Probabilistic XML via Markov Chains

Michael Benedikt, Evgeny Kharlamov, Dan Olteanu, Pierre Senellart

TL;DR

This paper introduces Recursive Markov Chains (RMCs) as a powerful new formalism for modeling probabilistic XML data. RMCs offer greater expressiveness and succinctness than existing methods, allowing for deeper and wider documents and more nuanced probability distributions, while still retaining tractability for certain queries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

XML is the de facto standard for data on the web, but real-world XML data is often uncertain. This uncertainty can arise from various sources like unreliable data feeds, errors in information extraction, or imprecision in data integration. While existing approaches to probabilistic XML (PrXML) have made progress, they often struggle with representing complex structures (deep and wide documents) or are limited to finite probability spaces. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a more flexible and expressive model that can handle these limitations while maintaining query evaluation tractability.

Methods

The core contribution is the adaptation of Recursive Markov Chains (RMCs) to model probabilistic XML. RMCs are an extension of standard Markov chains that incorporate a notion of subroutines, allowing for a natural hierarchical structure interpretable as nested words or trees. The authors explore various restrictions of RMCs to achieve tractability for query evaluation, particularly for Monadic Second-Order logic (MSO) queries.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • RMC Formalism: Defining RMCs with components, boxes, and transition relations that allow for recursive calls and probabilistic choices.
  • Mapping to XML: Showing how RMCs can generate probabilistic distributions over XML documents.
  • Tractable Fragments: Identifying specific restrictions of RMCs, such as Hierarchical Markov Chains (HMC) and Tree-like Markov Chains (TLMC), that guarantee tractability for certain query languages.
  • Expressiveness and Succinctness Analysis: Comparing RMC subclasses and existing PrXML models in terms of their ability to represent different types of probabilistic XML data and their representation size.
  • Query Evaluation Algorithms: Developing algorithms for evaluating queries (e.g., tree-pattern queries, XPath, MSO) over these probabilistic models, analyzing their complexity (data and combined).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RMCs as a Unified Framework: RMCs provide a more general and expressive framework that subsumes many existing probabilistic XML models, offering a unified perspective.
  • Beyond Finite and Shallow: RMCs break free from the limitations of finite probability spaces and shallow document structures inherent in many previous PrXML models.
  • Tractability Trade-offs: The paper meticulously maps out the trade-offs between expressiveness, succinctness, and query evaluation tractability by introducing and analyzing various RMC restrictions.
  • Hierarchical and Tree-like RMCs: These specific RMC subclasses are crucial for achieving tractability, offering a balance between expressiveness and computational feasibility.
  • Connecting to Existing Tools: By leveraging RMCs, the work connects probabilistic XML modeling to the rich body of tools and techniques developed for Markov models and automata theory.

Key Results

  • Expressiveness and Succinctness: RMCs are shown to be more expressive and succinct than existing PrXML models, capable of representing deeper and wider documents and more complex probability distributions.
  • Tractable Models: Hierarchical Markov Chains (HMC) are shown to be ra-tractable (tractable under fixed-cost rational arithmetic) for MSO queries, while Tree-like Markov Chains (TLMC) are fully tractable for MSO queries under standard bit-cost arithmetic.
  • Complexity Analysis: The paper provides a detailed analysis of query evaluation complexity for various RMC subclasses and query languages, ranging from FP#P for tree-pattern queries to PSPACE and beyond for MSO.
  • Relationship to SCFGs: RMCs are shown to have a close relationship with Stochastic Context-Free Grammars (SCFGs), a widely used model in natural language processing.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Unrestricted RMC Tractability: While RMCs are powerful, computing probabilities for unrestricted RMCs is as hard as the square-root sum problem, requiring significant breakthroughs for general query evaluation.
  • Open Questions: The paper highlights open questions regarding efficient translations between certain model classes, such as whether PrXMLexp can be efficiently translated into PrXMLmux,det or TLMC.
  • Practical Applications: While the paper lays a strong theoretical foundation, further research is needed to explore the practical application of these models in real-world scenarios, particularly in learning these probabilistic models from data.
  • More Expressive Query Languages: Investigating the tractability of even more expressive query languages over these RMC-based models remains an area for future work.

Summary updated

Abstract

We show how Recursive Markov Chains (RMCs) and their restrictions can define probabilistic distributions over XML documents, and study tractability of querying over such models. We show that RMCs subsume several existing probabilistic XML models. In contrast to the latter, RMC models (i) capture probabilistic versions of XML schema languages such as DTDs, (ii) can be exponentially more succinct, and (iii) do not restrict the domain of probability distributions to be finite. We investigate RMC models for which tractability can be achieved, and identify several tractable fragments that subsume known tractable probabilistic XML models. We then look at the space of models between existing probabilistic XML formalisms and RMCs, giving results on the expressiveness and succinctness of RMC subclasses, both with each other and with prior formalisms. © 2010 VLDB Endowment.
BibTeX
@article{benedikt2010probabilistic,
  author = {Michael Benedikt and Evgeny Kharlamov and Dan Olteanu and Pierre Senellart},
  title = {{Probabilistic XML via Markov Chains}},
  journal = {Proc. VLDB Endow.},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.14778/1920841.1920939},
}
Figure