Protodiffusion: Classifier-free diffusion guidance with prototype learning

Gulcin Baykal, Halil Faruk Karagoz, Taha Osama A Binhuraib, Gozde Unal

TL;DR

This paper introduces ProtoDiffusion, a novel approach that significantly speeds up the training of diffusion models for image generation by incorporating pre-learned class prototypes as conditioning information. By leveraging these representative prototypes, ProtoDiffusion achieves comparable or better generation quality in a fraction of the training time compared to standard classifier-free diffusion guidance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diffusion models have become a leading technique for generating high-quality images, outperforming previous methods like GANs. However, a major drawback is their substantial computational cost and long training times. While classifier-free guidance has improved efficiency by removing the need for an explicit classifier, it still relies on randomly initialized class embeddings that require extensive training to become effective. This paper tackles the challenge of reducing the training time for diffusion models while maintaining or improving generation quality, specifically for class-conditional image generation.

Methods

ProtoDiffusion employs a two-stage training process:

  • Stage I: Prototype Learning: This stage focuses on learning representative "prototypes" for each class in the dataset. The authors adapt a method by Yang et al. (2018) where a feature extractor (a ResNet-18 in their experiments) and a codebook of prototypes are trained jointly. The goal is to learn a set of prototypes that effectively capture the essence of each class. This stage is remarkably fast, taking only minutes for common datasets.
  • Stage II: Diffusion Model Training: In this stage, the pre-trained prototypes from Stage I are used to initialize the class embeddings for a standard classifier-free diffusion model (based on Ho and Salimans, 2021). Instead of random initialization, these learned prototypes provide a strong, class-representative starting point. The diffusion model is then trained to generate images conditioned on these prototypes and time embeddings. The authors explore two variants: "ProtoDiffusion (Frozen)" where prototypes are not updated during diffusion training, and "ProtoDiffusion (Unfrozen)" where prototypes can be further refined by the diffusion process.

Datasets

The experiments were conducted on the following standard image datasets:

  • CIFAR10: A dataset of 32x32 color images in 10 classes.
  • STL10: A dataset of 96x96 color images in 10 classes, with a smaller number of training images compared to CIFAR10.
  • Tiny ImageNet: A subset of ImageNet with 64x64 images across 200 classes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Prototypes as a "Warm Start": The core idea is that pre-learned, representative class prototypes act as a powerful "warm start" for diffusion model training. This significantly reduces the time needed for the model to learn effective class conditioning.
  • Faster Convergence: The learned prototypes lead to much faster convergence of the diffusion model, achieving comparable or better performance metrics (like FID) in a significantly shorter training period.
  • Prototype Refinement: The "Unfrozen" variant, where prototypes are updated during diffusion training, generally yields better results. This suggests that while pre-learned prototypes provide a great initial boost, allowing them to adapt to the diffusion process further enhances their representativeness and generation quality.
  • Dimensionality Matters: The dimensionality of the prototypes influences performance, with higher dimensions generally leading to better results by capturing more nuanced class information.

Key Results

  • Speedup: ProtoDiffusion achieves the best performance significantly faster than the baseline classifier-free guidance. For example, on CIFAR10, it reaches its best performance in approximately 2 times less time. The prototype learning stage itself is very quick, taking only 2-13 minutes depending on the dataset.
  • Performance: ProtoDiffusion consistently outperforms the baseline in terms of Fréchet Inception Distance (FID) across all tested datasets, indicating better generation quality. While the Inception Score (IS) for Tiny ImageNet was slightly lower than the baseline, the FID was still superior.
  • Quantitative Comparison:
    • CIFAR10: ProtoDiffusion (Unfrozen) achieved an FID of 8.55, compared to the baseline's 11.82.
  • STL10: ProtoDiffusion (Unfrozen) achieved an FID of 22.57, compared to the baseline's 33.86.
  • Tiny ImageNet: ProtoDiffusion (Unfrozen) achieved an FID of 23.07, compared to the baseline's 28.67.
  • Qualitative Results: Visual inspection of generated samples shows that ProtoDiffusion models produce images with better structural consistency compared to the baseline.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Tiny ImageNet Performance: The benefits of prototype learning were less pronounced on the Tiny ImageNet dataset compared to CIFAR10 and STL10. The authors hypothesize this could be due to the complexity of Tiny ImageNet, where the simple neural network used for prototype learning might not be sufficient to capture its intricate characteristics.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation into more complex datasets like Tiny ImageNet to better understand the impact of prototype learning. They also imply that exploring more sophisticated prototype learning architectures could yield even better results.

Summary updated

Abstract

Diffusion models are generative models that have shown significant advantages compared to other generative models in terms of higher generation quality and more stable training. However, the computational need for training diffusion models is considerably increased. In this work, we incorporate prototype learning into diffusion models to achieve high generation quality faster than the original diffusion model. Instead of randomly initialized class embeddings, we use separately learned class prototypes as the conditioning information to guide the diffusion process. We observe that our method, called ProtoDiffusion, achieves better performance in the early stages of training compared to the baseline method, signifying that using the learned prototypes shortens the training time. We demonstrate the performance of ProtoDiffusion using various datasets and experimental settings, achieving the best performance in shorter times across all settings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{baykal2023protodiffusion,
  author = {Gulcin Baykal and Halil Faruk Karagoz and Taha Osama A Binhuraib and Gozde Unal},
  title = {{Protodiffusion: Classifier-free diffusion guidance with prototype learning}},
  booktitle = {Asian Conference on Machine Learning - ACML},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=5HIWoXlktT},
}
Figure