The impact of occupational exposures on chronic rhinosinusitis: a scoping review

Aurelia S. Monk, Cameron P. Worden, Ezer H. Benaim, Cristine Klatt‐Cromwell, Brian D. Thorp, Charles S. Ebert, Brent A. Senior, Adam J. Kimple2024 · DOI

Abstract

Chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) is a prevalent and burdensome condition worldwide, characterized by inflammation of the paranasal sinuses. Ideally, instead of treating CRS, we would identify ways to prevent the development of this chronic condition. Occupational exposures may be an excellent target for prevention. Occupational exposures have been shown to play a critical role in the pathogenesis of multiple lower airway diseases, such as asthma, silicosis, asbestosis, and hypersensitivity pneumonitis. However, evidence for the association between occupational exposures and the development of upper airway disease, like CRS, is less well-defined. This manuscript examines the association between occupational exposures and CRS. A scoping review of the literature following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines identified 19 relevant studies. The populations examined and the methods and criteria used for defining CRS diagnosis and occupational variables significantly varied between the studies. Diagnosis of CRS was most often determined by self-reported symptoms or medical record review. Occupational variables ranged from employment status to occupation type to specific exogenous compounds encountered. Overall, substantial evidence demonstrates a general association between occupational exposures and CRS diagnosis; however, limitations in study methodologies, including variations in CRS diagnostic criteria, occupational exposures, assessment methods, and populations, hinder drawing more specific conclusions. Moving forward, rigorous research methodologies and standardized criteria are essential to draw conclusions supported by multiple studies. Critical components of future studies should include large, diverse populations, use of consensus CRS diagnostic criteria, and inclusion of many specific and quantitatively defined exposures. Ultimately, such efforts can help inform preventative measures and interventions for CRS, thus mitigating the burden of CRS on individuals and populations worldwide.

Introduction

Chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) is a significant global health issue, affecting approximately 5–10% of the population. It results in billions of dollars in healthcare costs and lost productivity annually. While the link between occupational pollutants and lower airway diseases—such as asthma and silicosis—is well-established, the impact on the upper airway is less understood. As the nose and sinuses are the primary entry points for inhaled hazards, identifying specific occupational triggers is crucial for shifting from chronic management to primary prevention.

Methods

This study employed a scoping review methodology following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Researchers queried PubMed, EMBASE, and Scopus, initially identifying 1,189 records. After removing duplicates and screening for eligibility based on CRS diagnostic criteria and occupational variables, 19 studies were selected for final analysis.

PRISMA flow diagram showing the identification, screening, and inclusion process for the scoping review.

Study Characteristics

The 19 included studies represented a wide array of populations and methodologies. These ranged from large-scale general population cohorts in South Korea, Denmark, Norway, and the Netherlands to high-risk groups such as World Trade Center (WTC) first responders and military veterans. The diversity in how CRS was defined and how occupational variables were measured is a hallmark of the current literature.

Characteristics of included studies, detailing study types, sample sizes, and occupational measurement methods.

Key Insights and Results

The review highlights several critical findings regarding the relationship between the workplace and sinus health:

  • Specific Exposures vs. Broad Categories: Studies focusing on broad employment status often failed to find a link. In contrast, research targeting specific compounds revealed significant associations. For instance, exposure to carpets (OR 3.76), damp/moldy environments (OR 2.37), poisonous gas (OR 1.77), and paper dust (OR 1.3) were all linked to increased CRS risk.
  • High-Intensity Environments: The strongest evidence for occupational CRS comes from disaster response and military contexts. WTC responders exhibited a 42–50% prevalence/incidence of CRS. Similarly, 55% of veterans exposed to sulfur mustard were diagnosed with the condition.
  • Biological Mechanisms: Particulate matter (PM) does more than physically irritate the nasal passage; it triggers pro-inflammatory cytokines (IL-6, IL-8) and disrupts the mucosal barrier's tight junctions.
  • Treatment Resistance: Occupational exposure is associated with increased disease severity, leading to higher rates of revision endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS) and a greater need for systemic steroids.

Limitations and Future Directions

A major challenge in current research is heterogeneity. Only 52% of the reviewed studies utilized objective diagnostic criteria like endoscopy or CT scans, with many relying on self-reported symptoms. Furthermore, exposure assessments were often subjective rather than quantitative.

To advance the field, future research must prioritize longitudinal designs, consensus diagnostic criteria (combining symptoms with objective findings), and standardized, quantitative exposure metrics. Establishing these standards is the first step toward developing industry-specific screening and prevention guidelines to catch CRS early in high-risk industries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) is a prevalent and burdensome condition worldwide, characterized by inflammation of the paranasal sinuses. Ideally, instead of treating CRS, we would identify ways to prevent the development of this chronic condition. Occupational exposures may be an excellent target for prevention. Occupational exposures have been shown to play a critical role in the pathogenesis of multiple lower airway diseases, such as asthma, silicosis, asbestosis, and hypersensitivity pneumonitis. However, evidence for the association between occupational exposures and the development of upper airway disease, like CRS, is less well-defined. This manuscript examines the association between occupational exposures and CRS. A scoping review of the literature following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines identified 19 relevant studies. The populations examined and the methods and criteria used for defining CRS diagnosis and occupational variables significantly varied between the studies. Diagnosis of CRS was most often determined by self-reported symptoms or medical record review. Occupational variables ranged from employment status to occupation type to specific exogenous compounds encountered. Overall, substantial evidence demonstrates a general association between occupational exposures and CRS diagnosis; however, limitations in study methodologies, including variations in CRS diagnostic criteria, occupational exposures, assessment methods, and populations, hinder drawing more specific conclusions. Moving forward, rigorous research methodologies and standardized criteria are essential to draw conclusions supported by multiple studies. Critical components of future studies should include large, diverse populations, use of consensus CRS diagnostic criteria, and inclusion of many specific and quantitatively defined exposures. Ultimately, such efforts can help inform preventative measures and interventions for CRS, thus mitigating the burden of CRS on individuals and populations worldwide.
BibTeX
@misc{monk2024impact,
  author = {Aurelia S. Monk and Cameron P. Worden and Ezer H. Benaim and Cristine Klatt‐Cromwell and Brian D. Thorp and Charles S. Ebert and Brent A. Senior and Adam J. Kimple},
  title = {{The impact of occupational exposures on chronic rhinosinusitis: a scoping review}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.37349/eaa.2024.00046},
}
Figure