Abstract
In the case of an unexpected pandemic, the mental health of healthcare providers is not optimistic. This situation still exists more than 2 years after the global outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic. Therefore, the physical and mental health of long-term healthcare providers working in a square cabin hospital still needs monitoring.
Introduction
The "square cabin" hospital (or Fangcang) became a cornerstone of China's COVID-19 response, designed for rapid isolation and treatment of large patient volumes. However, these environments are notoriously high-stress, characterized by intense workloads, dense populations, and strict isolation from family. While early pandemic research focused on the "panic phase" of 2020, this study investigates the health status of workers two years later, during the 2022 Omicron wave in Shanghai. The authors sought to determine if "pandemic normalization"—the implementation of better guidelines and professional training—successfully mitigated the mental health risks for frontline staff.
Methods and Participants
The researchers conducted a cross-sectional online survey via WeChat between March and May 2022. The primary dataset consists of survey responses from 142 frontline healthcare providers in Shanghai. To provide context, the authors compared these results against normative data from previous surveys of medical workers conducted during earlier stages of the pandemic.
Participants were evaluated using several validated psychometric tools:
- Insomnia Severity Index (ISI): To quantify sleep disruption.
- GAD-7 & PHQ-9: Standardized screens for Generalized Anxiety Disorder and Depression.
- CD-RISC: To measure psychological resilience.
- Homemade Somatic Symptom Scale: A 46-item survey designed to capture physical discomforts across respiratory, digestive, skin, and ocular systems.
Key Insights
The Resilience Buffer
Psychological resilience was the strongest predictor of mental health. Higher resilience scores were significantly associated with lower odds of insomnia, anxiety, and depression. This suggests that mental "grit" is a critical clinical variable in high-stress medical environments.
Age and Sleep Quality
Healthcare providers under the age of 40 were significantly more likely to suffer from insomnia than their older colleagues. This suggests that experience or different life-stage stressors play a role in sleep quality during a crisis.
PPE-Induced Somatization
The study highlights a clear link between protective gear and physical symptoms. The high incidence of dry eyes (57.8%) and headaches (29.6%) was attributed to the prolonged use of tight-fitting goggles, while lumbar strain (47.2%) was linked to the restricted movement caused by full-body protective suits.
Key Results
- Mental Health Prevalence: Insomnia was reported by 66.20% of participants, depression by 45.07%, and anxiety by 27.46%.
- Physical Symptoms: The most common complaints were dry eyes (57.75%), lumbar muscle strain (47.18%), and dry mouth (35.92%).
- Statistical Predictors: Age (>40 years) and high resilience scores were statistically significant protective factors against insomnia.
- Comparative Data: Frontline workers had significantly higher insomnia scores but lower anxiety and depression scores compared to control groups from earlier in the pandemic. This suggests that while mental preparation has improved, the physical toll of the environment remains severe.
Conclusion and Future Work
While "pandemic normalization" has helped workers handle the psychological load more effectively than in 2020, the physical and sleep-related toll remains high. The authors acknowledge limitations including the small sample size (n=142) and the cross-sectional design. Future research should focus on longitudinal surveys and testing specific interventions, such as improved PPE ergonomics and targeted resilience training, to protect staff in future public health emergencies.
Summary updated