Abstract
Objectives: To study the prevalence of hyperacusis in the general population and the special population, and to determine the effect of population differences on hyperacusis. Methods: The two authors followed a scoping review methodology and screened nearly 30 years of English literature in Pubmed, Web of Science, OVID, and EBSCO. Then, the extracted results of each study were discussed in groups and subgroups. Results: The authors selected 42 pieces of scientific literature that met the requirements, studying a total of 34,796 subjects, including the general population (28,425 subjects), the special occupation population (2,746 subjects), and the patients with concomitant diseases (5,093 subjects). The prevalence was 0.2–17.2% in the general population, 3.8–67% in the special occupation population, and 4.7–95% in the patients with special diseases. It was found that in the general population, the high prevalence occurs in adolescents and older adults. The prevalence of hyperacusis in women is significantly higher than in men. In people with hearing disorders, the prevalence of hyperacusis is significantly higher than in people with normal hearing. Various diseases (such as Williams syndrome, tinnitus, and autism), as well as various occupations (musicians, music students, teachers, and others), have been found to be high risk factors for hyperacusis. Conclusion: The high prevalence of hyperacusis and the large differences between reported prevalence in different studies deserves our great attention. Additionally, in order to increase the comparability of the studies, a standardized set of criteria are needed to study the prevalence of hyperacusis.
Introduction
While most people find a jackhammer annoying, individuals with hyperacusis find ordinary sounds—like a running faucet or a ringing phone—to be uncomfortably loud, frightening, or even physically painful. Despite its significant impact on quality of life, hyperacusis research has historically been fragmented.
This scoping review addresses a critical gap in audiology: the lack of a clear, unified understanding of how common this condition actually is. Because researchers use different definitions, questionnaires, and decibel thresholds to diagnose hyperacusis, comparing studies is often difficult. This paper synthesizes disparate findings to identify high-risk groups and explain the variance in reported prevalence.
Methodology
The authors conducted a scoping review following the Arksey and O’Malley framework, designed to map the breadth of a research field. They screened nearly 30 years of English-language literature (1990–2020) across major databases including PubMed, Web of Science, OVID, and EBSCO.
Out of 759 initial results, 42 studies were selected that specifically provided prevalence data. These were categorized into three groups: the general population, special occupations (e.g., musicians, teachers), and clinical populations with concomitant diseases (e.g., tinnitus, autism, Williams syndrome).
Geographic Distribution and Datasets
The review aggregated data from 42 scientific papers representing a total of 34,796 subjects. The dataset included 28,425 subjects from the general population, 2,746 from special occupations, and 5,093 from clinical populations.
As shown in Figure 2, the geographic distribution was heavily skewed toward Western nations, with Sweden, the USA, and the UK contributing the most literature. This suggests a potential geographic and language bias in the current body of research.
Key Insights and Results
Prevalence Rates
The prevalence rates found were highly dependent on the group being studied:
- General Population: 0.2% to 17.2%.
- Special Occupations: 3.8% to 67% (with musicians often at the higher end).
- Clinical Populations: 4.7% to 95%. Williams Syndrome reported the highest prevalence (up to 95%), while tinnitus patients reached up to 63%.
Demographic and Clinical Trends
- The "U-Shaped" Age Distribution: In the general population, hyperacusis peaks in adolescents and older adults. This may be due to the declining function of the medial olivocochlear efferent system with age.
- The Gender Gap: Across most studies, women report significantly higher rates of hyperacusis than men.
- The Tinnitus Connection: There is a powerful link between tinnitus and hyperacusis. Hyperacusis may be a precursor to tinnitus, potentially driven by "central gain," where the brain increases internal volume to compensate for a lack of external input.
- Occupational Hazards: Musicians and teachers are at high risk, likely due to prolonged exposure to complex, high-frequency, or unpredictable noise environments.
Discussion and Future Directions
The most striking insight is the lack of consistency in diagnostic criteria. Some studies define hyperacusis via a single "yes/no" question, while others use Loudness Discomfort Levels (LDLs) with thresholds ranging from 70 dB to 90 dB. These "large differences" in reported prevalence are likely artifacts of different diagnostic criteria rather than true biological variance.
To move the field forward, the authors advocate for a standardized set of criteria to make future studies comparable. This should ideally combine objective audiological exams (like pure tone audiometry and LDLs) with validated questionnaires to create a more robust, multi-dimensional diagnostic tool.
Summary updated