Probing the nonclassical dynamics of a quantum particle in a gravitational field

Martin Plávala, Stefan Nimmrichter, Matthias Kleinmann

Abstract

In quantum mechanics, the time evolution of particles is given by the Schrödinger equation. It is valid in a nonrelativistic regime where the interactions with the particle can be modelled by a potential and quantised fields are not required. This has been verified in countless experiments when the interaction is of electromagnetic origin, but also corrections due to the quantised field are readily observed. When the interaction is due to gravity, then one cannot expect to see effects of the quantised field in current-technology Earth-bound experiments. However, this does not yet guarantee that in the accessible regime, the time evolution is accurately given by the Schrödinger equation. Here we propose to measure the effects of an asymmetric mass configuration on a quantum particle in an interferometer. For this setup we show that with parameters within experimental reach, one can be sensitive to possible deviations from the Schrödinger equation, beyond the already verified lowest-order regime. Performing this experiment will hence directly test the nonclassical behaviour of a quantum particle in the gravitational field.

Introduction

The intersection of quantum mechanics and gravity remains one of the most significant frontiers in modern physics. While the Schrödinger equation accurately describes the behavior of particles under electromagnetic forces, its application to gravitational interactions is typically limited to the "Newtonian" regime. Current experiments, such as those involving falling atoms or neutrons, primarily probe the classical gravitational force. However, it remains unverified whether the Schrödinger equation—and its assumption of unitary, information-preserving evolution—holds true for quantum particles in a gravitational field beyond these lowest-order effects.

The fundamental question is whether gravity, when acting on a quantum system, introduces non-classical or non-unitary components to the evolution. This paper proposes a novel "table-top" experiment designed to move beyond classical force measurements and detect potential deviations predicted by alternative gravity models, such as wavefunction collapse theories or measurement-feedback gravity.

The Proposed Experiment: Asymmetric Mass Configuration

The authors propose utilizing a Mach-Zehnder atom interferometer to test for non-classical gravitational dynamics. In this setup, a single atom (e.g., Caesium) is prepared in a quantum superposition of two paths separated by a distance $\Delta x$. To isolate purely quantum effects, the researchers introduce an asymmetric source mass configuration.

The potential $V$ and the classical phase shift term $\Delta x V'$ as a function of distance. The positions of the source masses $M_1$ and $M_2$ are chosen to manipulate the gravitational landscape around the interferometer arms $|L\rangle$ and $|R\rangle$.

By positioning two macroscopic tungsten masses ($M_1$ and $M_2$) at specific distances ($d_1, d_2$) such that the gravitational force gradients cancel out ($M_1/d_1^2 = M_2/d_2^2$), the "classical" phase shift—associated with the Poisson bracket in phase space—vanishes. This isolation allows for the measurement of the Moyal bracket term, which represents the uniquely quantum part of the evolution.

Theoretical Framework

The study employs a phase-space formulation using Wigner functions to categorize time evolution. The general evolution equation is defined as: $$\dot{W} = \{H, W\} + G_H(W)$$ where $\{H, W\}$ represents the classical Poisson bracket and $G_H$ accounts for any non-classical or non-standard gravitational effects.

The distinction between the Poisson bracket and the Moyal bracket is central to this proposal. In classical mechanics, the evolution of a system in phase space is governed by the Poisson bracket, which depends on the first derivative of the potential. Quantum mechanics introduces higher-order corrections through the Moyal bracket, which involves higher-order derivatives. By nullifying the first-order gradient, the experiment forces the system's evolution to be dominated by these higher-order quantum terms. This setup is particularly sensitive to models like Tilloy-Diósi (measurement-feedback gravity), which predict gravitational dephasing and modified phase shifts.

Results and Experimental Feasibility

Theoretical calculations indicate that even with the classical force canceled, a quantum phase shift frequency of $\omega_Q \approx 0.22$ rad/s should persist under standard Schrödinger evolution. A measured phase shift differing from $\omega_Q$, or an observed exponential decay in the interference pattern (fringe contrast), would provide direct evidence for non-standard gravitational dynamics.

The choice of tungsten masses (20g and 40g) and a Caesium atom is strategic. Tungsten's high density allows for significant gravitational influence within a small spatial footprint. The proposed parameters—10 cm arm separation and multi-second coherence times—are achievable with current state-of-the-art lattice interferometer technology. Modern atomic clocks and interferometers have already demonstrated the necessary coherence times and spatial resolutions to make this experiment feasible.

Discussion and Future Outlook

While the current model uses a one-dimensional approximation, a physical implementation would require accounting for 3D geometry and the atom's specific trajectory. Additionally, environmental noise (vibrations, magnetic fields) and short-range forces like Casimir-Polder effects must be mitigated, perhaps by maintaining a 1mm gap between the masses and the atom's path.

Despite these challenges, the proposed experiment offers a clear path toward probing the quantum nature of gravity. Future iterations could involve varying initial states and interaction times to fully map the gravitational superoperator $G_H$, potentially revealing whether gravity truly adheres to the unitary evolution of the Schrödinger equation.

Summary updated

Abstract

In quantum mechanics, the time evolution of particles is given by the Schrödinger equation. It is valid in a nonrelativistic regime where the interactions with the particle can be modelled by a potential and quantised fields are not required. This has been verified in countless experiments when the interaction is of electromagnetic origin, but also corrections due to the quantised field are readily observed. When the interaction is due to gravity, then one cannot expect to see effects of the quantised field in current-technology Earth-bound experiments. However, this does not yet guarantee that in the accessible regime, the time evolution is accurately given by the Schrödinger equation. Here we propose to measure the effects of an asymmetric mass configuration on a quantum particle in an interferometer. For this setup we show that with parameters within experimental reach, one can be sensitive to possible deviations from the Schrödinger equation, beyond the already verified lowest-order regime. Performing this experiment will hence directly test the nonclassical behaviour of a quantum particle in the gravitational field.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{plavala2025probing,
  author = {Martin Plávala and Stefan Nimmrichter and Matthias Kleinmann},
  title = {{Probing the nonclassical dynamics of a quantum particle in a gravitational field}},
  booktitle = {Classical},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1088/1361-6382/ae1b5c},
}
Figure