Phylogenetically Novel Uncultured Microbial Cells Dominate Earth Microbiomes

Karen G. Lloyd, Andrew D. Steen, Joshua Ladau, Junqi Yin, Lonnie D. Crosby

TL;DR

This paper reveals that phylogenetically novel, uncultured microbes are the dominant life forms in most environments on Earth, with the exception of the human body. By analyzing vast public genomic datasets, the researchers estimate that these "microbial dark matter" represent the majority of microbial cells and likely play crucial, yet unknown, roles in Earth's ecosystems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, microbiologists have known that the vast majority of microbial life on Earth cannot be grown in laboratory cultures. This presents a significant challenge because understanding a microbe's function, metabolism, and ecological role typically relies on studying it in a controlled setting. While the diversity of these uncultured microbes (i.e., the number of different taxonomic groups) has been explored, their abundance – how many cells of these uncultured groups actually exist in various environments – has remained largely unquantified. This gap makes it difficult to assess their true importance to ecosystem processes and to determine if studying cultured microbes provides a representative view of microbial life in situ.

Methods

The researchers tackled this problem by analyzing publicly available 16S rRNA gene sequences from both metagenomic and metatranscriptomic datasets. They specifically focused on comparing these sequences to those from cultured organisms, using phylogenetic similarity as a proxy for novelty.

  • Metagenomic Data: This involves extracting all DNA from an environmental sample, sequencing it, and then computationally assembling it into longer DNA fragments (contigs). 16S rRNA genes within these contigs can then be identified and quantified. This method is less prone to the biases inherent in traditional PCR-based amplification of 16S rRNA genes.
  • Metatranscriptomic Data: This approach analyzes RNA, specifically looking at 16S rRNA transcripts. Since RNA indicates active gene expression, this dataset provides insight into which microbes are metabolically active.
  • Phylogenetic Similarity Analysis: They compared the 16S rRNA gene sequences to a curated database of cultured organisms. Sequences were binned based on their percent identity to the closest cultured relative, creating categories like "cultured species to genus," "uncultured genera to classes," and "uncultured phyla and higher." This allowed them to quantify the proportion of sequences falling into each novelty category across different environments.
  • Read Depth Weighting: For metagenomic data, they used scaffold read depths to provide a more accurate quantification of sequence abundance, accounting for variations in sequencing coverage.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available 16S rRNA gene sequences from:

  • Primer-amplified 16S rRNA gene surveys: These were sourced from the NCBI database and represented a large collection of Sanger-sequenced clone insertions.
  • Metagenomic and Metatranscriptomic datasets: These were obtained from the Joint Genome Institute (JGI) IMG/M database.

The researchers did not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather performed a comprehensive analysis of existing, large-scale public data. Their approach aimed to mitigate the "culture bias" often seen in primer-amplified datasets by emphasizing metagenomic and metatranscriptomic data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Microbial Dark Matter" is Dominant: The most striking insight is that phylogenetically novel, uncultured microbes are not just diverse but are numerically dominant in most Earth environments. This challenges the long-held reliance on cultured organisms as proxies for understanding microbial life.
  • Human Environments are the Exception: Uniquely, human and human-associated environments are heavily dominated by cultured microbes. This suggests that human influence, research focus, or specific host-microbe interactions may favor culturability in these niches.
  • Viability Confirmed by RNA: The higher representation of uncultured groups in metatranscriptomes compared to metagenomes strongly suggests that these novel microbes are not just present but are metabolically active and alive in their environments.
  • Beyond the "Rare Biosphere": The findings indicate that these uncultured microbes are not confined to the "rare biosphere" (organisms present in very low abundance but potentially important under specific conditions) but are instead numerically dominant players.
  • Implications for Ecosystem Function: The sheer abundance of these uncultured lineages implies they likely possess undiscovered physiologies and metabolic capabilities that are critical for ecosystem functions, from nutrient cycling to biogeochemical processes.

