Pointwise Lipschitz Continuous Graph Algorithms via Proximal Gradient Analysis

Quanquan C. Liu, Grigoris Velegkas, Yuichi Yoshida, Felix Zhou

Abstract

In many real-world applications, it is prohibitively expensive to drastically change the solution to a problem after a small perturbation in the environment. Therefore, the stability of an algorithm is a very desirable property. In this paper, we study the class of pointwise Lipschitz continuous algorithms as introduced in the recent work of Kumabe and Yoshida [FOCS'23]. The Lipschitz constant of an algorithm, intuitively, bounds the ratio of the changes in its output (measured in $\ell_1$ distance) over the $\ell_1$ perturbations of the weights of the underlying graph. In this work, we give a general and simple framework for bounding the Lipschitz constant of algorithms measured through the unweighted $\ell_1$ distance of their outputs. Our approach consists of three main steps. First, we consider a natural continuous relaxation of the underlying graph problem by adding a smooth and strongly convex regularizer to the objective function. Then, we give upper bounds on the $\ell_1$ distance of the optimal solutions of the convex programs, under small perturbations of the weights, via a stability analysis of the trajectory of the proximal gradient method. Finally, we present new problem-specific rounding techniques to obtain integral solutions to several graph problems that approximately maintain the stability guarantees of the fractional solutions. We apply our framework to a number of problems including minimum $s$-$t$ cut, densest subgraph, maximum $b$-matching, and packing integer programs. To complement our algorithms, we show the tightness of our results for certain problems by establishing tight lower bounds.

Introduction

In real-world systems like traffic routing or financial networks, stability is a critical requirement alongside accuracy. If minor fluctuations in input data—such as a slight change in road congestion—trigger drastic shifts in the output solution, the resulting "jitter" can erode user trust and incur high recourse costs. This paper addresses this challenge by introducing Proximal Gradient Trajectory Analysis (PGTA), a framework for designing "stable" graph algorithms characterized by pointwise Lipschitz continuity. An algorithm is Lipschitz continuous if the distance between its outputs is bounded by a constant times the distance between its inputs.

Methodology: Proximal Gradient Trajectory Analysis

The authors depart from traditional stability analysis, which typically focuses on first-order optimality conditions of the final solution. Instead, PGTA analyzes the path of the optimization process itself.

  1. Iterative Stability: By analyzing the Proximal Gradient Method (PGM), the authors prove that if the individual steps of the optimization are stable and the process converges, the final optimal solution inherits this stability.
  2. Weighted Regularizers: This trajectory-based perspective enables the use of weighted $\ell_2$-regularizers, such as the Laplacian quadratic form. Unlike unweighted regularizers used in previous work, weighted versions naturally align with graph structures but were historically difficult to analyze.
  3. Stable Rounding Schemes: To bridge the gap between continuous optimization and discrete graph problems, the authors developed sophisticated rounding techniques, including the Exponential Mechanism from differential privacy, $k$-Way Submodularity, and Multi-Item Cooperative Auctions for $b$-matching.

Key Results and Insights

The PGTA framework yields significant improvements across several fundamental graph problems. A central insight is the role of algebraic connectivity ($\lambda_2$); well-connected graphs (higher $\lambda_2$) naturally support more stable algorithms.

Minimum S-T Cut

The authors achieved a Lipschitz constant of $O(n/\lambda_2)$ with a $(1+o(1))$ approximation ratio for the Minimum Vertex $S-T$ Cut. As shown in the table below, these results provide both upper and lower bounds for the problem's stability.

Summary of results for Minimum Vertex S-T Cut problems.

Matching and Packing Integer Programs

The framework also improves the state-of-the-art for Bipartite $b$-Matching and generalizes stability guarantees to Packing Integer Programs (PIPs), which encompass problems like knapsack and set packing. The following table highlights the approximation ratios and Lipschitz constants achieved for these domains.

Summary of results for Bipartite Matching and Packing Integer Programs.

Conclusion

This work establishes PGTA as a versatile framework for building stable combinatorial algorithms. While the results for Min-Cut are proven optimal, future work remains to determine the tightness of bounds for $b$-matching and PIPs, and to extend bipartite matching results to general graphs.

Summary updated

Abstract

In many real-world applications, it is prohibitively expensive to drastically change the solution to a problem after a small perturbation in the environment. Therefore, the stability of an algorithm is a very desirable property. In this paper, we study the class of pointwise Lipschitz continuous algorithms as introduced in the recent work of Kumabe and Yoshida [FOCS'23]. The Lipschitz constant of an algorithm, intuitively, bounds the ratio of the changes in its output (measured in $\ell_1$ distance) over the $\ell_1$ perturbations of the weights of the underlying graph. In this work, we give a general and simple framework for bounding the Lipschitz constant of algorithms measured through the unweighted $\ell_1$ distance of their outputs. Our approach consists of three main steps. First, we consider a natural continuous relaxation of the underlying graph problem by adding a smooth and strongly convex regularizer to the objective function. Then, we give upper bounds on the $\ell_1$ distance of the optimal solutions of the convex programs, under small perturbations of the weights, via a stability analysis of the trajectory of the proximal gradient method. Finally, we present new problem-specific rounding techniques to obtain integral solutions to several graph problems that approximately maintain the stability guarantees of the fractional solutions. We apply our framework to a number of problems including minimum $s$-$t$ cut, densest subgraph, maximum $b$-matching, and packing integer programs. To complement our algorithms, we show the tightness of our results for certain problems by establishing tight lower bounds.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2024pointwise,
  author = {Quanquan C. Liu and Grigoris Velegkas and Yuichi Yoshida and Felix Zhou},
  title = {{Pointwise Lipschitz Continuous Graph Algorithms via Proximal Gradient Analysis}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2405.08938},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08938},
}
Figure