Abstract
Psychological and sleep disturbances are common among medical staff at work during the COVID-19 pandemic. This study examines the mental health and sleep quality of 236 vaccinated medical workers in Shanghai during the 2022 Omicron wave. Findings indicate that frontline and second-line staff face significantly higher rates of depression, anxiety, and insomnia compared to their colleagues at home, with nurses and female staff bearing the heaviest psychological burden. More psychological intervention should be administered for frontline medical staff (FMS), especially for nurses.
Introduction
While the global impact of COVID-19 on healthcare workers is well-documented, the 2022 Shanghai Omicron outbreak presented a unique scenario: a highly vaccinated workforce facing a massive, rapid surge under strict lockdown conditions. This study sought to fill a gap in understanding how different levels of exposure—specifically comparing first-line medical staff (FMS), second-line staff (SMS), and those quarantined at home (HMS)—affected psychological well-being. By distinguishing between these roles, the research aims to identify which specific groups of medical professionals require the most urgent mental health support.
Methods
A cross-sectional online survey was conducted in May 2022 among 236 vaccinated medical workers. The cohort was divided into three groups:
- FMS (n=85): Staff in mobile cabin hospitals or designated COVID-19 hospitals.
- SMS (n=82): Staff in general hospital departments (clinics, ER, wards).
- HMS (n=69): Staff stayed at home due to community containment measures.
The researchers utilized four validated instruments to quantify distress: the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9) for depression, the Generalized Anxiety Disorder-7 (GAD-7) for anxiety, the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) for sleep quality, and the Athens Insomnia Scale (AIS) for insomnia severity. Binary logistic regression was used to isolate independent risk factors, accounting for demographic variables such as age, gender, and education.
Key Results and Insights
The prevalence of disturbances across the entire group was alarmingly high, with 52.1% reporting depressive symptoms, 44.1% anxiety symptoms, 55.9% poor sleep quality, and 49.2% insomnia.
Workplace as a Primary Stressor
Being physically at work (FMS or SMS) was a stronger predictor of poor mental health than almost any other factor. Even though the "at-home" staff were also under lockdown, their psychological outcomes were significantly better. Compared to HMS, FMS were over 24 times more likely to report poor sleep (OR = 24.779, p < 0.001) and insomnia (OR = 24.111, p < 0.001), and showed a 5-fold increase in depressive symptoms (OR = 5.186, p < 0.001).
Frontline Sleep Deprivation
While both FMS and SMS suffered, FMS staff had significantly worse sleep quality than SMS. This is likely attributable to the high-pressure, high-risk environment of "mobile cabin" hospitals compared to general hospital wards.
Vulnerable Subgroups
- Nurses: Nurses were significantly more likely to experience poor sleep and insomnia than doctors, possibly due to longer shifts and closer patient contact for procedures like sputum collection.
- Gender: Female medical staff were nearly three times more likely (OR = 2.772) to experience anxiety symptoms than their male counterparts.
- Education: Higher levels of education were associated with better sleep quality, suggesting that specialized training or professional seniority might provide a buffer of psychological resilience.
Discussion and Limitations
The study captures a "snapshot" in time during a specific wave, and the sample size of 236 participants may not represent the entire medical population of Shanghai. Additionally, the cross-sectional design prevents definitive causal conclusions, and self-reporting may introduce selection bias. Future longitudinal studies are needed to track whether these symptoms resolve or lead to long-term PTSD and burnout.
Conclusion
Psychological disturbances are highly prevalent among medical staff working during pandemic surges. Psychological interventions should not be "one-size-fits-all." Policy recommendations should specifically target frontline nurses who are at the highest risk for sleep and psychological disturbances.
Summary updated