Key Results

  • Dominance in Non-Human Environments: In environments like seawater, freshwater, soil, and hydrothermal vents, uncultured genera and phyla accounted for a significant majority of 16S rRNA gene sequences. For example, uncultured genera to classes ranged from 22% to 87%, and uncultured phyla from 0% to 64% across various nonhuman environments.
  • Human Environments are Cultured: In contrast, human and human-associated environments showed a high proportion of cultured genera, ranging from 45% to 97%.
  • Global Cell Estimates: The researchers estimate that uncultured genera could comprise approximately 7.3 x 10^29 cells (81% of all microbial cells), and uncultured phyla could represent 2.2 x 10^29 cells (25% of all microbial cells).
  • Metatranscriptome vs. Metagenome: Uncultured phyla were overrepresented in metatranscriptomes (46% to 84% of sequences) compared to metagenomes, reinforcing their active status.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Relic DNA: The authors acknowledge that their datasets may include some "relic preserved DNA," which could inflate diversity estimates. However, they argue that the consistent findings across many samples and the metatranscriptomic data help mitigate this concern.
  • Culturing Challenges: The study highlights the "great plate count anomaly" and proposes that many uncultured microbes belong to "phylogenetically divergent noncultured cells" (PDNC) whose resistance to cultivation stems from fundamental physiological or ecological requirements, rather than simply being dormant or difficult to grow.
  • Future Culturing Efforts: The paper suggests that novel culturing techniques, informed by genomic insights and potentially incorporating strategies like antibiotic addition or long incubation times, are needed to bring these abundant and functionally important uncultured lineages into the lab.
  • Ecological and Physiological Studies: Future work should focus on understanding the specific roles and physiologies of these uncultured microbes in their respective environments, moving beyond just their abundance. This could involve advanced genomic inference, label incorporation studies, and tracking slow growth in complex communities.

Summary updated

Abstract

To describe a microbe's physiology, including its metabolism, environmental roles, and growth characteristics, it must be grown in a laboratory culture. Unfortunately, many phylogenetically novel groups have never been cultured, so their physiologies have only been inferred from genomics and environmental characteristics. Although the diversity, or number of different taxonomic groups, of uncultured clades has been studied well, their global abundances, or numbers of cells in any given environment, have not been assessed. We quantified the degree of similarity of 16S rRNA gene sequences from diverse environments in publicly available metagenome and metatranscriptome databases, which we show have far less of the culture bias present in primer-amplified 16S rRNA gene surveys, to those of their nearest cultured relatives. Whether normalized to scaffold read depths or not, the highest abundances of metagenomic 16S rRNA gene sequences belong to phylogenetically novel uncultured groups in seawater, freshwater, terrestrial subsurface, soil, hypersaline environments, marine sediment, hot springs, hydrothermal vents, nonhuman hosts, snow, and bioreactors (22% to 87% uncultured genera to classes and 0% to 64% uncultured phyla). The exceptions were human and human-associated environments, which were dominated by cultured genera (45% to 97%). We estimate that uncultured genera and phyla could comprise 7.3 × 10<sup>29</sup> (81%) and 2.2 × 10<sup>29</sup> (25%) of microbial cells, respectively. Uncultured phyla were overrepresented in metatranscriptomes relative to metagenomes (46% to 84% of sequences in a given environment), suggesting that they are viable. Therefore, uncultured microbes, often from deeply phylogenetically divergent groups, dominate nonhuman environments on Earth, and their undiscovered physiologies may matter for Earth systems. <b>IMPORTANCE</b> In the past few decades, it has become apparent that most of the microbial diversity on Earth has never been characterized in laboratory cultures. We show that these unknown microbes, sometimes called "microbial dark matter," are numerically dominant in all major environments on Earth, with the exception of the human body, where most of the microbes have been cultured. We also estimate that about one-quarter of the population of microbial cells on Earth belong to phyla with no cultured relatives, suggesting that these never-before-studied organisms may be important for ecosystem functions. <b>Author Video</b>: An author video summary of this article is available.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lloyd2018phylogenetically,
  author = {Karen G. Lloyd and Andrew D. Steen and Joshua Ladau and Junqi Yin and Lonnie D. Crosby},
  title = {{Phylogenetically Novel Uncultured Microbial Cells Dominate Earth Microbiomes}},
  booktitle = {mSystems},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1128/msystems.00055-18},
}
Figure