to integrate physical grid topology and geographical features to further refine these predictive capabilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

In recent years, extreme weather events frequently cause large-scale power outages, affecting millions of customers for extended duration. Resilience, the capability of withstanding, adapting to, and recovering from a large-scale disruption, has becomes a top priority for power sector, in addition to economics and sustainability. However, a good understanding on the power grid resilience is still lacking, as most approaches still either stay on the conceptual level, yielding no actionable results, or focus on a particular technical issue, revealing little insights on the system level. In this study, we take a quantitative approach to understanding power system resilience by directly exploring real power outage data. We first give a qualitative analysis on power system resilience and large-scale power outage process, identifying key elements and developing conceptual models to describe grid resilience. Then we propose a spatio-temporal random process model, with parameters representing the identified resilience capabilities and interdependence between service areas. We perform analyse using our model on a set of large-scale customer-level quarter-hourly historical power outage data and corresponding weather records from three major service territories on the east-coast of the United States under normal daily operations and three major extreme weather events. It has shown that weather only directly cause a small portion of power outages, and the peak of power outages usually lag the weather events. Planning vulnerability and excessively accumulation of weather effects play a key role in causing sustained local outages to the power system in a short time. The local outages caused by weather events will later propagate to broader regions through the power grid, which subsequently lead to a much larger number of non-local power outages.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2021spatio,
  author = {Shixiang Zhu and Rui Yao and Yao Xie and Feng Qiu and Xuan Wu},
  title = {{A spatio-temporal analysis for power grid resilience to extreme weather}},
  booktitle = {INFORMS},
  year = {2021},
}
Figure