A study on differences about the influencing factors of depressive symptoms between medical staff and residents during 2022 city-wide temporary static management period to fighting against COVID-19 pandemic in Shanghai

Ying Zhao, Yiran Tao, Xiwen Bao, Qiang Ding, Changyan Han, Tingkun Luo, Weijia Zhang, Jinhua Sun, Jiali ShiFrontiers in Public Health 2023 · DOI

Abstract: There are differences in the factors influencing depression symptoms between medical staff and residents during the 2022 city-wide temporary static management period to fighting against the COVID-19 pandemic in Shanghai. We should pay special attention to those with increasing internet usage time and daytime dysfunction in medical staff working in a special environment such as the COVID-19 pandemic.

Introduction

The 2022 Shanghai "static management" period, an unprecedented city-wide lockdown lasting over two months, created a unique environment of social isolation and professional strain. While the mental health impacts of COVID-19 have been studied globally, this research specifically compares the risk factors for depression between frontline medical staff and the general resident population. By identifying distinct patterns of symptoms, the study aims to provide a more nuanced understanding of psychological vulnerability during extreme social disruptions.

Methods

The researchers conducted an online cross-sectional survey of 840 participants (120 medical staff and 720 residents) in Shanghai between April and June 2022. The study utilized several validated psychological instruments:

  • PHQ-9: To measure depressive symptoms.
  • GAD-7: To assess anxiety levels.
  • PSQI: To evaluate sleep quality across multiple dimensions.
  • Self-compiled questionnaire: To capture demographics and changes in internet usage.

A key feature of the methodology was the use of Latent Class Analysis (LCA). Unlike traditional methods that rely on a single aggregate score, LCA is a person-centered approach that groups individuals based on their specific patterns of responses to the PHQ-9 items, allowing for a more sensitive classification of mental health status.

Results and Key Insights

The LCA revealed that the population naturally split into two distinct groups: a "low-depressive symptoms" group (Class 1, 44.9%) and a "high-depressive symptoms" group (Class 2, 55.1%).

Response probability values of latent classes of depressive symptoms across PHQ-9 items.

Frontline Vulnerability

Medical staff were significantly more likely to fall into the high-depressive category (65.8%) compared to residents (53.3%). This "double burden" likely stems from the combination of physical exhaustion and the psychological stress of potential infection while serving on the front lines.

Predictors of Depression

For both groups, anxiety and sleep quality were major predictors of depressive symptoms. As illustrated in the comparison of GAD-7 and PSQI scores, individuals in the high-depressive group exhibited significantly higher levels of anxiety and sleep disturbance.

Boxplots comparing GAD-7 and PSQI scores, illustrating the higher levels of anxiety and sleep disturbance associated with the high-depressive group.

Specific findings include:

  • Sleep as a Critical Factor: For medical staff, "daytime dysfunction" (difficulty staying awake or productive) was a massive predictor of depression (OR 6.22), while serious sleep disturbance had an even higher Odds Ratio of 8.88.
  • The Internet Usage Trap: Increased internet usage was a risk factor for both groups, but the impact was more severe for medical staff, who were 3.86 times more likely to be in the high-depressive group if their usage increased. This may be linked to "doomscrolling" or a reliance on digital spaces to replace lost physical connections.
  • The Education Paradox: For residents, higher education was actually a risk factor for depression, possibly due to greater professional disruption or a more acute sense of stagnation during the lockdown.

Discussion and Limitations

The study highlights that while both groups suffered, the drivers of their distress differed. Protective factors for residents included being older (OR 0.95) and being married (OR 0.69).

However, the authors acknowledge several limitations. The cross-sectional design means that while correlations are clear, causality cannot be definitively proven. Additionally, the sample size imbalance (fewer medical staff than residents) and the reliance on self-reported data may affect the generalizability of the results beyond the specific context of the Shanghai lockdown.

Conclusion

These findings emphasize the need for targeted mental health support. For medical staff, interventions should focus on sleep hygiene and managing digital consumption. Understanding these distinct risk factors is essential for developing effective psychological support systems during future public health crises.

Summary updated

Abstract

There are differences in the factors influencing depression symptoms between medical staff and residents during the 2022 city-wide temporary static management period to fighting against the COVID-19 pandemic in Shanghai. We should pay special attention to those with increasing internet usage time and daytime dysfunction in medical staff working in a special environment such as the COVID-19 pandemic.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2023study,
  author = {Ying Zhao and Yiran Tao and Xiwen Bao and Qiang Ding and Changyan Han and Tingkun Luo and Weijia Zhang and Jinhua Sun and Jiali Shi},
  title = {{A study on differences about the influencing factors of depressive symptoms between medical staff and residents during 2022 city-wide temporary static management period to fighting against COVID-19 pandemic in Shanghai}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2022.1083144},
}
Figure