Probing the nonclassical dynamics of a quantum particle in a gravitational field

Martin Plávala, Stefan Nimmrichter, Matthias Kleinmann

TL;DR

Researchers have proposed a clever "table-top" experiment to test whether gravity follows the Schrödinger equation at the quantum level. By placing source masses asymmetrically around an atom interferometer, they show it is possible to cancel out the classical gravitational force, leaving behind a purely quantum phase shift that could reveal if gravity behaves non-classically or even non-unitarily.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While quantum mechanics is incredibly successful at describing electromagnetism, its relationship with gravity remains one of the biggest mysteries in physics. In most experiments, we treat gravity simply as a classical background potential in the Schrödinger equation. While this "Newtonian" approximation works for current observations, we don't actually know if the Schrödinger equation—which assumes unitary (information-preserving) evolution—is the complete story for quantum particles in a gravitational field.

Existing experiments (like those with neutrons or falling atoms) mostly probe the "classical" part of the interaction—essentially measuring the gravitational force. This paper seeks to move beyond that "lowest-order" regime to see if there are deviations that current theories of "quantum gravity" or "alternative gravity" (like wavefunction collapse models) might predict.

Methods

The authors propose using a Mach-Zehnder atom interferometer. In this setup, a single atom (like Caesium) is put into a quantum superposition of two different paths, separated by a distance $\Delta x$.

The core innovation is the asymmetric source mass configuration:

  1. Two macroscopic masses ($M_1$ and $M_2$, specifically tungsten balls) are placed near the interferometer arms.
  2. By carefully choosing the masses and their distances ($d_1, d_2$) such that the gravitational force gradients cancel out ($M_1/d_1^2 = M_2/d_2^2$), the "classical" phase shift (the Poisson bracket term in phase space) vanishes.
  3. What remains is the Moyal bracket term—the part of the evolution that is uniquely quantum.

The authors use a phase-space formulation (Wigner functions) to categorize the time evolution. They define a general evolution equation $\dot{W} = \{H, W\} + G_H(W)$, where $\{H, W\}$ is the classical part and $G_H$ represents any non-classical or non-standard gravitational effects.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a theoretical proposal and does not use experimental datasets. However, it references parameters from existing state-of-the-art lattice interferometer experiments (e.g., Ref [27] and [35]) to ensure the proposal is feasible with current technology.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Canceling the Classical: The "aha moment" is realizing that the classical gravitational influence (which usually masks quantum effects) can be engineered to zero. This makes the experiment sensitive to higher-order derivatives of the gravitational potential.
  • Moyal vs. Poisson: In phase space, classical evolution is described by the Poisson bracket. Quantum evolution adds higher-order corrections via the Moyal bracket. This experiment is designed to isolate those specific quantum corrections.
  • Testing Non-Unitarity: The setup is sensitive to models like Tilloy-Diósi (measurement-feedback gravity). Unlike standard quantum mechanics, these models predict that gravity causes "dephasing" (loss of quantum interference) and a modified phase shift, which this experiment could potentially detect.
  • Experimental Feasibility: The authors suggest using a Caesium atom with a 10 cm separation and two tungsten balls (20g and 40g). They calculate a predicted quantum phase shift frequency of $\approx 0.22$ rad/s, which is within the resolution of modern atomic clocks and interferometers.

Key Results

  • Predicted Signal: Under the standard Schrödinger equation, even when the classical force is canceled ($\omega_C = 0$), a quantum phase shift $\omega_Q \approx 0.22$ rad/s should persist.
  • Distinguishing Theories: If the experiment measures a phase shift different from $\omega_Q$, or observes an exponential decay in the interference pattern (fringe contrast), it would provide direct evidence for non-standard gravitational dynamics (like the Tilloy-Diósi model).
  • Scale: The proposed parameters (10 cm arm separation, multi-second coherence times) have already been demonstrated individually in various labs, suggesting the experiment is "within reach."

Limitations and Future Work

  • 1D Approximation: The paper uses a one-dimensional model for simplicity. A real-world experiment would need to account for the 3D geometry of the masses and the atom's trajectory.
  • Noise and Decoherence: While the authors mention that dephasing from gravity might be hard to distinguish from environmental noise (like vibrations or stray magnetic fields), they argue the specific phase shift frequency would still be a reliable signal.
  • Short-Range Forces: At very close distances, Casimir-Polder forces (vacuum fluctuations) could interfere. The authors suggest a 1mm gap between the mass surface and the atom path to mitigate this.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that repeating the experiment with different initial states and interaction times could eventually allow researchers to "map out" the unknown gravitational superoperator $G_H$ entirely.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract In quantum mechanics, the time evolution of particles is given by the Schrödinger equation. It is valid in a nonrelativistic regime where the interactions with the particle can be modelled by a potential and quantised fields are not required. This has been verified in countless experiments when the interaction is of electromagnetic origin, but also corrections due to the quantised field are readily observed. When the interaction is due to gravity, then one cannot expect to see effects of the quantised field in current-technology Earth-bound experiments. However, this does not yet guarantee that in the accessible regime, the time evolution is accurately given by the Schrödinger equation. Here we propose to measure the effects of an asymmetric mass configuration on a quantum particle in an interferometer. For this setup we show that with parameters within experimental reach, one can be sensitive to possible deviations from the Schrödinger equation, beyond the already verified lowest-order regime. Performing this experiment will hence directly test the nonclassical behaviour of a quantum particle in the gravitational field.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{plavala2025probing,
  author = {Martin Plávala and Stefan Nimmrichter and Matthias Kleinmann},
  title = {{Probing the nonclassical dynamics of a quantum particle in a gravitational field}},
  booktitle = {Classical},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1088/1361-6382/ae1b5c},
}

Loading related content...

Figure